sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

What if all illegal USA immigrants were sent back?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 94/100. halina23 (1115) 4 years ago

I just saw a rather interesting article on MSN (http://articles.moneycent...) about what would happen to the USA economy if we sent all our illegal immigrants back home. Here's an excerpt: "Home help (21%): Los Angeles would still have its sunshine, but there'd be far fewer helping hands to clean floors, cook dinner and shush the kids. Not to mention in New York, Chicago, Houston, Phoenix and Miami. Some working parents might have to quit their jobs to care for the kids or break the family piggy bank to attract a housekeeper from a neighbor.

Farming (13%): "Agriculture would come to a screeching halt," says Nicole Rothfleisch, executive director of the Imperial County Farm Bureau in Southern California. She says El Centro, the county seat, has the highest unemployment in the state (18%). But farmers can never find enough local help. Pay is $9 an hour, and the summer temperatures can hit 110 degrees. The locals, she says, "want cushy jobs with air conditioning." Economists say many farmers would go broke as billions of dollars' worth of crops lay unpicked. Farms would merge and switch to crops that can be picked mechanically, like round lettuce or oranges used solely for juice.

Food manufacturing (14%): The big meatpacking and poultry-processing plants would slash production, increase wages (now $12 an hour in Texas) and send managers in helicopters to scour the countryside for workers. In 2006, when six plants of meatpacker Swift & Co. were raided for illegal workers, the company began offering $1,500 bonuses to Burmese refugees in Texas for each friend or relative they could recruit.

Construction (12%): If it looks bad now, imagine an economy where homebuilding is really crushed, says Rick Montelongo, owner of a building and remodeling company in San Antonio. "It would be a huge blow," he says. Workers' wages, which make up 30% of the cost of building a home, would have to rise "substantially," he says. That would make it more expensive to build new homes, resulting in even fewer sales for an industry already experiencing a sharp downturn.

Hotels and restaurants (11%): There'd be a triple whammy here. Latino staff and customers would both be lost, while the price of fresh food would be driven up by shortages. Distraught restaurant owners would pin up job ads at colleges, when they weren't up to their elbows in dish soap. The billions of dollars spent annually by illegal immigrants would disappear, bad news for small restaurateurs and fast-food joints. But over time, the industry would adapt. Self-service cafés would pop up. And more restaurants would serve chicken parmesan prepared in a factory and warmed up in a microwave. Yum.

In light of all this loss within the U.S. economy, why are we so against illegal immigrants around here?


 

employee
sponsors
Central AC Estimates
Find Top-Rated A/C Pros in Your Area. Get 4 Free Bids Today!
www.ServiceMagic.com

Ask an Immigration Lawyer
7 Lawyers Are Online. Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
Law.JustAnswer.com/Immigration

Air Conditioning Repair
Affordable Air Conditioning Service& Repair
www.theplumbingdoctoronline.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  agriculture, air conditioning, illegal, immigration, problems with illegal immigrants
 
1. myLot reputation of 79/100. baileycows (3432)   ranked 349 out of 1,609 in employee   4 years ago

Because I think we have learned to use the immigrants to make ourselves more lazy. We do not like it because some receive our benefits and they are not even legal. I think it has more to do with food stamps and stuff like that. Oh and why would you want to go to a country and never learn to speak the language?


myLot reputation of 94/100. halina23 (1115)  4 years ago

Actually, most immigrants do pick up English, and speak it quite well. But yes, I think we have gotten lazy and rely on cheap services for too much. It's the same argument that slavery got a few years ago- would the South have become as wealthy as it did, had Africans not been brought over to do all the manual labor?


myLot reputation of 82/100. coolseeds (2513)  4 years ago

I disagree with "use the immigrants to make ourselves more lazy". I think poor parenting, food stamps and welfare have made people lazy. And not the illegal immigrant.

One of the reasons why I say that, is there are not any illegal aliens where I live. However there are a lot of lazy people. If it were not for food stamps they would have to work to eat. If some parents didn't let their children live at home until they are 40 while they are not working there would be more workers.

I own a company and it is hard to get qualified employees. Most are really slow.


myLot reputation of 82/100. coolseeds (2513)  4 years ago

As a business owner, I wouldn't hire someone who couldn't speak English. That would cost me more time and having to explain, redo jobs that do not meet my approval, learn a new language and whatever else would arise.


myLot reputation of 82/100. coolseeds (2513)  4 years ago

I meant "time and money" is the response above.

Central AC Estimates Find Top-Rated A/C Pros in Your Area. Get 4 Free Bids Today!  www.ServiceMagic.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 82/100. coolseeds (2513)   4 years ago

Almost everyone in the United States in an immigrant. I have no problem with people coming here. However an illegal immigrant is like a drug dealer. They do not pay taxes on the money they earn. That is the only problem I have with them.

Ask an Immigration Lawyer 7 Lawyers Are Online. Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.  Law.JustAnswer.com/Immigration
 
sponsors
Heat Pump Systems
Budget-priced Heat Pump. Wholesale prices direct to the public.
www.budgetheating.com

Buy a Heat Pump Today
Brand Names, Wholesale Prices and Free Shipping. Save Big!
www.TheACOutlet.com

eBay ® - Official Site
Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!
www.eBay.com

similar discussions
I just realized our agriculture sector is not bad at all
The only agricultural controversy our country had that makes the international news are the...
is this a right time that we should give more importance to agriculture ?
As we all know that the future generation people will be fighting for food and water. I personally...
Vocabulary used in (Industry and Agriculture) a chance for learning English
Hi English learners. Am gonna give you useful information about the most words used in the industry...
500 to 700 dollar a kilogram potato
I think we had discussed so many who were expensive food in many discussions here in Mylot so I...
Agriculture
Why are the results of our agriculture can not meet the needs of their own country? We are an...
sites for agricultural information
can any of mylot memmbers give me information of agricultures where i can information of agricultue...
sponsors
Heat Pump Systems
Budget-priced Heat Pump. Wholesale prices direct to the public.
www.budgetheating.com
Buy a Heat Pump Today
Brand Names, Wholesale Prices and Free Shipping. Save Big!
www.TheACOutlet.com
eBay ® - Official Site
Get great deals on eBay. Buy It Now or Win It!
www.eBay.com
Portable
Spot Coolers has the lowest prices for commercial portable units
www.spot-coolers.com
Portable Air Conditioners
Save on Top-Rated Portable AC Brands. Free Shipping! 30-Day Returns.
www.Sylvane.com
Air Conditioning Units
Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.best-price.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.