sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

A very sad day.  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527) 3 years ago

Hi everyone,

I am a 40 year old woman who was born and brought up in India. Our family was not very privileged and we could only manage to make two ends meet. Time passed, I finished my education and got married to a very sweet and kind doctor. We now live in the UK and are fairly well off, him being a Respiratory Consultant. I try never to forget where I came from.

Last month I was in India with my 12 year old daughter who wanted to see my childhood home. It was a small flat in a very poor part of the town. I had vivid memories of this place, the children, the trees, the fruits we picked, the games we played. However miserable it was, it still was my childhood. But, as we got off our car and began to walk about the streets, several pairs of eyes started to stare at us. Maybe, we appeared very foreign to them. I was no longer 'one' of them.

Soon we were stopped by a very loud and rude resident, who started to question us about our purpose for wandering in that place. I was speechless and chose to ask him to stop bothering us. People gathered up to watch the drama. The man kept pestering us to get a reaction and I nearly broke into tears telling him 'this behind me is my childhood home and this here is my daughter who has come with me to see it'. The man and the crowd to my surprise was very unsympathetic and wanted us to leave the area. I took a last look at my house and left the place crying.
Wondering why we were recieved with such hostility!

Before this incident, I used to often dream of this place where I am still being the little child that I was, with my young parents in the background. But last week I had a very depressing dream where my daughter is standing by me in a very similar surrounding and I am begging a stubborn old man to let us pass so we could have a look.

I am unable to disassociate my childhood memories from this bitter experience no matter how many ways I think of it. My daughter who had gone with me to have an experience of her own came home extremely sad. I feel especially sorry for her who did not deserve it in any way. I had plans to ask the local people about my long lost friends, but that sounds illogical now. I do not 'want' to go back to this place but the thought of not being able to revisit a place from my youth is very unsettling.

Any advice, counselling, input or criticism to change the way I am taking all this is welcome.

Kindly comment.
Hugs
Autumn

 

sponsors
people
Get current information on people. Easy to use, search for free.
www.usa-people-search.com

BlueMax HD Lights for SAD
Full Spectrum Light Therapy Products at Factory Direct Pricing!
www.fullspectrumsolutions.com

Earth Day Puzzles
Fun materials to celebrate Earth Day - puzzles, reading, and more.
edhelper.com/caring_for_earth.htm

StarBright (1429) response was accepted on 10/7/2009.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  sad, day, india, people, childhood
 
1. myLot reputation of 96/100. jwfarrimond (3266)   3 years ago

It sounds like a clear case of envy to me. All that they could see was this rich woman walking about like a tourist. It's often not a good idea to try and revisit your childhood, it won't be the same, things change, people change, die, or move away. I understand your desire to show your daughter where it was that you grew up, but it was probably not a good idea.


myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527)  3 years ago

Hi JW,

Thanks a bunch for your comment. I think you are spot on. Revisiting your childhood is nearly always a wrong choice to make.

Huggles.

people Get current information on people. Easy to use, search for free.  www.usa-people-search.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 94/100. learn2earn (16936)   3 years ago

Well, going back to where we started is a good decision on your part. It is just unfortunate that there are people who want to ruin you and think that they can put you out. I believe that you don't need to quit going back to where your life started. I believe that all things work together for good to many people who believe. Don't allow such things to ruin your day. You are still alive. Enjoy life and pray for those who persecute you.


myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527)  3 years ago

How sweet!

Thanks for those touching words. I will go back there as and when I feel like. Nothing can take that right away from me ^.^

Hugs


myLot reputation of 94/100. learn2earn (16936)  3 years ago

Of course, nobody has the right to take it away from you. And don't allow anyone to do that..thumbup

BlueMax HD Lights for SAD Full Spectrum Light Therapy Products at Factory Direct Pricing!  www.fullspectrumsolutions.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 94/100. StarBright (1429)   3 years ago

Hello Autumn953. I am so sorry for your sad experience. I can only imagine how you must have felt trying to go home and show your darling daughter your roots. I am close friends with an Indian family and I had the pleasure of visiting your country India a year ago. I had some insight into the culture. It sounds like you went alone with your daughter to your old neighborhood. Perhaps that is why this man had issues with you.

When my sister and I visited in southern India for a month, they stressed to us the importance of never going anywhere alone as a woman. They said it was not considered safe for women to travel alone. Women should always have a male relative with them - a husband, brother, father, uncle. even older son. There are some Indian men who just do not understand and will not accept a woman traveling anywhere alone. They consider a woman alone like a harlot.

The family that we visited, also had once lived in extreme poverty and now live very well. They bought property and have built a beautiful home. When they invited friends from the old neighborhood to their home, their old friends would not come. This hurt our friends very much. It seems that once our friends moved up in status, they were not even welcome in the old neighborhood.

Do not be totally dismayed by this experience. Use it as a teaching tool for your daughter. There are many facets to India. Teach your daughter everything about her culture. She should know the good, the bad and the ugly. There is so much beauty in the Indian culture, so much history. It is young people like her who will change the world because they see the world from all sides. God bless.


myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527)  3 years ago

It is very comforting to know that there are people like you out there that belong to distant cultures, yet they take such deep interest in other people's way of life.

Your message is so eloquently written and most of all so genuine. You got it absolutely right when you said that 'There are some Indian men who just do not understand and will not accept a woman travelling anywhere alone. They consider a woman alone like a harlot.'

Rofl, it is something I grew up with ... being around caring male relatives and yet, I completely blew it when I forgot to consider this as I went back to my old house. Thanks for the advice. Next time, I will go there with my husband and I 'know' the people will hold their tongues in his presence.

Big hug
Autumn

Autumn


myLot reputation of 99/100. fjaril (6097)  3 years ago

Starbright.. your name is very apt. You speak eloquently and knowledgeably and with a comforting overtone that even I can relate to with visits I have had back to my homeland(s).
So nice to meet you here and this way. You have touched my heart also with your words of wisdom. Thankyou sincerely!


myLot reputation of 99/100. fjaril (6097)  3 years ago

Autumn953.. we have met a lovely person here today and I am glad she came to your discussion. Her understanding is so sound, isn't it?. She is a gem, a jewel amoung us and her words speak to me as well. I do hope you feel the same.
Nice to meet you and I am so very glad I dropped by here today! Take care!


myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527)  3 years ago

You can say that again Fjaril. Loved the way it restored my faith in empathy, she must have a beautiful soul. Straightaway undid the hurtful damage. It is because of people like you and StarBright and all the other lovely people on this thread, that it seems silly to give up on the human beings lol.

Hugs
Autumn


myLot reputation of 94/100. StarBright (1429)  3 years ago

Fjaril and Autumn953 you are both very kind. It is because of generous people like you that I enjoy MYLOT so much. I am so happy to have made two wonderful new friends. Thank you.

Earth Day Puzzles Fun materials to celebrate Earth Day - puzzles, reading, and more.  edhelper.com/caring_for_earth.htm
 
4. myLot reputation of 91/100. jlamela (3837)   3 years ago

That's pretty bad and depressing indeed, because instead of receiving a warm welcome from your countrymen and former neighbors, you ended up being harassed and ostracized.

Well, this case can be attributed to a xenophobia, you know the condition in which people in the neighborhood are afraid or intimidated by "foreigners"and since you gone to other country for so long, they regarded you now as foreigner too. There are people also who envied other people achievements, you know things like that.

What you are to do now is just take it as it is because there's nothing you can do about it because you cannot change their perception and maybe because they have different understanding about people living in a foreign land.

So try to explain it to your daughter and just look life in a positive and happy disposition.

For Black People -63% Great deals on For Black People! Compare prices and save up to 63%.  www.For-Black-People.best-deal.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 87/100. cutepink_13 (539)   3 years ago

we cannot please everybody even our relatives are also judgmental. maybe that person is jealous of you so instead of showing his or her jealousy to you he or she turn the jealousy into anger.

Top For Black People -57% For Black People at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!  www.For-Black-People.news72.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 84/100. NurseMathilda (170)   3 years ago

Thanks for sharing us your story on your journey back home eventhough it does not result to something good. The more I think about it is that those people probably are envious of you because you are already different from them. Maybe the way you dress, speak and walk. What you can do is to still be positive in life and think that you can never really please anyone. If you have not showed anything rude to them, then it is not your problem anymore. As long as you didn't say or show them anything bad, there's nothing to be guilty of. It's not your fault that you got lucky and now living a good life.

Bipolar Disorder Symptoms Learn Symptoms of Bipolar Disorder & Depression + Treatment Option  www.lakeviewhealth.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 96/100. wookieekyut (488)   3 years ago

I felt so sorry for your daughter. I am sure that was a trip she never enjoyed. Don't you have relatives in the area who could have showed you around and shielded you from these people?

Discount For Black People For Black People at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products  www.For-Black-People.best-price.com
 
8. hurvee (8)   3 years ago

Envy exists. people who cannot see a way out of their misery in life constantly do that. For them it is a way of venting their frustration for inequality in life. Unfortunately, it is not just right to hurt other people in d the process. That was a sad day indeed.

Online People Search 1) Enter Any Name & Search Free! 2) Get Phone, Address, Age & More.  www.Intelius.com/PeopleSearch
 
9. myLot reputation of 87/100. scarletwitch12 (274)   3 years ago

It is refreshing to see someone who despite having achieved a certain level of success had never forgotten about her roots. It is afterall what we had to go through that defines us as people. I admire your desire to go back and show your daughter your past home.

Unfortunately, not everyone from your past had been able to reach that illusive dream of finding a better life for themselves and their families. For these people, they feel that people who have more than they do would only look down on them so no matter what your intentions were, they would still regard you with hostility. It may be right that they show this amount of aggression because they are envious of what you have become. This is not your fault. Your intention was never to make things hard for them in the first place.
It is sad when we no longer feel welcome in the place we used to call home but you have nothing to feel guilty about. Whatever you have, you have achieved because you worked hard for it. If they cannot accept that, it is not your problem.
What you can do is teach your daughter not to feel hate towards these people no matter how hostile they may have been. It is the utmost sign of virtue to teach someone to love and respect despite difficult circumstances. One day, what will matter is how much we have given and not how much acceptance we were able to receive.
Keep your head up.


myLot reputation of 89/100. Autumn953 (1527)  3 years ago

Scarlet

The reason why I started this thread was because I could not get this chapter of my life out of my head. I wanted advice and opinions of sensitive people so that I could get a reason, a point of view to look positively at it all. And your sincere message did just that. You read my message and replied with such interest.

This makes Mylot a site that actually offers unadulterated advice. Thanks a bunch.

Love
Autumn

Mothers Day Looking For Mothers Day? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
10. myLot reputation of 88/100. ryheanne (114)   3 years ago

I am just startled why they acted like that? Any bad memories from the past? They must welcome you because atleast you still remember where you from. But I guess they envy you, just move on.

Call India Free Now Get 2 Hours of Free calling to India today. Try & Buy  UnlimitedIndiaCalling.com
 
sponsors
For Black People -63%
Great deals on For Black People! Compare prices and save up to 63%.
www.For-Black-People.best-deal.com

Top For Black People -57%
For Black People at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.For-Black-People.news72.com

Bipolar Disorder Symptoms
Learn Symptoms of Bipolar Disorder& Depression + Treatment Option
www.lakeviewhealth.com

similar discussions
How do you keep yourself happy in sad times?
Hey guys, I was just wondering how you keep yourself happy in sad times? we all have ups and downs...
nerves
Hi, I just wanted to if anyone here ever had nerves for no reason at all...well from sudden...
Are you holding onto something you need to let go of?
I've been trying to let go of this feeling that makes me so sad, so mad, so lonely! This is so hard...
Were you sad at the end?
Braveheart was a really interesting story about a very brave man. It is very touching in my opinion...
how to find mr. rite
how do you girls find mr. rite i have been looking for him and never to seemed to haved found him...
Is this a technical problem?
After a long gap, I am ill due to diabetic neuropathy, I tried to work in mylot, signed in to my...
maybe i am too old and getting very sensitive
it seems that i put myself always in the other's shoes especially those stories which are very sad....
I Am Worried About Him...
My husband is having such a hard time with this whole comp stuff. He is stressing more than I am...
Do you like sad ending movies?? Which do you prefer: sad ending or happy ending?
Or do you prefer happy ending movies? I always hated sad ending movies because I feel like that's...
I Lost my Cat
Some of you may remember that we got our first cat back in February. Well, today we lost him. I'm...
sponsors
For Black People -63%
Great deals on For Black People! Compare prices and save up to 63%.
www.For-Black-People.best-deal.com
Top For Black People -57%
For Black People at bargain prices: Compare offers and save up to 57%!
www.For-Black-People.news72.com
Bipolar Disorder Symptoms
Learn Symptoms of Bipolar Disorder & Depression + Treatment Option
www.lakeviewhealth.com
Discount For Black People
For Black People at Best-Price.com! Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products
www.For-Black-People.best-price.com
Online People Search
1) Enter Any Name & Search Free! 2) Get Phone, Address, Age & More.
www.Intelius.com/PeopleSearch
Mothers Day
Looking For Mothers Day? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Call India Free Now
Get 2 Hours of Free calling to India today. Try & Buy
UnlimitedIndiaCalling.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.