sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

comic books vs. graphic novels email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading3 months ago

Do you think there is a difference between the two? I never have (I love comics btw) but I know people who get very defensive if you call their graphic novels comic books.

Teach me, oh mylot. Teach me the difference between graphic novels and comic books.

 
 
reading
sponsors
OppenheimerFunds
We Can Help You Navigate The Changing Financial Markets.
www.OppenheimerFunds.com

Florida Masters Degree
Read This Before You Apply. Flexible Masters Classes, Evenings
www.Webster.edu/StPetersburg

Auto Glass Repair Service
There is a Lot Riding Behind Your Windshield! Get a Quote Online.
www.RoyalGlass.DanMattMedia.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  comic books, graphic novels, comics
 
1. myLot reputation of 73/100. Tantrums (946)   ranked 4,168 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

Now that you've mentioned it... I don't know too.. Graphic novel is a narrative work in which the story is conveyed to the reader using the comics form. A comic book (often shortened to simply comic and sometimes called a funny book, comic paper or comic magazine) is a magazine made up of narrative artwork, often accompanied by dialog (usually in word balloons, emblematic of the comic book artform) and often including brief descriptive prose. I still don't get it, what's the difference then? I call it Comics you call it graphic novel?


myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

Let's just call them picture books!

OppenheimerFunds We Can Help You Navigate The Changing Financial Markets. www.OppenheimerFunds.com
 
2. roadki11 (26)   ranked 9,420 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

A graphic novel stands alone as a complete story.

A comic book is a serial where, any one comic book is just a short glimpse of part of the story.

That is essentially it. It's like the difference between a T.V. show and a movie.

Graphic novels tend to be more sophisticated and have very adult content but that isn't necessary in order to be considered a graphic novel.


myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

That makes sense. Thank you!

Florida Masters Degree Read This Before You Apply. Flexible Masters Classes, Evenings www.Webster.edu/StPetersburg
 
3. myLot reputation of 50/100. Anora_Eldorath (2598)   ranked 1,495 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

Death-

I'm currently writing my master thesis on graphic novels, and yes there is a difference. A comic book is an illustrated short story with many plots that vary from episode to episode. A graphic novel is any illustrated story with one main plot, divided into chapters. It's much the same as the difference between a short story and novel.

Namaste-Anora


myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

So you're saying that Transmetropolitan by Warren Ellis would be a graphic novel while Sandman by Neil Gaiman would be a comic book?


myLot reputation of 50/100. Anora_Eldorath (2598)   ranked 1,495 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

I've not read either so I cannot say. I can say that Spiderman, Dark Knight, etc are comic books. Stories such as Inuyahsa, Ronin Kenshin and those in the Manga publication are graphic novels. 300 for example is a graphic novel rather then a comic book. Hope that helps. Enjoy your reading!

Auto Glass Repair Service There is a Lot Riding Behind Your Windshield! Get a Quote Online. www.RoyalGlass.DanMattMedia.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 78/100. goat6boy (171)   ranked 2,594 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

well a comic book is where the story continues weekly or bi weekly and a graphic novel is usually one story finished in one book.i love a good graphic novel and i dont mean a manga i mean like 30 days of night or even sin city


myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

that's he problem for me. Some of what are considered "graphic novels" were comics. They went out on a schedule in small doses. Hence my confusion.

G.I. Joe Complete Boxset The Complete G.I. Joe 1980's Animated Series.Plus The Movie. www.CompleteSeries.tv
 
5. myLot reputation of 94/100. Jennlk84 (2252)   ranked 147 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

This isn't by any means the TRUE definition of the two - but I will give you my thoughts! My husband reads both comics AND graphic novels. When he says he's going to go read a comic book, I think of the individual comic books that are like 20 pages long, paperback, real thin. If he says he's going to go read a Graphic Novel I think of one of the bigger, hard cover books. I believe the Graphic Novels are different because they contain the entire series or at least a significant amount of a series in one. So it would be like 10 comic books in one.

Extreme Graphics Drivers Update your Extreme Graphics w/ Official Drivers. Free download. ExtremeGraphics.Driver-Fix.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 99/100. ElicBxn (15097)   ranked 52 out of 10,241 in reading   3 months ago

I think the difference is that a graphic novel could be written as a normal book, just better described with pictures than words

A comic isn't as easily transferred to a story with words, its more picture driven than story driven.

Comic Books Original Comic Books and More� You Might Find Something You Like. www.KochComicArt.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 95/100. lordcaocao2025 (533)   3 months ago

I never know the difference between those two. I call every book that tell story with picture is a comic book. Now i realise that i am wrong. Well maybe i try to search more info about those two, so i will not get laughed at when i wrongly say a graphics novel as a comic books


myLot reputation of 78/100. deathspectacular (784)   ranked 1,111 out of 10,241 in reading  3 months ago

Don't worry about it too much. From my experience there are only a small majority of people who care about the difference. I was just curious.

Book Comic Discounted Comic Books Graphic novels, comic books and more at discounted prices. www.zaldiva.com
 
8. AllenWiggs (4)   7 hours ago

Actually the difference is not topic, subject, or anything else. It is simply format. A comic book is the typical format you would see when you think of a comic. Magazine like and anywhere from 16 to 100 pages (sometimes even more). A collection of these is called a trade (trade paper back for soft cover, and hardcover for well hardcover), a trade has a more permanent binding and is designed to remain in good quality for longer, sometimes these also get called graphic novels. Mostly to differentiate themselves from comics (which are for kids you know!). Now an original story (not a reprint of old material) in the same format as a trade is a graphic novel.

Examples of comics are Batman, The Amazing Spider-Man, 300, Sandman, and Transmetropolitan.

Examples of graphic novels are Batman: Arkham Asylum, Scott Pilgrim, Channel Zero, and Dramacon.

Wacom Graphics Tablet Drivers Update your Wacom Graphics Tablet w/ Official Drivers. Free download. www.Driver-Fix.com/wacomgraphics
 
sponsors
G.I. Joe Complete Boxset
The Complete G.I. Joe 1980's Animated Series.Plus The Movie.
www.CompleteSeries.tv

Extreme Graphics Drivers
Update your Extreme Graphics w/ Official Drivers. Free download.
ExtremeGraphics.Driver-Fix.com

Comic Books
Original Comic Books and More� You Might Find Something You Like.
www.KochComicArt.com

similar discussions
Do u notice that all super hero movies are based on male super heroes?
Well recently I've noticed that all the movies being made lately are always based on male super...
Comic books: Where do you prefer to get them?
Do you prefer to get them from people online, from trading with friends, from the big book stores...
comic books are good for kids
No, really, they are. "Researchers believe they can benefit from tales about the caped...
Favourite comic book?
Hi there friends.... Comic books are a part of the childhood of many of us here... Almost every...
Zatanna
Catching up on my old school Zatanna, I'm really enjoying Zatanna: Come Together though the artwork...
If You Had One Super Power Which Would You Pick?
If you had one super power to pick from which would you pick?Super powers:1. Flying 2....
Do you like Superman or Incredible man better??????
You think who you love more. For me i like Superman more than Incredible man, because Superman has...
superheroes
who is your favorite superhero. I like batman. the only one that is using his mind as a power. hes...
Anyone Else Enjoy Fanfic?
Okay I'm going to disclose one of my guilty pleasures here - I enjoy reading fan fiction (fanfic)...
Oh it is the comics they want now?
Did you ever read comics, well I read alot during my childhood and loved all those characters, this...
sponsors
G.I. Joe Complete Boxset
The Complete G.I. Joe 1980's Animated Series.Plus The Movie.
www.CompleteSeries.tv
Extreme Graphics Drivers
Update your Extreme Graphics w/ Official Drivers. Free download.
ExtremeGraphics.Driver-Fix.com
Comic Books
Original Comic Books and More� You Might Find Something You Like.
www.KochComicArt.com
Book Comic Discounted Comic Books
Graphic novels, comic books and more at discounted prices.
www.zaldiva.com
Wacom Graphics Tablet Drivers
Update your Wacom Graphics Tablet w/ Official Drivers. Free download.
www.Driver-Fix.com/wacomgraphics
Holiday Inn Express Washi
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more.
National.Citysearch.com
Crowne Plaza Hotel Tysons
Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more.
Washingtondc.Citysearch.com
Chat Comic
Find Your Soulmate & True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile.
Singles-Date.com/ChatComic
All Romance E-Books & Novels
Let your fantasies run free at All Romance E-Books. View our novels.
AllRomanceeBooks.com
Matchman Comic
Get Matched to Sexy Singles in Your Area for Free! Sign-up Now.
MatchmanComic.come-date.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.