sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

What did they do for water? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 91/100. positiveminded1977 (2818)   ranked 1 out of 179 in religion5 months ago

I am referring to the Genesis again, and to the story of Joseph in Egypt. Pharoah was so pleased with Joseph because of his ability to interpret dreams, and he gave Joseph a high position. During the seven years of plenty, Joseph collected from the Egyptian citizens a fifth of their produce and stored it in gigantic granaries. Then came seven years of famine, and he sold the same grain to the Egyptians and to the people of surrounding regions. Right now, let us not worry about the hardheartedness of Joseph to SELL food to the suffering Egyptians (when he had collected the same grain from them without paying for it) Later, when their money was over, he took their land, and finally made them slaves. I guess this was ok for Joseph to do because he was a Biblical hero and a believer of God. Anyway, let us not worry about moral issues right now.

The burning question is this. Seven years of famine means all the rivers, lakes, and so on dry up. What did they do for water? There is no mention made of water at all!! Has anybody thought about this? Has any explanation been given to this? Or do a few verses deal with this problem and have I missed it?

I will be glad to read your views on this.

 
 
religion
sponsors
You Could End World Hunger - For Good
Your gift will have an impact& help poor women defeat hunger.
www.freedomfromhunger.org

GreenMoo (1925) response was accepted on 8/17/2008.
denotes best response.
tags:  water, joseph, egypt, famine, grain
 
1. myLot reputation of 88/100. GreenMoo (1925)   ranked 8 out of 179 in religion   5 months ago

Famine doesn't necessarily mean an absence of water, just of food. The famine could have been caused by disease or pests destroying the main food crops, ruination of stored foods, distribution issues or a combination of things. Or of course, by drought. Does this story actually mention that the famine was caused by drought though?


myLot reputation of 91/100. positiveminded1977 (2818)   ranked 1 out of 179 in religion  5 months ago

Hmm, this is a thought. Yup, it could be that. So, there is a difference between "drought" and "famine"? I didn't think of that. Yup, it could be what you say. So, here is one of my Biblical dilemmas solved real fast.:) Nopes, the word "drought" is not mentioned, only famine.

Cheers and happy mylotting.

You Could End World Hunger - For Good Your gift will have an impact & help poor women defeat hunger. www.freedomfromhunger.org
 
2. myLot reputation of 82/100. daffodil1949 (948)   ranked 2 out of 179 in religion   5 months ago

Yeah I to got that doubt. A famine as I understand is caused by the failure of rainfall. It is always acompanied by scarcity of water. Humans and animals die. Then the Govts are not severe with the famine stricken people,the poor get rationed food. BUt the way Joseph was selling food grains frightened me. He amassed wealth. What is it?
WE can say thatthe famine was only of the foodgrains still to grow foodgrains water is required. How did they fail?
Sory I am not answering you for I too want explanation

 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. lordwarwizard (9827)   ranked 92 out of 179 in religion   2 months ago

What has famine to do with drought?

I am not familiar with the story but you mentioned only famine - no food - and not drought.

Whichever, even if it is drought, it just means no rain.

In such times, in those days, I think people try to dig deep to find new source of underground water when their wells dry up. If the rivers are not dried up, those are another source.

Worse, sea water... we know how much of Earth is really sea.


myLot reputation of 91/100. positiveminded1977 (2818)   ranked 1 out of 179 in religion  2 months ago

hehehe the thought never struck me! It was Greenmoo (1st response) who pointed it out.:)

Thanks for the response.:)

 
similar discussions
Is wasting water acceptable?
Starbucks has been accused of wasting water every day. The coffee chain has a policy of leaving...
Do you drink water/soda/milk during your meal or do you wait till you finish
eating? I have the habit of drinking water while eating and I heard that it's not a good thing to...
How many glasses of water you drink a day?
Hi. Nice to meet you all here. Normally we need at least 8 glasses of water a day to maintain our...
Do you drink bottled water? or use a water filter?
I don't like to drink water from the sink faucet. I have used a water pitcher purifier, Brita. I...
Do you take your tea after brushing your teeth?
I have been taking my tea before brushing my teeth once in my life and after I came to know that it...