sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Cartoon vs. Anime  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532) 3 years ago

Between American Cartoons and Japanese anime, which one do you prefer more? Usually Japanese anime have better character designs and stories , They also have different Target markets from kids, to teens to grown ups. American Cartoons usually have ugly drawings but there usually funnier and less perverted, (anime always have some perversion on it) There were Cartoons with good illustration though but not as phenomenal as anime. Both Cartoons and Anime have a more mature and serious plots sometimes. Anyway I was a bit upset that American animators started to make Cartoon characters with Anime like appearance. I do have my fair share of Cartoons and anime though but I usually preferred anime but I don't think kids should be watching them because of the mature language and violence.

 

anime
sponsors
World Dance Pole Leader
Platinum Stages offers the best in fitness dance poles and accessories
www.platinumstages.com

pole dance
Want to learn a sexy, exciting new form of exercise? Find it here.
www.poledancingclasses.org

Children's Hospital
Local Children's Hospital Listings. Search Your Listings at Local.com.
Health.Local.com

AllenWiggs (382) response was accepted on 3/3/2010.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  anime, cartoons, adult swim, america, animation
 
1. myLot reputation of 80/100. rovian (1529)   ranked 147 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

There were decent cartoons in the past such as Titan A.E, and Pirates of Dark Water but most of the new cartoons now rely on stupidity which seems to be the new trend. Even The Incredible Hulk was effected. This was a monster of rage in the movies, and cartoon from the 90th, but in the new kids cartoon, The Super Hero Squad Show, he was transformed into an idiot joke of himself. I prefer Anime more for the better action and stories, and not every Anime has perversion in them such as Ronin Warriors but this is an older one. Transformers is also Anime but Transformers Animated, was one version made by an American company. From the scenes I've seen of it, it wasn't as good in my opinion. They behaved too much like humans drinking oil as a beverage, and one appeared as if he was overweight.


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

I dont like the anime version of cartoons and I dont want to see a cartoon version of an anime.

World Dance Pole Leader Platinum Stages offers the best in fitness dance poles and accessories  www.platinumstages.com
 
2. warlordluke (43)   ranked 362 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

I'm going for Anime on this because I never have liked American cartoons, anime always does it for me because of the way the characters are designed and the whole depth to it using music to invoke deep emotions and various other things it's much much better than american cartoons.


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

Anime can be taken seriously by adults but its a different case in cartoons, they still look aweful even if they tried converting to CGI.

pole dance Want to learn a sexy, exciting new form of exercise? Find it here.  www.poledancingclasses.org
 
3. myLot reputation of 89/100. scaflone8 (170)   ranked 568 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

I really like anime due to the unique plot of each story. Japanese are really know for their eccentric ideas and always taking it to the next step which i like on the story plots. I also like cartoons but lately i fail to find good stories nowadays


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

Th3e japs never ran out of stories they were always able to serve something new to the plate.

Children's Hospital Local Children's Hospital Listings. Search Your Listings at Local.com.  Health.Local.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 96/100. saizo6 (1456)   ranked 4 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

If I were to compare today's American cartoons with Japanese anime, I'm going to have to say that anime is way better. I'm not a fan of today's cartoons. It's not the animation or anything like that, I just find it lacking. This is probably because I'm usually comparing it with the cartoon shows that I watched as a kid which I thought was a lot better. Anime has a more wide range of genre to choose from. There's actually a story unlike American cartoons which is more episodic.


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

Cartoon episodes have tendencies to be irelevant to each other while in anime we were enjoying sagas and chapters.

Fresno Anime Convention Largest anime con in the central valley  http://www.ani-jam.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 90/100. AllenWiggs (382)   ranked 578 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

They both have their draws and I really don't know if I could call one better then the other based solely on content, I mean technically anime would have to be better as there is more of it made per year then there is cartoons for American television, so based on the simple law of 90% of everything is complete crap and the other 10% is good to great, anime wins hands down.

As for your other points, I don't find there being an issue of the American cartoons gaining anime traits. When it's just the art style, well that does seem a bit silly, I agree. But let us not forget that a lot of the shows kids watched in the 80s was out of Japan and WAS anime, Voltron and Speed Racer for example, while Thundercats and Silver Hawks while both created by American companies were designed and animated by Japanese and had an anime look and feel that was current with the time. Plus borrowing from anime made one of the best cartoons in the last decade, Avatar: the Last Airbender. There is much to be learned and adapted from anime, like telling a story, and having definitive endings.

Also finally, anime is not by definition filled with mature language and violence. There is anime for all age groups in Japan. There are kids shows, shows for teens, and shows for adults. It is not just the stuff we see on Adult Swim or Hentai. There is also things that are bereft of violence all together or are no more violent then an episode of Looney Toons, and many MANY series exist that are perfect for kids.


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

Anime had a more diverse market for all shapes and sizes,They never run out of ideas and concepts. They can get serious and they can get funny. I had seen cartoons eith serious themes but they always lack the appeal. Anime can entertain people of all cultures while Cartoon seemed to appeal more for American alone but its hard to market abroad. I can see people buying more anime merchandise than cartoon ones.

GIF Web Animation Studio Design high-quality pictures for web site  myinternetstore.newweblab.com
 
6. MaxMouseG (4)   ranked 577 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

I prefer anime.. American cartoons are poorly drawn and most of them are just plain lame comedy stuff for 2 year olds...


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

Some of them dont make sense at all and they suck intelligence out of your brain, its really frustrating.

DMC Children's Hospital Quality care from top pediatricians at Children's Hospital of MI.  www.ChildrensDMC.org
 
7. myLot reputation of 51/100. munchiez117 (309)   ranked 570 out of 939 in anime   3 years ago

i would say that they both have their ups and downs not every anime show is cool neither are the u.s ones yes anime does follows more of a story but the story can be repeated several times with different shows.
besides the u.s makes more comedy cartoons becuase its cheaper
there are quite a few that are funny.


myLot reputation of 96/100. albertwhisker (4532)  3 years ago

I know there were some decent cartoons and there were awful animes.

The Cleansing of America W. Cleon Skousen's newest Book. How America will be cleansed!  www.MyFreedomLibrary.com
 
8. kiel_d_01 (96)   ranked 441 out of 939 in anime   2 years ago

anime the best wahahahah!!!

1.5¢ Surgical Face Masks Why pay 9¢ or more Sameday shipping Stops Droplets From Being Spread  www.mcgillswarehouse.com
 
sponsors
Fresno Anime Convention
Largest anime con in the central valley
http://www.ani-jam.com

GIF Web Animation Studio
Design high-quality pictures for web site
myinternetstore.newweblab.com

DMC Children's Hospital
Quality care from top pediatricians at Children's Hospital of MI.
www.ChildrensDMC.org

similar discussions
Do you stop at just the manga?
Manga fans, do you stop at just the manga? What I mean by this is...after you read a manga series,...
One Piece Lovers!...
Does anyone here love one piece?... its getting and getting interesting...
Naruto Manga UPDATE...
does any one want to talk about the updates of Naruto?...
can you give me some new cool anime titles with an adult protagonist?
I think during the 90's such anime exist but now most anime have a highschool student as a main...
Do you still watch anime or any cartoor series?
I still do, even I'm 25 years old now. Is it bad?
CARTOON/ANIME FANATICS!!!! no AGE LIMITS...
There are lots of movies on tv to choose from. Horror, suspense, drama and even full of laughs. One...
The most cookie cutter anime protagonist prototypes
I remember my self making a discussion before about anime cliche and this one is a bit related, but...
i really like conan
i really like conan for ran..even though i know that edogawa conan and shinichi kudo are the same...
shocking truth
In my past anime discussions I ranted on how Hentai is ruining the anime industry in Japan, but I...
How Many Among Us Here Are Anime Lovers?
I love to watch lots of anime shows. My youngest son is the one who provides the downloaded items...
sponsors
Fresno Anime Convention
Largest anime con in the central valley
http://www.ani-jam.com
GIF Web Animation Studio
Design high-quality pictures for web site
myinternetstore.newweblab.com
DMC Children's Hospital
Quality care from top pediatricians at Children's Hospital of MI.
www.ChildrensDMC.org
The Cleansing of America
W. Cleon Skousen's newest Book. How America will be cleansed!
www.MyFreedomLibrary.com
1.5¢ Surgical Face Masks
Why pay 9¢ or more Sameday shipping Stops Droplets From Being Spread
www.mcgillswarehouse.com
3D Animation Services
27+ Years Proven Results Creating 3D Technical & Branding Animation
www.adtechinc.com
Business Opportunity
Premium Italian Wine Selection Distribution Opportunities
fastyourtr.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.