sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

An invitiation to suprise a friend at her baby shower. email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend1 year ago

I have a dilemna. All input and opinions are welcome.

A friend of mine, lives out of state and her husband has invited me to come be a house guest and surprise her by attending her baby shower. I'm willing to go and can afford the airfare.

But here is the twist.
Her first husband was a close and dear friend of mine from college. I know her through him and through the years we have become really close. We visit each other, vacation together etc.
A few years ago, she cheated on her husband with her current husband and has now gone on to a beautiful, happy life with him. She and I have never spoken about any of it. It all absolutely crushed my friend/her first husband. While I like her new husband who is actually a good man, I sometimes feel he goes to too much effort to try and force a friendship with me and my husband.

This will be her first child and she is having that child a little later in life. I have been there and know how special this life changing event is for her. I want to be a friend and share this beautiful time with her. But since I have been there, I know the strain that can be placed on a marriage when you try for years to get pregnant without success. I know what she went through and sometimes feel she chose to cop out, chose the easy way out. Again, we have never talked about it.

My dilemna:
1. I don't love the whole surprise aspect of this. Plus, since I will be a houseguest, I worry that too much time will be spent making me at home when this should be a weekend all about her. I just wish I could speak with her about it.

 
 
being a good friend
sponsors
Baby Shower Cake Designs
Find Cute Baby Shower Cakes. Search for Unique Baby Shower Cakes.
babyshowercake.intelliseeker.net

Baby Shower Invitations
Shop For Stylish& Affordable Baby Shower Invites& Save $10 On $75.
www.PearTreeGreetings.com/baby

Custom Novelty beautiful baby shower cakes
Custom beautiful baby shower cakes with personalized message.
www.hotbreadsmddc.com

katsmeow1213 (4861) response was accepted on 1/13/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  baby shower, friends, friendship, unfinished discussion, oops
 
1. myLot reputation of 96/100. katsmeow1213 (4861)   ranked 6 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

Well your only other option is to stay at a hotel if you can afford it so they don't have to go out of their way to make you feel at home.
But regardless if you stay at a hotel or with the friend, you should definitly go, this is a special time in her life and you should be there to celebrate it with her.

And regardless of how much you may disagree, her husband wants it to be a surprise, you have to respect his wishes. Just because YOU may not like the surprise aspect does not mean that she won't. Just go and be a good friend and have fun. Let them (more like him, the hubby) worry about the rest.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I hit the submit button before finishing this.......Uggggg!!
Dilemna cont'd:
2. Being that she and I have never discussed all this, I worry that it will add an additional sense of awkwardness for her.... and again this is HER weekend. I worry that her husband has not considered all this and would like to know if she would want this herself. Again, he tries so hard to force our relationship.

3. The shower itself is NOT a surprise. Just my being there to share it with her is the surprise aspect. I have known about the shower for some time and have arranged to have something personal and very special to her there, to respresent my being there (so to speak). Her husband is doing the surprise part for her, very last minute. I worry that he is being a little selfish (he has the propencity to be). He will be the only person to know if I don't show up and if he tells her he tried to do this and I didn't accept... well that would be inconsiderate of him, but I have no control over that.

I am better friends with her and hardly know him. I wish I could talk to her.
What are your thoughts as you read this????


katsmeow,
You are right, in the end it will mean the most to her to have a close friend to share this with.

If I start adding on hotel, car etc., it is not something I am willing to do being that I was given such short notice.


myLot reputation of 96/100. katsmeow1213 (4861)   ranked 6 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Personally I think it's sweet he's trying to do this for her. Sure it's supposed to be her weekend.. but how is that going to change just because you're there? You can still steer the weekend the correct direction.
I don't see why the things you haven't discussed should be an issue. She's about to be a mom, the conversations will be all about motherhood and not about ex husbands and what not. I think you're just worrying a bit too much.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I think you are exactly right. I'm worrying to much about all this.

Bottom line, I want to celebrate this new life with a dear friend and nothing else matters. This is exactly why I came here with this dilemna. Thanks.


myLot reputation of 96/100. katsmeow1213 (4861)   ranked 6 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I hope you have fun if you go.

Baby Shower Cake Designs Find Cute Baby Shower Cakes. Search for Unique Baby Shower Cakes. babyshowercake.intelliseeker.net
 
2. myLot reputation of 92/100. Irishfrndly65 (7306)   ranked 8 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

Oh gosh Potsie...that's a tough one. I wish I had some wise advice for you. You might just talk to the husband and let him know how you feel about the suprise aspect and the stay at their house. Maybe just let him know you are still willing to come but not as a suprise because you feel that you really need to talk to your friend first. If it's making you this uncomfortable there must be a reason, ya know?

Hope it all works out, just be honest. There's no use and making your stay miserable by being on edge the whole time, others will be able to sense it anyways. I am sure that the aspect of you even considering coming would be enough of a suprise and present in and of itself!


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I thought the same thing. I am usually all about doing nice things to surprise a friend and travelling to do it was just an added perk. But then I thought, .... there must be a reason I feel so 'odd' about it all of the sudden. I have learned with age that my gut/heart usually knows best.

But at the end of the day, it is all about a dear friend and celebrating with her the most beautiful thing ever to happen to her.

Had a nice talk with her husband. It will be a very nice visit.

Baby Shower Invitations Shop For Stylish & Affordable Baby Shower Invites & Save $10 On $75. www.PearTreeGreetings.com/baby
 
3. myLot reputation of 100/100. jillhill (11596)   ranked 20 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

That is a tough one...I would hate to stay at someone's house too with all that going on and not feeling totally comfortable with the whole situation. But if she is your friend she will understand if you don't come....but send a very special gift that she and the baby can cherish.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I have a very special gift lined up for her and I had gone to some extra efforts to pull it off because I was thinking I would not be able to attend.

After a nice talk with her husband about my concerns, I believe I will attend afterall. The house they live in is rather sprawling.... I will be in practically my own wing. It will be a nice visit with an old friend.

Custom Novelty beautiful baby shower cakes Custom beautiful baby shower cakes with personalized message. www.hotbreadsmddc.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 99/100. jesssp (1221)   ranked 42 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

I agree, the best option is to stay at a hotel if it's feasible That way the surprise won't seem as severe or overhelming as it would if you stayed with them.

What it really boils down to is how much you want to be there. If you do want to see her and celebrate with them then I say go and leave it as a surprise. I think that it would definitely be more comfortable for everyone if you didn't stay with them, that way there is much less of a chance of the ex husband subject coming up. Maybe the best senario would be to come the day before the shower and leave the day after. That way you have time to celebrate with her and spend a little time with them w/o worrying that they'll be too concerned with making you at home.

And if it still doesn't feel right, send a nice gift and some pretty flowers, give her a call in the evening after the shower so you can have a nice long chat and call it good!


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

I'm so glad I came here with this. Everyone has been helpful.

I have had a nice talk with the husband and now feel very good about it all. I will be attending and spending a very special day with a dear friend. Thanks so much for your input.

Edible Baby Shower Favors Large selection of delicious edible baby shower favors online. www.ediblegiftsplus.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. someonesmom (2275)   ranked 111 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

Hi makingpots, happy

I'm wondering if you can answer a couple of questions for me here, just for my clarification? I can be a bit thick sometimes. lol

Is the shower itself a surprise, or just the fact that you'll be there?

Did your friend leave her first husband, because they were having problems getting pregnant? I mean, is it this issue that drove them apart?

If it's 'only you' that's the surprise, and not the shower, then I think it's okay for you to let her husband know, that you'd like your friend to know that you'll be there.

If her first marriage ended due to the lack of children, then I think you should be able to discuss your feelings with her, about your friendship with her ex husband. If this is the case, does she know how much she hurt him, and is she sure that he was the cause of the infertility?

As for worrying about being a house guest, it seems as though her husband really wants you to stay there, so I wouldn't worry about it. I do think it's nice that it's important to him to include you (and your husband), as their friends.

Take care.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Hi, someonesmom.
Haha, you are not a bit thick... I ended the discussion accidentally without all the details. Scroll back up. I finished it once I got the first response.

But to answer your questions.
The marriage with my friend ended over the affair with her current husband. But a divide had been drawn in the marriage over not conceiving. We were friends with that in common.... a strained marriage over trying to move on - childless. We just chose to move on in different ways and have never spoken about it seen the break up of her marriage.
But at the end of the day, none of this matters for this one day. I will celebrate a beautiful event with a dear friend. We are thrilled to have been down this road together and now both of us have children. It is a special bond.

Her hubby and I had a nice chat over my concerns and I know all will go very well.


myLot reputation of 99/100. someonesmom (2275)   ranked 111 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Thanks for clearing this up for me. I'm very happy to hear that you were able to discuss this with your friend's husband. I'm sure you'll have a wonderful, and very memorable time, once you're there.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Yes, I'm sure I will. I looking forward to it now...... very much.


myLot reputation of 99/100. someonesmom (2275)   ranked 111 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

thumbup

Printable Baby Shower Invitations 1000s of Free Printable Invitations. Send as Many as You Want. CardPrintables.org
 
6. myLot reputation of 81/100. cyntrow (2693)   ranked 39 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

You said that you and she have not spoken about it, but is she your friend??? The break up of a marraige does not need to include the break up of friendships. I have been friends with couples who have split and I have still remained friends with both. If she's a friend; if you care about her, you should go.

On another side, if she is a friend then this should not be a dilema. After she has the baby and things settle for her, the two of you should discuss the situation. Only if she is a friend and if you care about the friendship. You need to do some soul searching I think.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

You are right, cyntrow. I needed to do some soul searching over this.

We have remained friends through all of this because at the heart of it, we are truly caring friends. We do need to have a difficult discussion or two in the future, but that has nothing do to with celebrating the exciting birth of her first child.

After a nice chat with her husband we are on the same page about my concerns. And we are both committed to making this a very special day for her. I will be going.

Thanks for your input on this. I have grown to love this about myLot.

Eco Baby Shower Gifts Great gift ideas for baby showers. Go green & save the earth. www.gifts.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 95/100. ronaldinu (7780)   ranked 40 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

I think your situation is straight forward, if her husband phones back, just tell him what you have written here. I would tell him there and then that I don't like the idea of a surprise visit. © ronaldinu 2008


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

That is just what I did, ronaldinu. We had a nice chat and are both on the same page about all this.

Baby Shower Cameras Great disposable Cameras for any occasion. Cameras for baby showers, baby births, baby birthdays and more. Prices starting at just $3.59 for standard wedding Cameras. www.custom-disposable-cameras.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 93/100. ANTIQUELADY (11104)   ranked 38 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

you are in a predictament. do u still talk to her first husband to? looks like you are between a rock & a hard place. that was probably one person i would have let go if i was still close to the first husband. all i know to say is follow your heart.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Yes, it is a bit of a predicament for me. I am still friends and actually better friends with her 1st husband. We go way back!
He still has deep feelings for her and probably always will. Yet, selflessly, he is happy for her that she is having the child she always wanted. It tears my heart out.

The worse part of all this for me is that she has not wanted to talk with me about it at all. We bonded in an all different way when my son was born and now we have a friendship based on something other than our history together. Does that make sense?
I'm proud of the fact that the dilemna stems from having so many caring wonderful people in my life....... in other world's this would have become ugly, messy and everyone might have lost good friends.

Your words are very wise. I will be following my heart. It never fails me.


myLot reputation of 93/100. ANTIQUELADY (11104)   ranked 38 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

i hope it all works out for you. good luck.

Baby Shower Poems Hundreds of Baby Shower Poems. Largest Poetry Site On The Web. Poems-Online.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 78/100. whiteheather39 (13253)   ranked 37 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

I get the impression from your posting that the situation makes you feel uneasy. Remember you will not just be spending a couple of hours at the shower and then "escaping" back to your home. I would not like to be stuck spending a few days in an uncomfortable situation.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Yes, those were my thoughts. If this shower were here in my town, I would not have even had a second thought.

But it was not MY feeling stuck in an uncomfortable situation that was concerning me, it was the expectant mother feeling uncomfortable that had me concerned.

Thanks for the input.

Personalized Baby Shower Gifts We have a large selection of distinctive and fun, personalized and non-personalized, shower gifts for that special new baby. kkbabygifts.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 77/100. MizzLadyB08 (837)   ranked 43 out of 163 in being a good friend   1 year ago

All I can say is show up for the baby shower. You do not have to be a houseguest if you feel that way about the situation. Friends are a blessing.


myLot reputation of 91/100. makingpots (6662)   ranked 1 out of 163 in being a good friend  1 year ago

Friends are indeed a blessing, MizzLadyB08.
I will be showing up for the shower!

Rubber Ducky Baby Shower Baby shower ideas, themes, party favors, gift ideas and Free Shipping. www.pricehot.com
 
sponsors
Edible Baby Shower Favors
Large selection of delicious edible baby shower favors online.
www.ediblegiftsplus.com

Printable Baby Shower Invitations
1000s of Free Printable Invitations. Send as Many as You Want.
CardPrintables.org

Eco Baby Shower Gifts
Great gift ideas for baby showers. Go green& save the earth.
www.gifts.com

similar discussions
A baby shower for a pregnant teen???
Would you have a baby shower for your 14-year old daughter if she got pregnant? Wouldn't that be...
Surprise Baby Shower
I want to arrange a surprise baby shower for three of my freinds. I am thinking of the games,...
Babyshower
I went to a babyshower yesterday and had a pretty good time. It was for my mom's cousin's daughter....
How long should a baby shower last?
I am still in the process of planning for an upcoming baby shower. This is my first time hosting a...
Couple questions on hosting a baby shower!
We hosting a baby shower in a little over a month. This is a first for me. I have a couple of
Food advice for upcoming baby shower needed
We are hosting a
When do you send the invitations?
We will be holding a baby shower at the beginning of December. How far in advance should the...
How much money do you spend for a baby shower gift?
How much money do you spend for a baby shower gift? I know sometimes it depends on how much money...
Baby Shower
Friday night I attended a bay shower for a woman in my church. We had it at the home of another...
I am just not that kind of Girl, Please help!!
My sister is having her first baby!! I am so excited, and want to give her a baby shower. However,...
sponsors
Edible Baby Shower Favors
Large selection of delicious edible baby shower favors online.
www.ediblegiftsplus.com
Printable Baby Shower Invitations
1000s of Free Printable Invitations. Send as Many as You Want.
CardPrintables.org
Eco Baby Shower Gifts
Great gift ideas for baby showers. Go green & save the earth.
www.gifts.com
Baby Shower Cameras
Great disposable Cameras for any occasion. Cameras for baby showers, baby births, baby birthdays and more. Prices starting at just $3.59 for standard wedding Cameras.
www.custom-disposable-cameras.com
Baby Shower Poems
Hundreds of Baby Shower Poems. Largest Poetry Site On The Web.
Poems-Online.com
Personalized Baby Shower Gifts
We have a large selection of distinctive and fun, personalized and non-personalized, shower gifts for that special new baby.
kkbabygifts.com
Rubber Ducky Baby Shower
Baby shower ideas, themes, party favors, gift ideas and Free Shipping.
www.pricehot.com
baby shower invites
Choose from 1000's of Custom baby shower invites.
www.Pingg.com
Party Supplies World for Baby Showers
Baby shower party supplies at our new Baby department. Thousands of Baby shower items to choose from.
partysuppliesworld.com
Baby Shower in a Box
Everything for your shower in 1 box - plates, cups, dec. Only $39.95.
www.perfect-babyshower.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.