What do you think of hermonie? Is she just brilliant or the lady luck favors her

hey ashvan hermonie is brilliant as she has saved in many occasions with her spells which she studied herself as she is muggle born.

I think hermione is brillinat rather a lucky girl. What she excels in presence of mind in very tense and dangerous occasion. she can think efficiently at the moment when other people may fumble/scare(like ron). Plus she hige amounts of knowledge behing her. And she is also brave and luck favors the brave!!!

I think Hermione is brilliant for her age and probably the 11-25s in the HP world, but she has been very very lucky to survive against Lord Voldemort who was the greatest ever student Hogwarts has EVER had and magically stronger than Dumbledore. Yet Harry, Hermione and Ron somehow managed to stay alive when he was trying to kill them all... I would say she is brilliant and very lucky.

Lucky would not seem to discribe her, other than that she was lucky to have gotten the gene to be a witch even with normal parents. She is smart, book smart anyway. through hard study and a very good memory she has learned what she needs to save the day, and the boys again and again. The school would be closed, and the boys would be dead if she were not there to help.

Hi, ashvan
Hermione Granger is brilliant and very diligent on learning everything about the magical world and everything else. She is not just brilliant by coincidence, she also reads and analyzes the things she learned. That is why she gets it all right, not by luck.

Have a nice day!

I think she's a little bit of both. She has the brains to work out almost any situation. Buit when it comes to trying to get out of those situations while in immediate danger I think it's lady luck on her side. Hermione is a book smart young lady who, under normal circumstances, can show Harry up. But add in danger and it takes her a little while to think of a solution.