sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Movies based on true murders  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 93/100. UmiNoor (1384)   ranked 69 out of 10,796 in watching movies 3 years ago

I'm reading this book about notorious crimes. And one chapter was about notorious murderers/murderess. And there were details of their crimes and also some extra information about their crimes being made into movies like the crime of Juliet Hulme and Pauline Parker who killed Pauline's mother because they believed that her mother was trying to break up their friendship. This was made into a movie by Peter Jackson "Heavenly Creatures". And the most recent movie "An American Crime" was based on the true murder of Sylvia Marie.

How do you feel about movies based on true murders? Some of them are pretty sensationalized like Natural Born Killers which was inspired by the true crimes of Charlie Starkweather and his girlfriend. The movie inspired another pair of teenagers to commit similar crimes.

Don't you think by dramatizing these crimes, film producers are romanticizing these crimes and impressionable teenagers will want to emulate them especially if the actors or actresses who play the parts are those that they idolize?

 

watching movies
sponsors
Man Cheats Credit Score
He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.
www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com

Reputable Online JD
Designed for Working Professionals; Distinguished Faculty; Low Cost
www.stfrancislaw.com

Low Cost Bail Bondsmen
Get Fast, Cheap Bail - Search here
yellowpages.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  true crimes, true murder movies, true murders
 
1. myLot reputation of 92/100. dlr297 (2879)   ranked 450 out of 10,796 in watching movies   3 years ago

I agree with you they do make big impressions on the young minds of our teens. But i also believe that the teens that would commit crimes like these have problems to begin with, and if they did not copy the movie they would eventually do something else,


myLot reputation of 93/100. UmiNoor (1384)   ranked 69 out of 10,796 in watching movies  3 years ago

Yeah I guess so but the movie might be a trigger.


myLot reputation of 92/100. dlr297 (2879)   ranked 450 out of 10,796 in watching movies  3 years ago

Yes i agree that the movie could be the trigger, but if they do not have it in them to do something like that the movie will do nothing.

Man Cheats Credit Score He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.  www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 93/100. dasani (4202)   3 years ago

hi UmiNoor

Yes, true crime movies are very sensational.
I don’t know if you’ve watched THE STEPFATHER? This movie was based on the true story of a mass murderer, John List. Very scary. I saw the original movie of 1987 and now there is a new remake of it out in theaters. Another true crime movie I saw recently that is quite disturbing is RIVER’S EDGE, a dark social based on actual events.
Both movies were really good.

I have no clue if Crime stories could inspire violent acts regarding teenagers or anyone for that matter. But I speculate it could very well happen. It’s certainly a controversial subject that needs to be sorted out.



myLot reputation of 93/100. UmiNoor (1384)   ranked 69 out of 10,796 in watching movies  3 years ago

Violence breed violence. If our children are brought up in a world full of violence they might think that violence is the norm and act accordingly. I don't like movies that romanticize violence and crimes like Bonnie And Clyde. Sociologists have done research on children who are brought up by parents who are criminals and they found that these children think that what their parents do are okay and not wrong. So if our children are constantly exposed to violence in movies and television, they might think that it's all right to be violent. That is a scary thought.

Reputable Online JD Designed for Working Professionals; Distinguished Faculty; Low Cost  www.stfrancislaw.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 93/100. crimsonladybug (2533)   ranked 64 out of 10,796 in watching movies   3 years ago

I love horror movies but I hate the slasher kind and all of the horror movies that are based on true stories (Hostel, the Hills Have Eyes) end up being slasher movies. But I do like the crime drama approach like Zodiac with Jake Gyllenhaal or Black Dahlia with Josh Hartnett. Both of these movies focused more on the people trying to solve the murders than on the actual murder so I don't think there is a lot of chance of teens (or anyone) using them as inspiration for committing their own murders. But, yeah, in cases like Natural Born Killers that focus on the killers, I can see where it could but I agree with the person above who said if they will kill someone because of a movie they probably would have killed someone without the movie, it just maybe wouldn't have been as graphic.


myLot reputation of 93/100. UmiNoor (1384)   ranked 69 out of 10,796 in watching movies  3 years ago

Natural Born Killers is one movie that sensationalize and romanticize violence and I think it shouldn't be watched by young children and teenagers. Even I cannot stand the violence depicted in the movie.

Low Cost Bail Bondsmen Get Fast, Cheap Bail - Search here  yellowpages.com
 
sponsors
Money Market Rates
CD& Money Market Rates. Search and Compare for Higher Bank Rates.
bankrate.com/Rates

Mutual Fund
Secure Your Future. Get Top Mutual Fund Advice. Free Info Avaiable Now.
auroramutual.com

About Mutual Funds
Looking For About Mutual Funds? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com

sponsors
Money Market Rates
CD & Money Market Rates. Search and Compare for Higher Bank Rates.
bankrate.com/Rates
Mutual Fund
Secure Your Future. Get Top Mutual Fund Advice. Free Info Avaiable Now.
auroramutual.com
About Mutual Funds
Looking For About Mutual Funds? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Money Market Rates
Get The Best Money Market Rates With Exclusive Online Offers.
firstcountybank.com
Online Stock Broker
- Faster Trades and Lower Costs. Start Trading Stocks Today... for Free
RealFastTrader.com/Stocks
Mortgage Rates Hit 2.50%
If you owe under $729k you may qualify for 3.01% APR Govt Refi Plans.
www.SeeRefinanceRates.com
5 Growth Stocks for 2012
Discover Your Best Opportunities For Safe Portfolio Growth.
www.insideinvestingdaily.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.