they were all SUPERB... but someone needs to go home tomorrow night. :(
By Jhordie
@Jhordie (5115)
Philippines
April 29, 2009 11:15am CST
Simon predicted that it could be Allison... he does't love Kris performance as much as the other three judges did but he loved Matt, Danny and Adam's renditions. What do you think guys? Will it be Allison, Kris or Matt that might leave the competition come the elimination tomorrow?
I would have to AGREE with Randy and Kara about Matt's performance... it kinda fell short and he seems to be just a follower than a leader in this competition unlike the rest. I love Matt... but I would just love to see Allison and Kris come next week than him. Sorry but I guess... It is his time to go. But I would still buy his album that's for sure. I just didn't love his performance as much as Paula and Simon did.
Now its your turn to judge them... and let us know your opinion here.
3 people like this
10 responses
@LadyMarissa (12148)
• United States
29 Apr 09
OMG wasn't last night just outrageously good??!!! 
I couldn't believe that Randy was complaining about Adam being theatrical. Is that not what performers are??? For ONCE, I agreed with Simon!!! 
I missed Kris' performance, but the bit that I got to see he was extremely good. I'm very sad to say that I've come to the conclusion that it's Matt's turn to leave. I really like him, but he didn't bring his "A" game last night. That genre should have been his place to shine, yet he was dull. Danny was beyond excellent. I totally disagreed with Simon on Allison. I thought she did a good job on her song. Sometimes I think Idol decides who they want to leave next & gives them a bad song to work with. 
I couldn't believe that Randy was complaining about Adam being theatrical. Is that not what performers are??? For ONCE, I agreed with Simon!!! I missed Kris' performance, but the bit that I got to see he was extremely good. I'm very sad to say that I've come to the conclusion that it's Matt's turn to leave. I really like him, but he didn't bring his "A" game last night. That genre should have been his place to shine, yet he was dull. Danny was beyond excellent. I totally disagreed with Simon on Allison. I thought she did a good job on her song. Sometimes I think Idol decides who they want to leave next & gives them a bad song to work with. 1 person likes this
@LadyMarissa (12148)
• United States
14 May 09
Idol has control over EVERY move they make. Yes, they get to choose their own song; yet they have a mentor who helps them decide which song to choose & how to arrange it so it's NOT just their decision & responsibility. They are NEVER given full control over what they do from the time they go into the audition until weeks after the finale. Clay Aiken had to wait to put out his first CD until after Ruben Studdard had put his out because of the contract with Idol.
Idol had begun to lose its popularity, so they have been playing Adam & the others like a fine violin. With all the controversy over Adam, Kris & Danny, people who have NEVER watched are watching it this year. Week before last only 64 million voted. Last week 88 million voted. Most of this season's contestants will be offered recording contracts & with hard work they all have the potential to make it BIG. It will be interesting to see who comes out as the most popular once they are on their own!!!
1 person likes this
@ArsonCuff (3114)
• United States
2 May 09
I assumed it would be Matt and it was.
1 person likes this
@Fortunata (1135)
• United States
29 Apr 09
Lol, my sister in law HATES Allison. I don't know why. It infuriates her when I defend her. Having said that, I think it's going to come down to two guys, Danny and Adam.
1 person likes this
@Rainegurl (2156)
• Philippines
30 Apr 09
Hi, Jhordie. I guess you are right and Matt was really sent home. He did not amaze as much as Adam and Danny. Now those two are really talented. I think Allison is talented too and I like her big voice but I do not think she will win. I am looking forward to hearing her own songs someday though. I hope it would be like Kelly Clarkson's. Edgy songs.
Have a nice day! 
1 person likes this
@Jhordie (5115)
• Philippines
14 May 09
And it wasn't proven that episode because he got the second lowest number of votes... good thing he was not eliminated. I don;t have anything against him its just that voters doesn't realize that their votes can eaither make or break the dream of every Idol contestants
@kun2349 (23381)
• Singapore
29 Apr 09
I dont' know because i did not even watch it.. lol =D Be it who's going or who's staying tomorrow night, it's up to the citizens of USA to vote.. Be it right or wrong, as asia supporters, we can only watch and weep in sorrow if our own idols is being voted out.. lol =D
Be it, Matt, allison, Kris, Danny or adam, only one of them will win the competition, thus being voted out is just a matter of time ^_^ haha
1 person likes this
@Jhordie (5115)
• Philippines
14 May 09
really true... we can't do anything with it, we can just simply watch and smile if our bet remains and cry if he/she was eliminated... and there could only be ONE AMERICAN IDOL... its just a matter of time in accordance to the will and support of American voters... it is as it is
1 person likes this
@ladym33 (10978)
• United States
29 Apr 09
I think they were all good last night. But I have to surprisingly say based just on last night's performances Kris had the weakest performance. He was good, but everyone else was really on it last night. That being said, I would be surprised if Kris went home tonight based on his consistently good performances, and huge fan base. Just based on history Matt and Allison are the only ones who have been in the bottom 3 before, so it will likely be one of them. As you said someone has to go home. I don't think anyone deserves to go home but someone has to it is the nature of the game after all. I think the 5 who are left will do really well after this years competition is over regardless of who goes home tonight.
1 person likes this
@gracie04 (4549)
• Philippines
29 Apr 09
They were all great! I love Adam, Allison and Danny.. I think Allison or Matt will go home tomorrow.. They always get the lowest votes from viewers.. I would also have to agree with Kara and Randy's comment about Matt's performance.. Matt is good but there are better singers than him like Allison.. I would still like to see Allison perform next week.. Imagine, at the age of 17 she got a very powerful voice.. but of course, only one would be crowned as the winner and definitely, it would be ADAM LAMBERT! =)
1 person likes this
@monica058 (83)
• Philippines
29 Apr 09
I think most of Simon's critiques today are totally wrong. For instance, Matt's performance was not that brilliant. Even though I'm quite tone deaf, his performance, especially the beginning, was a little pitchy.
1 person likes this
