sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

You Are Invited To A Good Hanging at 1900 Hours email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people6 months ago

When the guillotine was used to execute prisoners, there used to be a big gathering of people, it was good entertainment in those days

'Off with their heads'

Old grannies would actually go and take their knitting and sit and have ringside seats to watch someone having their head cut off by the dreaded Guillotine!

Would this be entertainment to you? If there were no computers, no cinema, no tv, no radio, no social clubs, would you go along to watch someone getting hung or getting guillotined?

Would you enjoy it if the person who was being hanged had violated you or your family

Could you ever watch an execution if the person had committed a terrible terrible crime?

 
 
people
sponsors
No Time for School? Graduate Online
Get a Degree in as Few as 2 Yrs- Graduate Faster with Online Classes.
www.ClassesUSA.com

See Today's Mortgage Rates
Calculate Your New Mortgage Payment. See Rates- No Credit Check Req.
www.LowerMyBills.com

Online Degrees
Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now.
www.NexTag.com

sparkofinsanity (1872) response was accepted on 4/7/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  hanging, execution, executions, death penalty, justice
 
1. myLot reputation of 80/100. rintintin (2348)   ranked 4,518 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

Im not a fan of the death penalty.
But you have a way with words

Old grannies would actually go and take their knitting and sit and have ringside seats to watch someone having their head cut off by the dreaded Guillotine!

My Great Grand Mother would have been in her element,lol
By all accounts she was a hard hard woman,or at least thats what my father and grand father told me.

Would this be entertainment to you?

No,I dont think it would be.Im quite squeemish!!!

Would you enjoy it if the person who was being hanged had violated you or your family

Thats a harder question to answer,because I dont think hypothesis and this issue go hand in hand.I might though,despite my reservations and misgivings about the death penalty.

Could you ever watch an execution if the person had committed a terrible terrible crime?

I watched the Saddam one,and I have to say it wasnt good viewing.I felt a bit angry that his fellow Muslims taunted him as he went to his death.


myLot reputation of 93/100. mrslisae (1098)   ranked 762 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Absolutely not...the very thought makes me feel sick:P


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Well I watch gorey films and love Hostel, Saw so I don't think it will be any different and people do watch snuff movies. If someone had violated my family then I would watch for sure.

No Time for School? Graduate Online Get a Degree in as Few as 2 Yrs- Graduate Faster with Online Classes. www.ClassesUSA.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 93/100. OreoCookie3 (13344)   ranked 315 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

I'm sorry, Wolfie, but I could not find that entertaining; not even if the person was a bad criminal. I just can't watch blood, and gore, nor could I watch a person hang. I would have nightmares forever after that. thumbdown


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

I understand my friend x

See Today's Mortgage Rates Calculate Your New Mortgage Payment. See Rates- No Credit Check Req. www.LowerMyBills.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 84/100. sparkofinsanity (1872)   ranked 3,870 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

Life was much more brutal in those days wolfie and most of the people were there to celebrate that it was someone other than them on the chopping block. Almost a celebration of life rather than a spectacle of death. Interesting anthropology at work there during that time.
Today, I couldn't watch an execution through to completion. If it was the perp of a crime visited on my children or family I know that my emotions would be strong in the 'kill the creep' line, but I couldn't follow through. It would be like a victory for him to have me reduced to his level of violence.


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

But I think the justice system is far too soft, there is no happy medium is there? They either lavish away in a luxury prison or they are electrocuted, middle ground is needed between the two x


myLot reputation of 84/100. sparkofinsanity (1872)   ranked 3,870 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Good point wolfie. But then these days prisoners have so many civil rights that to find a middle ground for punishment would take years and years and cost way too much. I remember some time ago the son of a friend of mine was complaining about how difficult his life was and how hard it was to make a living. The general consensus was, "Get arrested. The government will take real good care of you". Sad huh?


myLot reputation of 84/100. sparkofinsanity (1872)   ranked 3,870 out of 25,855 in people  5 months ago

Well chop my head off! I got best response! Thanks wolfie and glad to see you kept your head through this discussion! LOL

Online Degrees Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now. www.NexTag.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 96/100. mssnow (3185)   ranked 338 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

OK Wolfie, thats kinda morbid and gross. I don't even like killing bugs. I hate to see blood and I would not like to see parts of bodies being chopped off. I had read some where that a man who was doomed to have his head cut off told his friends that if he could he would blink his eyes to show them he was still alive after his head was cut off. He had heard a person is still alive for about a minute or so after wards. His head was cut and everyone watched him blink his eyes a few times. So no I would not go watch someone suffer even if only for a few minutes.

I still wuv you, Wolfie even if it was a morbid discussion.lol xxxx


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Well you know me, Mr Weirdy Wolfie;0) Fanks for wuvving me still princess x

 
5. myLot reputation of 98/100. nannacroc (1649)   ranked 181 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

I wouldn't want to watch any sort of execution. However bad the crime it's still murder to take a life.
Judging by some things posted on You Tube, ( I've only seen what the tv showed), there are many young people who would thoroughly enjoy this sort of thing.

 
6. myLot reputation of 66/100. visitorinvasion (3453)   ranked 2,179 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

I never did understand why anyone would want to see such a thing in real life or why in God's name they would take their children to witness such brutality.

Sure, I joke about "off with their heads" and stuff like that, but to actually be an eye witness to something that horrible is disgusting.

Now, could I watch an execution?
Sure, if the guy killed my mom or something without a shadow of a doubt. In fact, the guy better pray the law gets to him before I do in such a case.
Other than something along that line, no, I don't care to witness an execution.


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

I think just ten minutes alone with the person would be enough, rather than moddlecoddling him in prison like they do nowadays, it's too easy to be a criminal in today's society

 
7. myLot reputation of 92/100. dumblnddzzy (8832)   ranked 140 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

I don't have the stomach for that sort of thing wolfie. It would totally gross me out. And NO I couldn't watch even if they had done something to my family. I say an eye for an eye but I couldn't watch it being done..Lori


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Don't worry you can hide in my fur when it happens xxx


myLot reputation of 92/100. dumblnddzzy (8832)   ranked 140 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

Thanks I knew I could count on you to protect me!! XXXXXLori

 
8. myLot reputation of 89/100. uath13 (2436)   ranked 2,792 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

Guillotines are too complicated. I've got an axe.... wink. I'm just not into specator sports, I like to participate.


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

You are definitely invited then as the main executioner! Have axe will chop! LOL!


myLot reputation of 89/100. uath13 (2436)   ranked 2,792 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

I was tempted to say that, but then someone would want me to cut them some firewood so I didn't. lol

 
9. myLot reputation of 97/100. nelly5 (703)   ranked 792 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

No, oh no, this would not be intertainment to me..ugh. I could not even imagine watching something like that. Even if someone committed a terrible crime against my family, I still could not watch this happen to that person....and even if I did, it wouldn't make what they did to my family go away or better. I too, am not a big fan of the death penalty so of course this wouldn't be something I would be interested in watching. Wow, I can't believe the the old grannies would take their knitting occupy them while they sat there waiting for this to happen, yuck.

Thanks for sharing Wolfie=)


myLot reputation of 99/100. wolfie34 (10676)   ranked 36 out of 25,855 in people  6 months ago

I won't be taking my knitting with me either LOL!

 
10. myLot reputation of 96/100. pumpkinjam (2463)   ranked 239 out of 25,855 in people   6 months ago

I don't think I could stand to watch that, no matter who the person was or what they had done. Weird though considering I love hospital dramas on the telly! Well, I don't think there has been a head-chopping on any of them - yet!
If there were no tv, computers, etc. I'd probably find plenty of other things to do. You never know, my house might even get tidied occassionally!

 
similar discussions
Are you just one of the guys or are you a real girly girl????
Guys this ones for you as well. I have to say I am a little of both. But I definitely hang with...
should hangin be the death penalty?
if hangin was used for the death penalty do you think there would be less crime? i know a lot of...
General Hospital, Today's Gripe!
Dont tell me Jason wont be able to work again, seem his hands are in bad shape, possible nerve...
saddam hussain
do you think hanging saddam husain was justified?
death penality, hanging
Many countries still practicing death penality as hanging, electical chairs or gaz rooms! some...
hanging to death is the ultimate justice.
do you support this??
Hanging~~Facts & Myths!!!!
There are four methods of performing a judicial hanging::(1) the short drop, (2)suspension...
Hanging Clothes out to Dry
I am about to hang a couple of loads of clothes and linens out to dry. Although this is a great way...
is saddam hanging is justified?
is saddam hussain hanging is justified, one thoery saya he would have not hanged, other says he...
Posters Hanging In your Room??
My walls have been somewhat bare for sometime, but i bought a rather large poster today at tower...