sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

I saw an ad for a 500. giftcard for walmar today ......  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 85/100. oneandonemakesix (23975) 5 years ago

Ok here's the deal the person had a 500.00 gift card, and she had 5 auctions, only 1 auction winner would get the gift card, and the others would get a 'prize of cents on up to 20.00.

The way the auction was worded was that you were bidding on an ENVELOPE, that was numbered 1-5, and only one of the auctions had teh actual gift card, no amounts were the same, and all amounts outside of the gift card were a mystery.

Do you think people should be allowed to run auctions like this, because while they do not call it a lottery or a sweepstakes that's basically what you are winning, the money if you don't get the gift card is deposited in your PayPal account, and you don't even get a tangible envelope with the money in it.

In order to win the gift card you would have to bid on all 5 auctions and win them all.

So are aucitons like this right?

Mooch

 

ebay.com
sponsors
eBay ® - Official Site
Great deals for you on eBay!
www.eBay.com/eBay_Deals

Win a Gift Card
Enter to win a $1,500 giftcard to any store.
GiftCard-Sweepstakes.com

Auction Classifieds Free
Buy Sell 100% Free
BargAbid.org

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  ebay, bidding on an evelope, gamble auctions, giftcard, scam auctions
 
1. myLot reputation of 97/100. tyc415 (4490)   ranked 1,151 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

I know that I would not bid on an auction like that. I would not win anything and possibly no one would be a winner except who was running the auction. So, with that said I don't think this should be legal.

eBay ® - Official Site Great deals for you on eBay!  www.eBay.com/eBay_Deals
 
2. myLot reputation of 96/100. luvstochat (6696)   ranked 60 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

I don't think that auctions like that are right but alot of people have them I never bid on them I always wonder how do you know if someone acutally wins something or if they are just scamming everyone.
I never bid on those type of auctions.

Win a Gift Card Enter to win a $1,500 giftcard to any store.  GiftCard-Sweepstakes.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 78/100. suspenseful (19613)   ranked 415 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

No one can win all five auctions, so I doubt that this is legal. You would have to ask the Better Bureau about it or go on the net and look for scams --Walmart giftcard scams in particular and see if it is. It does sound like that millionaire on Tv, but the money goes to your Paypal account so if you see it, you have won, but it also could be a way of getting you Paypal id so they can rip you off. I would check to see if it is a scam.

Auction Classifieds Free Buy Sell 100% Free  BargAbid.org
 
4. myLot reputation of 97/100. theproperator (2141)   ranked 64 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

Dodgy, very dodgy. I think you are right, that sort of auction should be banned from ebay. It's not really an auction at all, and no way to guarentee that it isn't rigged. Heck, they could just be having a friend run up the the bids and then the freind is the one that "wins" the giftcard auction and they give a few bucks to the other 4 winners a few bucks to make it all kosher in ebay's eyes (if they allow this kind of thing in the first place).


myLot reputation of 75/100. fit4lifein07 (623)   ranked 224 out of 1,621 in ebay.com  5 years ago

Yep I agree alot of people have mystery envelope auctions and put its not a gamble that whatever is in it is their gift to you, I don't think ebay should have that I've done it a couple times because I love to gamble LoL plus I figured what the heck right, I got way less than what I paid for, no more mystery auctions for me unless I am positive I will get something out of it

about ebay Get Access, Sign-up and Login  sign-in.at
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. drannhh (9927)   ranked 257 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

I have seen those auctions, too, and no, I do not think they should be allowed. They can dance around the terms all they want, but in my view it is simply a form of unregulated gambling, and we all know what unregulated means. I suppose that some people bid on empty envelopes, but I surely never would do that.

eBid Over 5,000,000 auctions and growing. Why pay to list your auctions?  eBid.net
 
6. HellaBass (86)   ranked 770 out of 1,621 in ebay.com   5 years ago

right or wrong, I am not sure, but definitely creative...

Ebay Coupons Get up to 75% off in your area today. Claim your free coupons here.  CouponsCastle.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 100/100. terri0824 (3607)   5 years ago

This doesn't sound like something that should be allowed to be done. Especially if your not actually going to get a Walmart gift card, but money in your pay pal account. Something smells fishy about this one.

Bid Online Cheap Auctions Up To 90% Off Retail Auctions On Electronics, Games, Toys & More  bidcactusonline.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 99/100. whittby (2039)   5 years ago

What was her feedback total? How could someone do this on Ebay without being tossed out eventually? I love Ebay, but it's getting so big, they can't watchdog all their auctions like they used to.

Ask Tech Support Now 31 Technicians Online Now Answer Your Questions In Minutes.  eAnswer.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)   5 years ago

Since I know your an active e-bayer, I'm assuming the auction in question is at ebay which would surprise me cause I didn't think e-bay allowed this type of auction on their site. I sure wouldn't bet on something like this. Just too full of loopholes.

Giftcard Save up to 90% Off Giftcard. Low Prices, Free Shipping  OutletFactoryStore.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 99/100. blackbriar (6633)   5 years ago

Not sure if I responded to this or not already so will again just in case.

I don't think an auction like this is right. I sure wouldn't place a bid on an envelope.

Larry Burke Truth Here is the shocking info about this Guru  popularhomebasedbusinesses.com
 
sponsors
about ebay
Get Access, Sign-up and Login
sign-in.at

eBid
Over 5,000,000 auctions and growing. Why pay to list your auctions?
eBid.net

Ebay Coupons
Get up to 75% off in your area today. Claim your free coupons here.
CouponsCastle.com

similar discussions
How I made $1,000 in a month
A little more than a month ago my husband's hours were cut at work, so I started a discussion...
$36 Jacket. Is it worth it? =P
I was browsing ebay.com and I found this Fred Perry jacket. My boyfriend have been looking for this...
ebay shopping
So I just started shopping on ebay, mostly for Christmas gifts. Every transaction that I have made...
How to upload the pictures on the spec.page on Ebay website?
Hi,friends,recently I found a lot of Ebay-sellers are uploading pictures on the Spec. of the ebay...
What have you had the most luck with on eBay?
About a month and a half ago I decided to put up this North Face jacket I got from the thrift store...
tring to make money by selling american ginseng in china
After the Spring festival break,I come upon an idea,that is to sell genuine american ginseng in...
Ecrater
I'm trying to find a site where I can list my crafts and sell without using Etsy or E-bay. Etsy is...
Civet Coffee
I have around 5 kgs of civet coffee with me. Civet Coffee is considered to be worlds costliest...
If you sell on Ebay do you claim it on your taxes?
If you do, how do you do it?
Ebay Bidding
Friends. I am curious. Why do some sellers put their stuff on ebay for bidding? Is it because these...
sponsors
about ebay
Get Access, Sign-up and Login
sign-in.at
eBid
Over 5,000,000 auctions and growing. Why pay to list your auctions?
eBid.net
Ebay Coupons
Get up to 75% off in your area today. Claim your free coupons here.
CouponsCastle.com
Bid Online Cheap Auctions
Up To 90% Off Retail Auctions On Electronics, Games, Toys & More
bidcactusonline.com
Ask Tech Support Now
31 Technicians Online Now Answer Your Questions In Minutes.
eAnswer.com
Giftcard
Save up to 90% Off Giftcard. Low Prices, Free Shipping
OutletFactoryStore.com
Larry Burke Truth
Here is the shocking info about this Guru
popularhomebasedbusinesses.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.