sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

How Old Does A Song Have To Be To Be "Classic Rock"? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music6 months ago

Lots of people think "Classic Rock" is all 60's and 70's, with a little 80's thrown in.

I am of the opinion that there are MANY songs from the 90's that could be termed "classic" now.

Jane's Addiction, Pearl Jam, Stone Temple Pilots, Soundgarden...I myself would consider many of these to be "classic" now. They have stood the test of time, and are still as popular and vital as when they came out many years ago...but some of my friends say they can't be "classic" because they aren't old enough...but when I try to pin them down on how old a song has to be, I can never get a definite answer from them. rolleyes

So...what do you think? How old does music have to be before it is "Classic"?



 
 
listening to music
sponsors
Classic Soft Rock 11 CD Set by Time Life
$9.95 30 day trial includes bonus CD& upgrade option to 19 CD set.
directfromtv.com

Stone Temple Pilots 2009 Tour
Find tickets to all STP concerts. Get free alerts for new shows.
ThrillCall.com

Backstage Fashion - Classic Rock Shirts
Worldwide, wholesale only, distributors of licensed rock and novelty t-shirts as well as stickers, patches and flags. For business owners only. Others, please visit your local retail store.
www.backstage-fashion.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  classic rock, rock, music that ages well, dawn, how old does a song have to be to be classic rock
 
1. myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10177)   ranked 66 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

At least a week... rasp
idk seriously when do you decide that a song has stood the test of time? When it ends up in an elevator? I don't know but I'd think you'd have to give it at least 10 years and lots and lots of sales.


myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Ten years is kind of what I think...but you get the occasional music that comes out that sounds like it should be classic even though it just came out...


myLot reputation of 95/100. dawnald (10177)   ranked 66 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Like a certain Daughtry song that has gotten played over and over ad nauseum?

Classic Soft Rock 11 CD Set by Time Life $9.95 30 day trial includes bonus CD & upgrade option to 19 CD set. directfromtv.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. tamarafireheart (12616)   ranked 1,955 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

Hi MYKL,



To me 50s and the 60s are classic, I don't think 80s and 90s are as they are too modern.


Tamara

Stone Temple Pilots 2009 Tour Find tickets to all STP concerts. Get free alerts for new shows. ThrillCall.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 98/100. amybrezik (1111)   ranked 3,238 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

I was just having this same conversation the other day. The way you are thinking of it, I would agree that the bands you listed would be considered classic. However, I think there is some sort of number of years old they have to be to be considered classic. But I agree with you wish i knew hw old it had to be.

Backstage Fashion - Classic Rock Shirts Worldwide, wholesale only, distributors of licensed rock and novelty t-shirts as well as stickers, patches and flags. For business owners only. Others, please visit your local retail store. www.backstage-fashion.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 92/100. Irishfrndly65 (7439)   ranked 11 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

What is a classic car, 20 yrs...I always thought of music the same way for some reason. LOL Although your criteria is a bit better, I must admit.


myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Thing is, I used to listen to AOR...album oriented rock...but now it's all called "classic"...of course, they don't use albums anymore either...but...still


myLot reputation of 60/100. darkjedi1 (752)   ranked 3,300 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

hey:D


myLot reputation of 0/100. IDinySqueek (109)  6 months ago

Hahaha a squeelin rock star....how lovley...NOT!!

Pearl Jam Lyrics All Pearl Jam Song Lyrics -- #1 Lyric Site On The Net. songlyric-site.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 99/100. scarlet_woman (9029)   ranked 43 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

seems to be 20 years minimum.what it used to be,anyway.
having said that however,how the hell did britney spears get in the R'n'R hall of fame before black sabbath?


myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

I don't even wanna get started there... angry

Bratney Spears...

Classical Music Downloads Stop paying for music. Download classical songs for free. 100% legal. www.mpfree.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 89/100. sconibear (2560)   ranked 1,081 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

when the "classic rock" radio station plays a song it's considered classic rock cuz they went to school and stuff and know these kinda things.









............plus they play funny sound effects when they talk. lol


myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Well, I put some Godsmack in my classic rock app...screw 'em...

*zoing*

*pow*

(is that how you spell*zoing*?)


myLot reputation of 89/100. sconibear (2560)   ranked 1,081 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

close enough myk! thumbup

*WOO WOO ZIIIIIIIIIIING!!!*

Elizabethan Classics - Free S/H 20%-50% Off Retail Pricing. Wholesale Prices & Fast, Free S/H. www.efaucets.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 86/100. fwidman (5375)   ranked 1,064 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

If it came out after 1979, it's too young to be a classic lol

Used Honda Pilots at Yahoo! Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car. www.honda.com/yahoo
 
8. myLot reputation of 64/100. AnnieOakley1 (1683)   ranked 2,851 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

Well, a car is considered a "classic" after 20 yrs, so maybe a song should, too then.

So a song that came out in 1990, should be considered a "classic" in 2010, provided of course that it is still as popular and well liked and has "stood the test of time".

nuclear medicine technology jobs washington dc Find Jobs in Nuclear Medicine - Search Washingtonpost.com Now. www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
 
9. myLot reputation of 71/100. TheGreatWhiteBuffalo (1443)   ranked 6,786 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

A Classic like a Classic Car is a car that is 15 years old or older. Most times the car is well kept in almost new condition.

To me a Classic Song is one that will be unique to stand the test of time. There are so many songs that are re-recorded that have been done time and time again and they are truly classics.

Washington Rock Climbs Cragging or alpine rock climbing, beginner or advanced, we guide it. www.mountainmadness.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 60/100. darkjedi1 (752)   ranked 3,300 out of 9,158 in listening to music   6 months ago

HMmm dont know, Ive always thought about stuff being classic being at least 20 years old or older. Including movies, but hell I will hear music or see movies on AMC that are less then 20 years old and will be called classic, um what? I dont think so lol.


myLot reputation of 76/100. MYKLJ999_VERSION_2 (2981)   ranked 200 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Hey, you would probably know this...if I send someone files on Yahoo messenger, where do they look for them on their computer? Will they be in the documents folder? I sent someone some music files and they don't know where to look for them...


myLot reputation of 60/100. darkjedi1 (752)   ranked 3,300 out of 9,158 in listening to music  6 months ago

Oh ok thats what you meant about answre you lol.

health testing Looking For health testing In Your Area. Call Now. TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
 
sponsors
Pearl Jam Lyrics
All Pearl Jam Song Lyrics -- #1 Lyric Site On The Net.
songlyric-site.com

Classical Music Downloads
Stop paying for music. Download classical songs for free. 100% legal.
www.mpfree.com

Elizabethan Classics - Free S/H
20%-50% Off Retail Pricing. Wholesale Prices& Fast, Free S/H.
www.efaucets.com

similar discussions
I love you Andrea Bonecelli!!
I was watching Oprah today after getting back from the appointment with nurses regarding education...
What's your favorite classic rock band?
Just taking a survey on favorite classic rock bands. Mine just happends to be Bad Company. My...
legend rock and legend classic rock
Hi mylotters who rock music lover, whether you think there rock band that was born in the year 2000...
How much of a part of your life is music?
I listen to music all the time and have very varied taste from chart to the unheard of from punk to...
Alan Parsons Project
A couple of nights ago I had a talk radio station on and they had Alan Parsons as a guest. AP used...
Need some help with a song..
I use to listen to a song that I can't completely remember.. I'm pretty sure it's classic rock.. I...
Rock and Roll
Who still loves classic rock?
Newer music not so good?
I am a fairly young person, and I seem to be shunning all the new music that is coming out lately....
About Sanctyfied!
Sanctyfied is a husband and wife team that started a band awhile back. Instead of making the music...
The 70s or anything retro
Who in here is retro? I know I am. I am really into the 70s and I'm only 21 years old. I totally...
sponsors
Pearl Jam Lyrics
All Pearl Jam Song Lyrics -- #1 Lyric Site On The Net.
songlyric-site.com
Classical Music Downloads
Stop paying for music. Download classical songs for free. 100% legal.
www.mpfree.com
Elizabethan Classics - Free S/H
20%-50% Off Retail Pricing. Wholesale Prices & Fast, Free S/H.
www.efaucets.com
Used Honda Pilots at Yahoo!
Certified Used Cars in Washington, DC. Shop for a Honda Used Car.
www.honda.com/yahoo
nuclear medicine technology jobs washington dc
Find Jobs in Nuclear Medicine - Search Washingtonpost.com Now.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
Washington Rock Climbs
Cragging or alpine rock climbing, beginner or advanced, we guide it.
www.mountainmadness.com
health testing
Looking For health testing In Your Area. Call Now.
TheQualityOfLifeGroup.Local.com
Young Frankenstein the Musical
Don't miss the musical this holiday season! Tickets start at $37 here.
Kennedy-Center.org
Special David Bowie Album
2-Disc "Space Oddity"anniversary set feat. 8 new songs. Get it here.
amazon.com/davidbowie
Auto Insurance Agents
Find auto insurance agencies & brokers serving Washington DC.
yellowpages.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.