Bob Dylan; as good as a singer as Caruso  

whoa....bob dylan is a good singer. i like very muck it..
caruso is good too

Caruso had an amzing voice but, as I don't like opera, I never really listened to him. Although Dylans songs always have meaning just lately I have begun to think he couldn't sing, maybe it's because I'm getting old.

Hi crispeater, I think it depends, if someone was REALLY into opera, they would probably like him better.
I always liked Bob Dylan's voice. He just had his own style. I remember people trying to figure him out :) There are certain songs I like better than others that he has, goes with the way he sings better, I think!:)

Caruso would be as unimpressive singing "Blowin' in the Wind" as Bob Dylan would be performing in "La Traviata".
I have always said of Bob Dylan, he wrote such beautiful melodies and it's a shame he never sang any of them. To some extent that is true, you hear the melody more clearly when a lovely voice, such as Joan Baez, trills it. But what makes Dylan a great singer is not the timbre of his voice, it's the absolute perfect emotional quality of his voice for the songs he wrote. His phrasing and style is unique and delivers his message with more emotion and impact than any technically perfect,trained voice could.

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.

dude get over yourself...dylan was good for ticking off the media,back then the government did everything they could to kill the movement..!

dylan was like a sore thumb to the american/british establishment.

he and many others..i might say..he could care less about carouso..!

you need to get out more..!

I love Dylan`s voice but most people I know get irratated by it.It is all a matter of what you like I guess.I never really thought of Dylan as a good singer,but I like his voice.

I'm a huge bob dylan fan. I first saw him on hampton beach back in 1966 or 67 before he hit it big on the radio. His voice is one that you either love or hate but his gift of words is one that can not be denied. Oh and to answer your question...'who is caruso?

No. Caruso is a better singer ,but Bob Dylan has his own sound.Have you noticed that some great song writers can't sing at all?At least Dylan can sing but he isn't better than Caruso.

I like bob dylan the best. He is a great singer I used to listen to all his music all the time.