sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Is megapixel really important? email this discussion to a friend?

papapao (1)   ranked 225 out of 251 in artist9 months ago

There are tons of threads and talks about whether the rise of the number of megapixels in digital cameras are really that important. Here is my take, there is nothing wrong with the numbers, for as long as you know the what you are doing, taking nice photographs are being happy with what you are doing, then we are good. The only issue here i think is, one should never be so engulfed in the idea of "more megapixels= better image". Prolly yes, technically, more room for cropping, more details in some areas but the overall impact of the photo can never be based on the number of megapixels of a digital camera.

How bout you? what do you think my friend?:)

 
 
artist
sponsors
Store Your Life in Photos
Free Your Content With Western Digital My Book Photo Storage.
WDC.com/SeeYourLifeSafe

Sensor Solutions (Manufacturer)
Manufacturer of sensors used in solar arrays for sensing position.
www.sensorso.com

Used Honda Fit at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  photography, photo, cameras, photos, megapixel
 
1. myLot reputation of 72/100. alphabetagamma (131)   9 months ago

Hi, papapao, welcome to myLot!!
I totally agree with you, more pixel doesn't mean better image,
I think good photo not necessarily taken by top class equipments.
I believe in 'feel' the photo, the photo may not need to be sharply focus, correctly exposed, accurate color balance, fine grain, large number of pixel which can be print as wall paper (not the one on your pc desktop!), I think a good photo is one can tell a story or can show the characteristic of the object in the photo.

Happy myLotting!!

Store Your Life in Photos Free Your Content With Western Digital My Book Photo Storage. WDC.com/SeeYourLifeSafe
 
2. myLot reputation of 81/100. Archie0 (3135)   ranked 216 out of 251 in artist   9 months ago

well i think it is important for me atleast. sometimes if you got a camera with lower mp or say it is just a vga camera yuor clearity wont be that well to get a clear perfect picture
where as if you have a good percent of mega pixel then possibly your photos are clearer in images and they got the shaper images. you dont need to edit the photos for them to be clear though. otherwise you need to edit them if you got a low mp camera. though i got a 6 megapixel camera but i am planning to get a 10 mp one soon
happy mylotting

Sensor Solutions (Manufacturer) Manufacturer of sensors used in solar arrays for sensing position. www.sensorso.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. UK_Shree (1848)   9 months ago

Hello there and welcome to the site - hope you enjoy using it. I agree, most people who use their camera only to capture general images on holiday, family occasions etc do not need a huge number of megapixels! I have a 7 megapixel camera that I bought around 2 years ago and it is more than enough for me.

Used Honda Fit at Yahoo! Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
4. myLot reputation of 91/100. Jellytang (365)   9 months ago

My answer is yes.If megapixel is low,the photoes and videos will be hard to attract people,especially when people have seen the high megapixel works.

Position Sensors 2.3 mm diameter Lvdt and more Position sensors. www.singer-instruments.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 70/100. Davidarich (766)   ranked 183 out of 251 in artist   8 months ago

The megapixel count is important, but there is no simple answer: it depends on the type of sensor, the size of the sensor and the quality of the lens. Very few lenses can resolve as much detail as a 12 megapixel sensor can record, so extra pixels are pointless unless you are using very good glass. You do not get that sort of lens on consumer cameras, only on high quality pro-sumer and SLR cameras... and most of the lenses on those expensive cameras can't use all the data from a 12 MP sensor.

There are several types of sensor in cameras. CCD sensors are the most common, a few cameras have Foveon sensors that put the red, blue and green sensitive pixels on different layers, and CMOS sensors are available on some high-end cameras. CMOS sensors have noise -reducing components at every sensor site on the sensor. The Foveon and CMOS sensors can handle more pixels than CCDSs without degrading the images, so higher pixel densities are worth considering if you own a camera of this type.

The major issue, though, is the size of the sensor. Photo sensors generate electrical charges and heat. the more you pack into the same space, the smaller you have to make them, and the closer you have to put them together. That increases the heat and electrical interference between them, and generates "noise" which breaks up the images. Computer algorithms built into the camera to reduce this ugly grainyness smear the picture slightly, losing even more detail. Also, smaller pixels collect less light, so these problems get worse in low light. Increasing the ISO to compensate increases the noise even more.

Phone cameras have tiny sensors. Anything above about 5 megapixels degrades the image. Compact point-and-shoot cameras seem to go OK up to about 9 Mp, but not if you want to shoot above 200ISO. The sensors in SLR cameras are twice the area of standard compacts and many have CMOS sensors. They produce lovely images up to 15Mp (although the CCD ones like Nikon D60 start to have problems above 10 Mp and 400ISO is their limit for quality pictures; compared with the Nikon D300 with a CMOS sensor, which takes lovely pics at 6400 ISO and above)). Full frame cameras like the Canon 5 series handle 21 Mp with ease, and large format cameras have no issue with Mp count.

Short version: too many pixels degrade the image. Avoid compact cameras with more than 7Mp if you want to print you photos or shoot in low light or with flash. If you are never going to do anything with your photos but put them on the screen, then the poor quality will not be quite so obvious, but you are never going to sell one.


myLot reputation of 84/100. momtrying2makeit (2269)   ranked 232 out of 251 in artist  8 months ago

You were full of some good information here and I just want to let you know I appericate the fact that you shared your knoweledge about this here. Take care and happy mylotting to you as well. happy

Photo Electric Sensor by Highly Manufacturer of proximity, inductive, capacitive, photoelectric sensors with low price. www.highlyusa.com
 
6. Angelovely (53)   ranked 192 out of 251 in artist   8 months ago

Depends on what you want to do with the photo. For online, it doesn't matter so much but if you want to do a great image and enlarge it, you need the megapixels. For fun shots it doesn't matter at all. For more serious art, you need the quality of the pixels. I do freelance photography and would not dream of submitting a photo without the bonus of at least 6 megapixels. Still, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and something I might be happy with you might not like at all and vice versus.

Usb Pc Camera Cmos Sensor Update your Usb Pc Camera Cmos with official drivers. Free download. UsbPcCameraCmos.Driver-Fix.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 64/100. prathna (111)   ranked 193 out of 251 in artist   7 months ago

haha! yesterday we were talking about this in photography class
yea more megapixels means basically theres more detail captured, so when u zoom ur image, it doesnt blur that much, like if u wanna make it ur desktop wallpaper or something, the more the megapixels, the clearer the image

Industrial Sensor Safety light curtains, photoelectric sensors, bar code readers, and more. www.leuzelumiflex.com
 
8. jalaluddin (43)   ranked 176 out of 251 in artist   7 months ago

i agree. more megapixels does not automatically convert to better images. sometimes when you take pictures with such cameras they turn out a little grainy . it is better to take a camera which suits you rather than one with way too many megapixels and other technical applications which might just end up confusing you if you don't know how to operate it (this happened to my dad.:D)


jalaluddin (43)   ranked 176 out of 251 in artist  7 months ago

the cameras i'm referring to here are the tiny digital cameras with something like 10 mega pixels.. i have one of them.. thing is even though the number of mega pixels increases the size of the camera's image sensors stays the same. this means more mega pixels are squeezed out from the same sensor, leading to less light per pixel . hence the camera works poorly in dimmer conditions,like inside the house..

Monitoring Sensors View a variety of reliable monitoring sensors. Live online support. www.apc.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 73/100. cecillecarmela (1103)   ranked 188 out of 251 in artist   7 months ago

megapixel is also something important, since it makes the image crispier but according to my professor (which I also believe in) good photographers make great pictures no matter what camera they use. It just depends on what angle they are..:)

Washington DC Electricals Find Washington DC Electricians & Electric Contractors at YellowPages. WashingtonDC.YellowPages.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 91/100. akumei1269 (1086)   7 months ago

Thanks for opening a important topic here. I have recently bought a Sony DSC H-10 camera - it's 8 mp. I would like to know more about details of a digital cameras.

I thing MP is an important parametre, because determines the clarity of the image. But at the same time compatibility of other parmetres is also important.

Compare All SLR Cameras 1000+ Stores on MySimon. Save Big. MySimon.com/Electronics
 
sponsors
Position Sensors
2.3 mm diameter Lvdt and more Position sensors.
www.singer-instruments.com

Photo Electric Sensor by Highly
Manufacturer of proximity, inductive, capacitive, photoelectric sensors with low price.
www.highlyusa.com

Usb Pc Camera Cmos Sensor
Update your Usb Pc Camera Cmos with official drivers. Free download.
UsbPcCameraCmos.Driver-Fix.com

similar discussions
Do you believe that orbs are some kind of spirits or just flaws in photography?
Orbs are unexpected often circular appearances on photographs. It's a result of reflection from...
photography as a hobby
photography is one of the best hobbies of my friend.i dont know much photography technics.but i do...
Favorite thing to photograph?
I really like photographing people, on account of their many different expressions. When I take the...
Opinions on a photo?
What do you think of this photo? I slowed down the shutter speed and it turned out really cool....
Do you think digital cameras have brought in a revolution in photography?
digital cams digital clicks so convenient so inexpensive few years back, I didn't even dream...
How to earn money from photography?
I heard that I can earn good money from photography. DO you know any online sites to share and earn...
A few questions on photography;]
Well let me explain a bit about myself first with this subject. I went to college before, and had...
If somebody in the street want to take a pictures with you, will you accept?
Is not a big deal, ion special in cities with many tourists, and they want sometimes to take a...
Do you think digital camera has made us careless while shooting?
When I had an ordinary camera, where every shot mattered, I used to be very diligent and careful,...
Close-up photography - is there any one how practise it?
Hi, Mylotters. I'm a fan of the photography and espacialy the close-up photography. Is there any...
sponsors
Position Sensors
2.3 mm diameter Lvdt and more Position sensors.
www.singer-instruments.com
Photo Electric Sensor by Highly
Manufacturer of proximity, inductive, capacitive, photoelectric sensors with low price.
www.highlyusa.com
Usb Pc Camera Cmos Sensor
Update your Usb Pc Camera Cmos with official drivers. Free download.
UsbPcCameraCmos.Driver-Fix.com
Industrial Sensor
Safety light curtains, photoelectric sensors, bar code readers, and more.
www.leuzelumiflex.com
Monitoring Sensors
View a variety of reliable monitoring sensors. Live online support.
www.apc.com
Washington DC Electricals
Find Washington DC Electricians & Electric Contractors at YellowPages.
WashingtonDC.YellowPages.com
Compare All SLR Cameras
1000+ Stores on MySimon. Save Big.
MySimon.com/Electronics
Camera Shopping
Everything you need is here. Shop & compare the best deals online.
shopping.lycos.com
Limousine Services at Special Low Rates
Christmas light tours are offered by Jason Tours LLC.
www.JasonTours.com
Image Sensor Sockets
Protect delicate image sensor devices from damage during board processing by using economical sockets from Advanced Interconnections Corp. Standard and custom designs available.
www.advanced.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.