sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

Anime vs. Cartoons.  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 91/100. Virginians (229) 6 years ago

I am twenty three years old, and I'm the first to admit that yes I still watch cartoons. Why? Because I can, and I enjoy them. There are of course, non-cartoon shows that I watch as well. They're just harder to captivate and hold my attention long term, meaning keep me coming back each week. I also watch Anime, I love Anime. And if there is one thing that drives me absolutely insane- is when someone calls anime, cartoons. I realize that some anime could fall into the category of cartoons like most children watch. For example: Pokemon, Yugi-Oh, Digimon, Etc. Those are all anime, but they're children's anime. The anime I prefer, for the most part is more of an adult anime. It falls full across the spectrum, it really does. You have the children's anime as I mentioned before, things like Pokemon. Then you have the middle spectrum, which would be anime like Naruto, Inyuasha, One Piece, and then you have the more adult anime such as Ghost in the Shell, Akira, S-Cry-Ed. There are many more, that fall into various categories. There is even Anime known as Hentai- which is basically Japanese animated porno. But it's animated! So if you're going to call all Anime cartoons, then wouldn't you have to call Hentai a cartoon as well? Mmm, I bet most parents wouldn't. So next time you want to say something about how Anime is childish, remember this little rant. Anime is not like the cartoons your children watch on tv, it's not like Tom and Jerry, Looney Tunes, Carebears, etc. In fact, next time you catch your younger kids watching Anime- I suggest you take a look at it yourself. Just because it's animated, that doesn't mean your children should be watching it. Some Anime can be quite violent, sexual, obscene, and graphic. Yes, I realize there are better animes that I could have used in the above comparisons, but I was trying to use more well known names to drive my point home.

 

sponsors
DISH® - Official Site
Promo Price Starting at $19.99/mo. Don’t Wait. Switch to DISH®!
www.DISH.com

Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

Globo nos EUA sem antena?
Pegue a Globo Internacional nos EUA sem antena, social nem crédito.
www.dishworldiptvbrasil.com

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  anime, mature content, cartoons, ghost in the shell, tv
 
1. myLot reputation of 89/100. mellbrb (153)   6 years ago

You raise a very good point with that.

DISH® - Official Site Promo Price Starting at $19.99/mo. Don’t Wait. Switch to DISH®!  www.DISH.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 68/100. Dayna_Jeffrey4ever (662)   6 years ago

don;t feel bad my dad it like 47 and loves the rugrats

Local Coupons 1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!  www.Groupon.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 92/100. tmnjyk (1527)   6 years ago

Sis I just wanna let you know I just bought Cars today, and it cost me $23.83 crying out loud:(( in the Philippines an original one like this is only about 5 bucks. I don't really know the difference between anime and cartoon, sometimes, I do think they are jus the same. Thanks for the info...I think you're really smart. But please I hope I can see some other started discussions of yours which is more easier for me to respond:( something like a poll question ehhehe LOL.

Globo nos EUA sem antena? Pegue a Globo Internacional nos EUA sem antena, social nem crédito.  www.dishworldiptvbrasil.com
 
4. chadmonson (14)   6 years ago

You wanna know the real difference between Cartoons and Animes? Well I, the marvelous Chadwick, shall tell you!

Language. o_O

Yup. That's it. Language. Basically it seperates what is a cartoon, versus an anime.

Alrighty....Let's look at some of the titles here....Pokemon, Digimon, Yu-Gi-Oh!... In Japanese, these all have a geenral serious sense. Soem comedy is thrown in, but mostly it's actually really serious. Though when turned into English, they lose a lot of that seriousness for comedy. This is because it's too ridiculous to sell to middle aged folk as serious, and it would go over children's heads. So to make it easier, they make it funny, and then throw it at gullible children. -Nods-

Now look at Naruto. This is another great example. Japanese Naruto has much violence, blood, and swearing. Why? Because that's what ninjas are all about.

Now in English it's pretty much about the same thing, but they cut things out. Blood is taken out more often, and even the slightly yaoi scene in the series is totally cut out, replaced by a black screen with a kissing noise....Lame. But mostly they transform it into a funny kind of show, taking out almost all seriousness. Mostly this is because they decided to give Naruto a catch phrase...."Believe it."

He says this probably about seventeen times every episode, or so I've been told. How can you take the show seriously with a stupid little kid saying "Beleive it" every few seconds, and after every sentence? I sure can't.

Now yes, I realize that there are many good animes that aren't so bad in English. But that's usually because they've just been dubbed, rather than redone. So in a sense, they're still Japanese, just with English voices.

And thus ends my rant. Yup yup.


myLot reputation of 97/100. Aeval39 (540)  6 years ago

I know exactly what you mean. That's so true. I prefer original Japanese animes with subtitles.


chadmonson (14)  6 years ago

Well....I had a super long rant all typed up, but MyLot decided to eat it....So...Short version.

Japan has no censorship (Or maybe not as strong a censorship. I can't say for certain, as people tell me things, and I'm too lazy to actually research things...). America has a hardcore censorship.

Apparently, from what I'm told, hentai, and violent animes are not hard to come by in Japan, and can in fact, be purchased by teenagers. Now, the Japanese anime artists don't particularly care about what they make, in the sense that whatever they put out, it's not going to be messed with. Thus, violence, hentai, and all that is put into the anime, and that is an anime.

When Americans take an anime into America, they change it with their censorship laws. They bleep out words, parts of pictures, and even sometimes entire scenses. Other times they alter things around because they think it's better to aim at the children of our nation. Of course, violence isn't drowned out so much from cartoons. (For instance, Looney Tunes) But when do you ever see blood? You don't. Not in a children's show. So overall, the difference is censorship. A censored anime becomes a cartoon.

Live TV PHP Portal Create your own live TV website, exploit the multi million $ market!  www.VianoTVPortal.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 97/100. Aeval39 (540)   6 years ago

Wooh! Very nicely put, you voiced what's going through my mind at times too. Though some cartoons (simpsons, american dad, family guy) aren't meant for kisa either. I'm a manga girl myself, and haven't watched a lot of anime, but I love to draw it. And it really makes me upset when people say that anime isn't real art and takes no skills. It's true that a lot of beginner artists prefer drawing anime because there's less detail, but just check out http://kaze-hime.deviantart.com or http://shirotsuki.deviantart.com and tell me that didn't take skill.


Drawing by me.^^
Man "Cheats" Credit Score He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.  www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 77/100. Xeedar (124)   6 years ago

Good point for sure, people has to understand that anime are not just childlish animation, but they can be valid as any other show (and metter of most of them).

Just wanted to say few things.
Hentai is not really "porno", it sounds so offensive...a real Hentai is soft erotic animation...a lot of websites call hentai s a lot of things which aren't. There's another category of more "strong" adult animes, but, sorry, at the moment i just cannot remember the name.

Anyway...people doesn't have to think animes as adult things just 'cause there things like hentai or porn animes...there are a lot of anime not for children, but not concerning sexuality. You gave just some of thousands valid names, I could add a lot, but I think it would be useless.

You talked about violence, sexuality, etc... it makes sound them as rubbish.
Animes (the most part of them) are just concerning the same (and more and better) themes of the movies you all watch in tv or at the cinema, and they are not for sure worste than real actor ones.

The Future of TV Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. No monthly bill.  www.StopPayingCableBills.com
 
sponsors
Live TV PHP Portal
Create your own live TV website, exploit the multi million $ market!
www.VianoTVPortal.com

Man "Cheats" Credit Score
He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.
www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com

The Future of TV
Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. No monthly bill.
www.StopPayingCableBills.com

similar discussions
can you give me some new cool anime titles with an adult protagonist?
I think during the 90's such anime exist but now most anime have a highschool student as a main...
Do you stop at just the manga?
Manga fans, do you stop at just the manga? What I mean by this is...after you read a manga series,...
CARTOON/ANIME FANATICS!!!! no AGE LIMITS...
There are lots of movies on tv to choose from. Horror, suspense, drama and even full of laughs. One...
The most cookie cutter anime protagonist prototypes
I remember my self making a discussion before about anime cliche and this one is a bit related, but...
i really like conan
i really like conan for ran..even though i know that edogawa conan and shinichi kudo are the same...
shocking truth
In my past anime discussions I ranted on how Hentai is ruining the anime industry in Japan, but I...
How Many Among Us Here Are Anime Lovers?
I love to watch lots of anime shows. My youngest son is the one who provides the downloaded items...
I will love anime forever...
I am in my midtwenties now and it seems that I still watch some of these japanese cartoons, Im not...
sponsors
Live TV PHP Portal
Create your own live TV website, exploit the multi million $ market!
www.VianoTVPortal.com
Man "Cheats" Credit Score
He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.
www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com
The Future of TV
Watch 3500+ channels today. Digital TV on PC. No monthly bill.
www.StopPayingCableBills.com
TV: Buy, Sell, or Hold?
Don't trade TV until you get our trusted free weekly trading advice!
www.TheBestNewsletters.com
Your Local Search
Looking For Live TV? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
live tv
View Live live tv Updates. Download Sports Coverage Free!
sportsuptodate.com/FreeDownload
Watch Full Episodes Free
Full episodes and clips of your favorite TV Shows for free.
www.videosurf.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.