sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

how good are you at baking cakes email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake8 months ago

me, well i can laugh and say that i could make a mess by baking cakes, i remember at school, my domestic science teacher wanted us to make a simple victoria sponge cake with butter cream and jam in the middle, mine turned out like a rock cake, literally, i took it home and my nanna ate some, then my aunt ate some and they both had that whincey look on their faces, i think they were being kind by saying it was nice, but i could tell that it was a mess and not nice, the next day my nanna showed me how to make a proper cake, hers was so soft and spongy but with mine we could have used it to sole our shoes, shocked over the years my baking became somewhat tolerable but not palateable, blink even to this day i don't know what i am doing wrong, but my cakes always turn out heavy and tasteless, so how are you with baking cakes and have you made a complete disater, or maybe a masterpiece?

 
 
cake
sponsors
Do You Have Coffee Teeth?
An Underpaid, Overworked Single Mom Reveals $4 Teeth Whitening Secret.
News13KDTV.com

Manhattan Gmat
Read reviews for this Education Center& find local Education Info.
Citysearch.com

Send A Cake
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more
Portland.Citysearch.com

suzzy3 (3924) response was accepted on 5/7/2009.
denotes best response.
tags:  cake, baking, cakes, decorating, bake
 
1. myLot reputation of 88/100. skylight53 (360)   ranked 466 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

I made a terrible birthday cake for myself,just a few days ago.It was supposed to be a two layered cake and the two layers were flattened like a pancake.It was funny.It tasted awful,it was supposed to be angel food cake.The two layers were smashed down together.LOL It tasted awful too.


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4270)   ranked 67 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

Awww! Your cake sounds like the ones I make from scratch! But, HAPPY BIRTHDAY, anyway!!!


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

well first off, happy belated birthday, i am terrible at baking i can make fruit pies and meat pies but when it comes to cakes i am terrible, i will take mental wards advice and make one from a mix instead...then tell my friend i made it my way...hehehe! lol


myLot reputation of 99/100. PurpleTeddyBear (3807)   ranked 47 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

Happy belated birthday skylight! That's too bad that your cake didn't turn out!

Do You Have Coffee Teeth? An Underpaid, Overworked Single Mom Reveals $4 Teeth Whitening Secret. News13KDTV.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4270)   ranked 67 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

w00t I just wrote about my cakes in another discussion not too long ago.

My cakes have ALWAYS been disasters! I tried to make an angelfood cake once. It came out of the oven with HUGE holes all through it. Where there should have been cake, there was just air.

One cake I attempted had a 1/4 inch layer of something "rubbery" on the bottom. I'm not kidding! I peeled this layer off the cake and I could stretch it! I have NO idea what I did wrong to that poor cake!

Another cake came out being about 2 inches tall. I'm talking 2 layers WITH icing! WHAT AM I DOING WRONG???

I gave up. Now, I use cake mixes ONLY. I rarely mess them up. I've even learned how to make them more moist by adding instant pudding mix to the cake mix. It works great, too! I've made my sons' birthday cakes almost every year since their births, but always from a boxed cake mix. However, I can be VERY creative with the decorations. My sons always look forward to seeing what their next birthday cake will look like... now that I make cakes that are edible! LOL

Boxed cake mixes, Tatty. Some of us simply were not born to bake a good cake from scratch. sad

But, I do make a GREAT pie crust! wink


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

oh i make excellent pies, i couls make any pie and make my own pastry but makine cakes is a whole different ball game, i bet them cakes you made were funny at the time, i have tried so much to get the "prefect" cake but it just didn't work out the way i wanted them to, my nanna used to make mixed fruit cake and they always turned out like they were bought out of the shop, but mione tasted like someone had trodden on them in rubber wellies, i guess the instant mix will do me for now, it's my friends birthday next week and i want to make him a cake for his birthday, so i think i will buy cake mix instead, at least if it goes wrong i cannot blame myself...lol....


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4270)   ranked 67 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

Yep, we can blame the companies who make the cake mixes! LOL

One of these days, we should share pie recipes. I'm hoping to get enough peaches from my trees this year to be able to make a peach pie or cobbler.

Oh! My lilacs are in full bloom (although VERY wet from all the rain). I'm keeping a close eye on them to see when they start wilting because I'll place bags over some of the blossoms to collect the seeds before the birds do. You're gonna get those seeds soon... it's a promise!


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

yeah we can blame the manufactoreres, oh thanks mental, i would love them lilacs, i have just ordered some lily of the valley bulbs which should be here any day now, maybe today even, also i sent off for some night scented stock, i love that stuff, it smells so nice, at the mo i have runner beans growing and i think i better get them in the ground before something happens to them, also my raddish is sprouting so they better be in the ground too, take your time with the flowers hun, wait till they are dry then send them, i have made a seated area in the garden and i have planted lots of lovely flowers in that area too, so i would love them lilacs to set it off a bit, thankyou for that, it's so kind of you...


myLot reputation of 99/100. Aliceinwebland (5005)   ranked 86 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

confused mine too mentalward! total disasters! cry


myLot reputation of 98/100. mentalward (4270)   ranked 67 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

cry Alice, what did our mothers know that they forgot to tell us? Mine used to make great cakes but I sure didn't inherit her skill! doh


myLot reputation of 99/100. Aliceinwebland (5005)   ranked 86 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

lol I inherited a lot of her skills, but not that one! hehe

Manhattan Gmat Read reviews for this Education Center & find local Education Info. Citysearch.com
 
3. THEMADTYPER (46)   ranked 464 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

That sounds like if I would make a cake I am scared and would not dare try to do that though I do love cake very much.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

hi and welcome to mylot, i love your nickname, i too am terrible at baking so i might cheat and get a boxed mix and make it from there....lol....

Send A Cake Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more Portland.Citysearch.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 93/100. jerzgirl (2745)   ranked 151 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

Baking is not my forte either. If not for boxed mixes, I'd probably never have a decent cake ever. But, there is one scratch cake I've made that turns out good every time - if you like a heavy moist cake. It's meant to be heavy. It's a depression era recipe and I grew up on it. I have always liked it and it doesn't need frosting. We always called it "Poor Man's Cake". It was baked in a tube pan (Turk's head, bundt-type, whatever it might be called).

DEPRESSION BOILED RAISIN CAKE

2 c. raisins
2 c. boiling water
2 c. sugar
1 c. butter
2 tsp. soda
1 tsp. cloves
1 tsp. allspice
2 tsp. cinnamon
1 tsp. salt
3 c. flour
1 tsp. baking powder

Put first 10 ingredients in a 4-quart kettle. Boil 4 minutes. Cool 2 hours. Add remaining ingredients. Pour into 9x13 inch greased pan. Bake 40-50 minutes at 350 degrees. Serves 20 people.


No eggs or milk. We'd put colored jimmies (sprinkles, candies) on top before putting in the oven. Here's another version.

POOR MAN'S CAKE OR THE DEPRESSION CAKE

1 c. water
1 c. sugar
1 c. raisins
1 tsp. ground cloves
1 tsp. ground nutmeg
1 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/4 c. shortening (I use liquid) (the old recipe called for lard)
2 c. flour
1 tsp. salt
1 tsp. soda
Powdered sugar

Notice no eggs or milk.
Bring the first 7 ingredients to a boil. Simmer for 5 minutes; let cool to touch. Add flour, salt and soda. Bake in 350 degree oven - cake for 30 minutes; cupcakes for 25 minutes; cookies about 12-15 minutes. These ingredients will make one 8 inch square or round or loaf cake, 1 1/2 dozen cupcakes or 36 drops cookies (depending on size). Dust with powdered sugar. The small of the ingredients boiling will fill the house.


The last comment is a good one because the boiling of the raisins WILL fill the house with the fragrance of the spices being used. Excellent way to build that cake appetite!! I couldn't even wait for the cake to cool before I'd have some!!

Another cake I've made that turned out well is a "surprise" cake. In a deep 9x13 pan, place a layer of miniature marshmallows on the greased bottom. Then pour cake batter over that (your choice of flavor) followed by canned pie filling on top of the batter. Bake at 350 degrees for 30-40 minutes. When done, the pie filling will be on the bottom and the marshmallows will be on the top. It will be almost like a cobbler at times, but it is always yummy!! I like mixing chocolate cake with cherry pie filling or spice cake with apple or peach pie filling. You decide!!


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

oh you are making me feel so hungry now, i will copy and paste this into office word and save it, i would love to try it out, thankyou for taking the time to do this, i truly appreciate it so much, yum yum, it sounds so delicious....


myLot reputation of 93/100. jerzgirl (2745)   ranked 151 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

I think you'll like it. I prefer it being cooked in a tube pan because it can't dry out as much as a shallow cake can. What are jimmies/sprinkles called in the UK? They're the tiny cylindrical candies that get sprinkled on top of cup cakes and sundaes.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

oh sprinkles here are called hundreds and thousands, but i call them sprinkles myself, i wen to the shop the other day and asked for some sprinkles and the shop keeper gave me a funny look, then i told him, hundreds and thousands, then he knew what i was talking about, lol....i still call them sprinkles it's less or a mouthful saying hundreds and thousands...lol....


myLot reputation of 93/100. jerzgirl (2745)   ranked 151 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

Wow - I guess that IS a mouthful!! Dang!! LOL They're called "jimmies" here in the South Jersey area. I have no idea why, but at least "hundreds and thousands" has a minuscule of reason behind it.

Washington DC Transportation dca suv tranpsortation All your ground transportation in the Washington DC, MD and VA areas. www.jasontours.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 95/100. tamarafireheart (12526)   ranked 273 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

Hi tatt,



I used to bake cakes as my mum used to be always bakeing cakes when we were young, and every year she Baked christmas cakes, so with mum bakeing I used to bake as well but over the yeas, I cannot be borthered, well it is only two of us here and I don't want to spoil the hubby and if i do, he'll expect me to bake often, so don't anymore. love and hugs.


Tamara
xxxx


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

lol, don't spoil him too much tamara, he has to watch his figure...lol...i am no good at baking, i just don't think i am cut out for that kind of thing, i am a great singer but baking cakes is not for me...lol....maybe if i sing to my cakes they will turn out ok...lol... rasp

washington health insurance? 40% Savings On Health Insurance. Health Insurance Quotes In Minutes. Health.Insurance202.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 95/100. drannhh (7437)   ranked 469 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

I've had some duds, but overall, I'm pleased with my own results. However, I do prefer to "healthy up" the food I make so some might not like them. One of my favorite cakes to make (and to eat!) is applesauce spice cake, but my most favorite I just buy at Sam's Club, as it is their lemon mascarpone cheesecake, yummers. They are big, so I freeze most of it after repackaging it into portion controlled slices:-)


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

yum, i love anything with lemon in, i also like anything with apple inside too, but when it comes to sponge cakes, forget it, i may aswell just go outside and tarmac the driveway with it....lol.... lol

DC Storage Trailers Find Washington DC storage trailers & containers -- all sizes, rates. Storage.YellowPages.com/DC
 
7. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (15240)   ranked 109 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

either you are mixing them too long or not long enough


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

that's probably what it is, or i am just no good at making cakes full stop...lol... lol


myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (15240)   ranked 109 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

I only make box mixes, when I can find one that is corn starch free

Cake Decorating Supplies Directory Search Businesses At Local.com For Cake Decorating Near You. Local.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 96/100. patriciaqualls (4604)   ranked 360 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

I always just use the Betty Crocker box for cakes.
I can never go wrong. I bake cakes with my daughters
when they are here for my week we have a lot of fun
baking them.
Take care and have a great day!


myLot reputation of 97/100. GardenGerty (20287)   ranked 72 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

That is me exactly. You can do a lot with a box cake and never go wrong. I put shredded carrots in mine, voila, carrot cake.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

not dure if we get betty crocker cakes here, but i will ure look, even if i have to cheat making one, i still want to make one for my friends birthday, he knows i am making one now coz his daughter spoiled my surprise by telling him...sigh! so once i have had a try i will take a pic and put it in here...jeez i am dreading it already....lol... doh


myLot reputation of 96/100. patriciaqualls (4604)   ranked 360 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

That sounds so good right now I love carrot
cake!!!

cupcake wedding cake Creative Designs for Wedding Cakes From the Experts at RealSimple.com! RealSimple.com/weddings
 
9. myLot reputation of 99/100. faeryoftheshire1 (192)   ranked 91 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

I stink at baking,I could follow the instructions to a T and still mess it up.I barely passed Home Ec...I liked when we did group activities I would do all the clean up,lol!My cakes seem to come out lumpy or hard as a rock,lol!I have yet to master baking a simple cake.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

lol, i was good at sampling cakes but never making them, even i read the instructions and they never turn out the way i want them to, i wanna make a cake for my friends birthday next week, i was gonna keep it as a surprise but his daughter biubbled on me, tsk tsk, i asked her not to but there ya go, some people just cannot keep a secret, i may have one more stab at it and see how i go, if i fail, then at least i know i tried...lol...


myLot reputation of 99/100. faeryoftheshire1 (192)   ranked 91 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

I wish you alot of luck,I guess it is all about trial and error when learning things but after many times of epic failure I decided I will just buy the desserts I want,lol!I may give it another go sometime again.I can cook meals but not cakes.I can barely make jello...hahahaha!I hope your cake comes out great!x

Custom Created Cakes All occasion custom created cakes and favors. Srvg the Metro DC area. www.sugarnshindigs.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 97/100. GardenGerty (20287)   ranked 72 out of 1,077 in cake   8 months ago

I usually make mine from mixes. They are hard to ruin. Hubby made his first one at a lumber camp and it was hard enough to use for target practice throwing axes at it. I do think I used to make a sponge cake from scratch and it was pretty tolerable.


myLot reputation of 98/100. tattylashes (4295)   ranked 25 out of 1,077 in cake  8 months ago

hahaha gerty that made me laugh, throwing axes at a cake...lol...now i got the giggles... lollollol

cake Find Local Cake Online. Search For Cake Today! Tazinga.com
 
sponsors
Washington DC Transportation dca suv tranpsortation
All your ground transportation in the Washington DC, MD and VA areas.
www.jasontours.com

washington health insurance?
40% Savings On Health Insurance. Health Insurance Quotes In Minutes.
Health.Insurance202.com

DC Storage Trailers
Find Washington DC storage trailers& containers -- all sizes, rates.
Storage.YellowPages.com/DC

similar discussions
Cakes
Do you ever think you could make a cke that turned out like the pictures you see?I have always...
are birthday cakes just for kids?! what do you do when its your birthday?
hello, i'm just curious if you still celebrate your birthday and if you still have a cake to...
do you prefer to bake your own cake or just buying on the bake shop?
i would like to learn how to bake and design my own birthday cake but i dont know how.so when my...
Ice Cream or Cake on birthdays? Which one do you like more?:)
I love ice cream...I think it is one of the most delicious dessert on the planet. In every occasion...
what kind of cake do you like to eat?
Many people around the world may like eating cake,but they have diffrent kind of taste and fruit.i...
Which flavor cake u like to eat?
Tell here which flavor cake u like to eat?
Would you ever eat cake for dinner?
One time, I ate cake for dinner. I wasn't really hungry for real food. I think it was my...
get chilled sour cream cake
my friend sent me a text message asking me if she can keep inside the fridge a cake made of sour...
Carrot Cake Cookies!!!!
These are great and easy cookies that I need to share with you all! Okay, all you have to do is mix...
Do you love baking cakes?
l loves baking cakes for my family when lm free. lt had been one of my hobbies since l was still...
sponsors
Washington DC Transportation dca suv tranpsortation
All your ground transportation in the Washington DC, MD and VA areas.
www.jasontours.com
washington health insurance?
40% Savings On Health Insurance. Health Insurance Quotes In Minutes.
Health.Insurance202.com
DC Storage Trailers
Find Washington DC storage trailers & containers -- all sizes, rates.
Storage.YellowPages.com/DC
Cake Decorating Supplies Directory
Search Businesses At Local.com For Cake Decorating Near You.
Local.com
cupcake wedding cake
Creative Designs for Wedding Cakes From the Experts at RealSimple.com!
RealSimple.com/weddings
Custom Created Cakes
All occasion custom created cakes and favors. Srvg the Metro DC area.
www.sugarnshindigs.com
cake
Find Local Cake Online. Search For Cake Today!
Tazinga.com
That's My Pan - Personalized Cake Pans
4 Lid colors and 100 artwork choices. Shipped in 7 days or less.
www.thatsmypan.com
Before You Buy …
Start A Cake Business Today First Read These User Reviews.
www.dp-db.com/start-a-cake-business
Cake Decorating Supplies
Cincinnati cake and candy supplies, featuring all your needs for cake, candy, and cookie baking supplies.
www.cincicakeandcandy.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.