sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Is the U.S./Canada Civil Assistance Plan Constitutional? Is it even legal? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 59/100. ParaTed2k (4586)   ranked 406 out of 6,335 in politics2 years ago

"U.S. Air Force Gen. Gene Renuart, commander of North American Aerospace Defense Command and U.S. Northern Command, and Canadian Air Force Lt.-Gen. Marc Dumais, commander of Canada Command, have signed a Civil Assistance Plan that allows the military from one nation to support the armed forces of the other nation during a civil emergency."

Article II, Sec. 2 of the U.S. Constitution assigns the authority to make international treaties to the President of the United States, with consent from 2/3 of the Senate.

This agreement was signed between two Generals who are supbordinate to to commanders and their national leaders. The agreement was signed on Feb 14 of this year. It binds the military and civilian federal agencies to aid to the other country in the event of national emergencies.

The Commander of a U.S. Military Command has no authority to bind any federal department to anything.

Is Gen. Dumais working with clandestine authority from Prs. Bush? Will this "treaty" be brought before the U.S. Senate?

If not, they are illegal and unconstitutional.

If so, what does Candian troops on U.S. soil mean when it comes to Posse comitatus laws. Federal Troops can't be used for law enforcement within our borders, but that doesn't include Candadian forces.

This "treaty" raises a lot of questions... Questions that demand answers.





http://www.northcom.mil/News/2008/021408.html

 
 
politics
sponsors
Washington Jeep Dealer
Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer
www.JeepDealer.com

U.S. Air Force Rings
Buy a Air Force ring direct from the factory and Save up to 50% OFF.
www.dunham-mfg.com

Air Force Distance Education
100% Tuition Assistance Available For Post Military Career Training.
www.Education4Military.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  canada, posse comitatus, emergency, disaster, treaty
 
1. myLot reputation of 85/100. NeoComp (1431)   ranked 67 out of 6,335 in politics   2 years ago


Very interesting info.

I would think they would have to take this before the Senate. I had not hear about this. sometimes It's hard to keep up with all the news out there.

Washington Jeep Dealer Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Jeep Dealer www.JeepDealer.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 49/100. Destiny007 (4538)   ranked 603 out of 6,335 in politics   2 years ago

While this article talks about floods and such other natural disasters, and also mentioned terrorist attacks, there is one other scenario that's pops into my mind, and that would be in case martial law is declared.

There was a similar plan being considered during the Clinton Administration, and I am going to have to try to locate the information on that.

This has a really bad smell to it.

As to whether it is Constitutional, I seriously doubt it.

Congress is trying to ban as many guns as possible, a lot of people have no idea what the 2nd Amendment is all about... most of them seem to think it had something to do with hunting... and now this.

It would be hard enough to defend against the forces of our own government, and now it seems we would have to contend with the combined forces of two governments if it came down to that.

Actually, I am positive that the Constitution and the Bill of Rights never intended for this type of thing to happen.

I think we are being set up.

U.S. Air Force Rings Buy a Air Force ring direct from the factory and Save up to 50% OFF. www.dunham-mfg.com
 
sponsors
Washington Nationals Tickets on Sale
Compare Nationals Tickets on sale by multiple vendors.
Travelocity.TicketCommunity.com

washington nationals t-shirts
Shop Washington Nationals Apparel& Gear at the Yahoo! Sports Shop.
YahooSports.TeamFanShop.com

Washington DC AC
Summer's here -- Find local air conditioning dealers& services.
WashingtonDC.YellowPages.com

similar discussions
Online Shopping in Canada
What are the best sites to shop online that deloivers to Canada? Ive used sears.ca, ebay and...
MarineLand Canada
If you are in Canada close to Niagra Falls for vacation, try to stop at Marineland, its a great...
sponsors
Washington Nationals Tickets on Sale
Compare Nationals Tickets on sale by multiple vendors.
Travelocity.TicketCommunity.com
washington nationals t-shirts
Shop Washington Nationals Apparel & Gear at the Yahoo! Sports Shop.
YahooSports.TeamFanShop.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.