sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Surgeon uses drill to do brain surgery on conscious patient email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 85/100. oneandonemakesix (24038)   ranked 1 out of 3,622 in health2 years ago

http://www.foxnews.com/st... don't think I could do this, in fact I KNOW, I couldn't do what this woman did.

>U.K. newspaper the Daily Telegraph reported that Marsh was unable to find a suitable anesthetist — so his patient was only given a local anaesthetic to cope with the pain.

And, when the cordless drill’s battery died, Marsh was forced to finish the operation by hand to save Dolishny’s life, the newspaper said. Marsh said he kept talking to his patient throughout the surgery to make sure he wasn't causing any brain damage. <


The surgery was taped, and will be shown on the BBC on March 30th

Ok first of all I have to know if you could stomach wathcing it? I can't couldn't and won't....so I hope that it is NOT broadcast in the US, I think I'd probably vomit if I saw it.

Would you go through such an operation, and would you trust the doctor to use a cordless drill, something you can buy at any store, and do the job by hand?

How would you feel if no anethesiologist was around and you couldn't be put down? Would you be comfortable with Locoal anesthetic?

This doctor travels twice a year to perform surgery that people can't pay for or afford, even if free could you go through with it?

Mooch

 
 
health
sponsors
Spine Treatment Procedure
Treatment for Back and Neck Pain. Learn More.
www.GWHospital.com/SpineCenter

Spinal Laser Surgery - LSI
Gentle Arthroscopic Laser Surgery! Request A Free Medical Review.
LaserSpineInstitute.com/BackSurgery

Safe, Affordable Lasik Eye Surgery
See clear with FDA approved, safe LASIK. Call for a free evaluation.
www.lasikvisioninstitute.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  brain surgery, surgery, brain surgery on conscious woman, cordless drill, power tools in surgery
 
1. myLot reputation of 74/100. robsbrooklyngirl (3079)   ranked 166 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

Goodness thats crazy. I would never want to be awake for any surgery, nevermind brain surgery.

Spine Treatment Procedure Treatment for Back and Neck Pain. Learn More. www.GWHospital.com/SpineCenter
 
2. myLot reputation of 97/100. tyc415 (4492)   ranked 466 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

I don't know if I would or not, can't say unless I was in the situation and what my odds were if not having the surgery then.
I do know there are certain types of brain surgery where they need to have the patient alert but not sure if that is done with just local anestheisa or what. It does sound scarey to me and I hope I am never in the situation to have to make that decission.

Spinal Laser Surgery - LSI Gentle Arthroscopic Laser Surgery! Request A Free Medical Review. LaserSpineInstitute.com/BackSurgery
 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. TheHairDresser (3366)   ranked 396 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

Hello Mooch
What a brilliant doctor is all I have to say..the fact that he will do this and not standby and let someone die and go there and do surgeries for free is a true doctor and shows his humanity, despite the fact that he had to make due with the tool and no anasthetic for the patient..this is unreal but I do applaud him for his dedication and bravery..the patient must have had great confidence in him, and the poor soul, I hope they made it alright..wow this is really something Mooch. They say it is amazing what pain you can tolerate if you have to though.

Safe, Affordable Lasik Eye Surgery See clear with FDA approved, safe LASIK. Call for a free evaluation. www.lasikvisioninstitute.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 65/100. BCMike (3316)   ranked 92 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

Interestingly, once you get into the brain itself, there are no pain receptors on the brain. So much work is performed on people using thios method.
They use it sometimes on epileptics to control seizures and other involuntary responsed deemed unheathy to the point of severe danger.

plastic surgery surgeon plastic surgery surgeon. Find a Local plastic surgery surgeon Now. www.plasticsurgeryclinicsite.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 80/100. mrpippo (720)   2 years ago

now a days its hard to tell if a surgeon went to medical school or carpentry school,i recently had surgery on my arm and had a steel plate and 6 screws put in my arm,and i remember before they put me to sleep(thank god)for the surgery they had all kinds of tools ie:drills, saws, hammers,etc on a table next to me and i asked the doctor if he could add an addition to my house in his free time, at first he did'nt get what i was saying then he smiled and sure why not .....

Psi-Plastic Surgery Inst Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more Sanfrancisco.Citysearch.com
 
6. oxoxallyoxox (40)   2 years ago

Wow that is so bizarre - I couldnt be awake during an operation in a hospital with a doctor that had proper equipment never mind someone using a cordless drill

Chelsea Eye & Cosmetic Read reviews for this Doctor & find more local Medical Info Newyork.Citysearch.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 97/100. queenofarms (1344)   ranked 90 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

Thats one brave woman. I have to be put to sleep to have a tooth pulled. I can't stand pain. So if theres no anesthetist, then I'll wait until he finds one.

I wouldn't let a doctor use a drill from the hardware store on me.

plastic surgery surgeon Expert advice, articles, tools and more - all about Plastic Surgery. ivillage.waidev5.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 60/100. definitelyarun (185)   2 years ago

That was one amazing incident. and i have to mention the mettle the doctor showed for performing the surgery. i dont know if it was rationale to perform a local anaesthesia for a brain surgery. I am a doctor myself but i have not specialised in surgery. but it is not so horrific in getting a surgery done under local anaesthesia . one common surgery done under local anaesthesia (spinal) is caesarean section. the mother is given a local and surgery is done and once the baby is delivered out the mother is shown the baby. this is very important for the mother which can bring immense relief to her. it is always better than general anaesthesia as general anaesthesia carries great risk in performing surgery and the patient can go into coma or cardiac arrest or shock even if the dose is within normal limits . I have seen people who are given general anaesthesia shedding tears during a surgery. i have asked my seniors the reason . they say that in a general anaesthesia you become paralysed temporarily and if the drug given has low pain killing effect, you actually sense the pain even if you are sedated and paralysed. so it is like hurting the helpless. in local anaesthesia you are aware of everything around you. can hear what the doctors speak, the progress of the surgery, the anaesthetist's enquiry on how you feel or do you have any discomfort or are you feeling any pain etc etc..if you feel a bit of pain the surgery will be stopped temporarily and will only continue after the analgesic of appropriate dose is administered. So in every sense surgery under local anaesthesia is the best. but you cannot demand that your surgery should be done under local anaesthesia because it depends on the patient health status, disease and the operation planned.

Top Ranked Spine Surgeon Dr. Biscup is globally recognized as the expert in spine surgery. BiscupSpineInstitute.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 90/100. Ldyjarhead (5170)   ranked 1,895 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago


Well there's no way I'd do it without a qualified anesthesiologist present, that's for sure.

It's not uncommon to perform brain surgery while the patient is not totally put under, though. There are times they need to know whether what they are doing is interfering with brain function (speech, etc).

A heavy-duty local anesthetic is a given, I would think!

Top Plastic Surgeons Locate Board-Certified Plastic Surgeons. Schedule your visit today. www.1800mySurgeon.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 93/100. carmelanirel (6329)   ranked 34 out of 3,622 in health   2 years ago

Oh wow, I don't think I could have, but it was obviously to save her life, so maybe she wasn't thinking at the time.. I do know that if my husband and daughter found out, they would be interested, and I may try to watch, but can't guarantee I can watch the whole operation..

Compare Textbook Prices: Handbook of Local Anesthesia - Find the Lowest Price. www.BooksPrice.com
 
sponsors
plastic surgery surgeon
plastic surgery surgeon. Find a Local plastic surgery surgeon Now.
www.plasticsurgeryclinicsite.com

Psi-Plastic Surgery Inst
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more
Sanfrancisco.Citysearch.com

Chelsea Eye& Cosmetic
Read reviews for this Doctor& find more local Medical Info
Newyork.Citysearch.com

similar discussions
WHOA..is this for real
i cannot believe this, this guy is having BRAIN SURGERY while playing a banjo......NO WAY.....you...
brain tumours now there may be other options besides therapy
right now, only surgery seems to be the option used to treat brain tumours and only complete...
Procedure
As many of my circle of friends on mylot know, I write a devotion, that I post on mylot. I also...
Little League star has brain surgery
Kyle Carter's emergency operation to replace childhood shunt a success BY MARK RICE Staff...
sponsors
plastic surgery surgeon
plastic surgery surgeon. Find a Local plastic surgery surgeon Now.
www.plasticsurgeryclinicsite.com
Psi-Plastic Surgery Inst
Read reviews for this business wit directions, offers and more
Sanfrancisco.Citysearch.com
Chelsea Eye & Cosmetic
Read reviews for this Doctor & find more local Medical Info
Newyork.Citysearch.com
plastic surgery surgeon
Expert advice, articles, tools and more - all about Plastic Surgery.
ivillage.waidev5.com
Top Ranked Spine Surgeon
Dr. Biscup is globally recognized as the expert in spine surgery.
BiscupSpineInstitute.com
Top Plastic Surgeons
Locate Board-Certified Plastic Surgeons. Schedule your visit today.
www.1800mySurgeon.com
Compare Textbook Prices:
Handbook of Local Anesthesia - Find the Lowest Price.
www.BooksPrice.com
Local Insurance Agents
Find local insurance agencies in Washington DC at YellowPages.com ®.
Www.YellowPages.com/WashingtonDC
Plastic Surgery
Cosmetic Plastic Surgery, Learn About Qualified Surgeons, Clinics.
plasticsurgery.infosearcher.org
Varicose Vein Surgery - Mclean, VA
Minimally Invasive Alternative to Vein Surgery at McLean Vein Center.
DC.Vein-Treatment.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.