sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

prayer  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912) 6 years ago

Does intercessory prayer actually have thid party effects on peoples health or well being. Have there been any scientific studies to see if it can really have theraputical effects on the out come of health problems or is it just a placebo effect. Can this be disscussed with out using the bible as a reference and keep it out of the emotional arena.

 

the physical healing power of prayer is real or imagined and is there any conclusive evidence that it works
sponsors
Law Schools Online
Earn An Assoc, Bach, or J.D. Completely Online. Get Free Info!
EarnMyDegree.com

1 SOUL| Spiritual Nexus
Gurus, Holistic Living, Ayurveda, Self-Realization, Meditation& Yoga
http://www.onespiritualsoul.com

Top 2011 College Grants
Grant funding may be available to those that qualify. Free info.
www.ClassesUSA.com

flowerchilde (8039) response was accepted on 12/16/2006.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  prayer, documented healings, duke university, emotional, healing
 
1. myLot reputation of 59/100. suitsme (2559)   6 years ago

I doubt it.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

Thats the best you can do ![ I doubt it.] Are you actually going to let me escape unscathed. Did you send your tounge back to the verbal abuse shop to have it resharpened. Have the muslim threads reduced your cutting edge to that of a butter knife. I will pray for you. And speaking of prayer, thank you! Gertie took 4 or 5 steps and wagged her tail and as far as I am concerned that suits me.


myLot reputation of 59/100. suitsme (2559)  6 years ago

Goodie for Gertie!


myLot reputation of 59/100. suitsme (2559)  6 years ago

"Can this be disscussed with out using the bible as a reference and keep it out of the emotional arena."

This is why I said "I doubt it". We been through ths before roz. That's how we met remember?

Law Schools Online Earn An Assoc, Bach, or J.D. Completely Online. Get Free Info!  EarnMyDegree.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)   6 years ago

Roztredtoes,

You are really good at asking multiple questions with complex answers.

First question:

" Does intercessory prayer actually have third party effects on peoples health or well being."

This can be debated endlessly. I will say this. Whether or not the person being prayed for is helped, the person doing the praying is helped, so, it is beneficial.

Second question:

" Have there been any scientific studies to see if it can really have theraputical effects on the out come of health problems or is it just a placebo effect."

Yes, there have been studies. How scientific some of them are is certainly open to debate.

Third question:

" Can this be disscussed with out using the bible as a reference and keep it out of the emotional arena. "

Yes and yes. Though, I agree most people can not do it.


myLot reputation of 59/100. suitsme (2559)  6 years ago

"Yes and yes. Though, I agree most people can not do it."

I agree.
I believe if moderation is kept in mind it can be done. Just don't say "Jesis IS God" or "Mohommad IS silly" and there won't be any death threats.


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

" Just don't say "Jesis IS God" or "Mohommad IS silly" and there won't be any death threats."

T'aint that there the truth! LOL. Glad to see someone understands this stuff.

1 SOUL | Spiritual Nexus Gurus, Holistic Living, Ayurveda, Self-Realization, Meditation & Yoga  http://www.onespiritualsoul.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8039)   6 years ago

I think Harvard did a study, but I don't think they used people of faith..

My sister got Leukemia and I prayed for her (heartfelt) and into my mind came the image of the painting of Jesus and his sheep and the thought came to my mind very clearly, that my sister was the lamb which he held in his arms.. Ten years later, she is still well.

One of my best friends was diagnosed with terminal cancer and myself and many of us friends, prayed for her, and it is two years later and she is still well..

Personally, I was healed of many childhoos abuses.. without which my life would have likely been total failure, I was so dysfunctional. But married for 26 years, raised two healthy and independent kids..

You've given me the idea to do a google search of healings from prayer and see what comes up.. maybe I'll come back and post a note on it..


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

Let us know the results of the Google search. Sounds interesting.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

Here we go! is a long prayer better than 5 short prayers. Is the person or persons religious depth more influental Than say a person like me who has no depth at all. Does the number of prayies have significant impact, or maybe a person of my ilk who has no religious couth could be looked upon more favorly because im not always harrassing the powers that be, and they might think my request requires closer inspection. If the person being prayed for has no knowledge of being interceded for will it have the same effect or any at all. There is also the thought that if the person being prayed for is fully aware of the concern on his behalf it will generate enough positive attitude to give rise to his immune system to over come any medical challanges. Who knows? Only the shadow knows! I would certainly like to hear a muslims thoughts on this subject.


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

1) Is a long prayer better than 5 short prayers? No, 5 short prayers are better in most cases.

2) Is the person or persons religious depth more influental Than say a person like me who has no depth at all. NO.

3) Does the number of prayies have significant impact, or maybe a person of my ilk who has no religious couth could be looked upon more favorly because im not always harrassing the powers that be, and they might think my request requires closer inspection.

Number of prayies has significant impact, religious couth counts for naught, it is the quality of the prayer as judged by God that counts.

4) If the person being prayed for has no knowledge of being interceded for will it have the same effect or any at all?

In some cases yes and in some no. Depends on how likely the person being prayed for is influenced by things psychosomantic

5) I would certainly like to hear a muslims thoughts on this subject.

Me too!


myLot reputation of 91/100. flowerchilde (8039)  6 years ago

- I didn't find that much in my google search.. one link sounded very good, but was a book for sale ($15) - and then there was a lot of how-to links, and a lot of Chrisitan Science links.. But here was a couple of things I did find at one link I thought was interesting:

Quest for Truth - Richard Rossi filmed for the first time documented footage of actual exorcisms and contemporary healing miracles of Biblical proportions in his stunning documentary which first aired on the FOX network. Credible cases and testimonies of ordinary people experiencing extraordinary power include a woman paralyzed thirty years instantly walks, a cancer victim who is cured, a disabled child with a twisted foot miraculously is made whole. The viewer is held on the edge of his seat for the most fascinating documentary on faith healing and exorcism ever done, set to a score of contemporary rock music!
http://www.buyindies.com/...

Answered Prayers? Investigating the Healing Power of Prayer - Can prayer account for astonishing recoveries that exceed medical expectations? In this program, doctors—including Larry Dossey, author of Healing Words—and people outside the medical profession share their understanding of prayer as a complementary therapy and the different approaches to using it. They also discuss the difference between curing and healing, and whether or not a patient’s death is a failure of prayer. People of different faiths agree that prayers for the ill, whether done as part of a group or alone, vocally or silently, can help provide meaning, hope, and possibly even health for those in need of healing.
http://www.films.com/id/10543

I thought those were kool..

This was the book:: (Amazon link, I think)
Healing through Prayer:
Health Practitioners Tell the Story
by Dossey, Benson, Polkinghorne, et. al.

People of faith know the power of prayer. Now scientists and others are using prayer to heal. Their findings and firsthand accounts will provide new conviction to people of all religious faiths and offer real hope to all who seek healing. Doctors and patients quote scientific surveys and relate personal experiences of healing through prayer. They are convinced that prayer has had a profound effect in their lives. $15.95 160 pages


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

Thanks, for the research into prayer at google. I'm considering the book.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

Prayer is a womderfull thing for the emotionaly distressed and poor souls swirling about in the foggy complexities of a life gone sour. Prayer can bolster ones resolve to get a good two handed grasp on the situation that is sending them on the road to perdition and get back in the main stream of life. Depression will evaporate and along with it many health issues will flee the scene. This has been commonly known but constantly over looked since Jesus said love you neighbor as you would your self,even if she is fat and ugly. To try and bring science into the equazion is really streching probably enough to tear a ligament. The only important part of this issue is the end results.to totally ignore science in favor of mumbling requests in a protate position can be with out merit and totaly deadly. science and prayer must work cohesively to achieve results that can be acceptable to the inellectualy elite as well as the moron element. But rest assured thier will always be some inellestual bone head that will write a know all book on what ever subject with garrenties of divine inspiration. I f this doesn't get the whole camp pissed off I don't know what will.


Top 2011 College Grants Grant funding may be available to those that qualify. Free info.  www.ClassesUSA.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 91/100. baby_mine (459)   6 years ago

I pray everyday. Some of my oddest prayers have come true. The strangest line of events will happen sometimes, just to give the end effect of my prayers, and no other human knew what I prayed about. I think everyone should pray. Whether or not they believe. Maybe they wouldn't be so angry and worried all the time.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

In my uninformed opinion, prayer is a form of meditation and one of the most valuable tools in mans arsenal of weapons to hold at bay depression, unhappiness and all the negative input that life has to throw. Praying to a higher intellect and asking for guidance to solve disturbing and preplexing problems may not neccessarly give you a solution but may open pathways for you to further investigate and lead to a remedy that will bring things to a satisfactory conclusion. Which is a whole lot better than confronting the moron and blowing his brains out.


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

" Praying to a higher intellect and asking for guidance to solve disturbing and preplexing problems may not neccessarly give you a solution but may open pathways for you to further investigate and lead to a remedy that will bring things to a satisfactory conclusion. Which is a whole lot better than confronting the moron and blowing his brains out."


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

Who are you that made the comment above in place of roztredtoes? What did you do with him? Is he alright? Release him now or we will pray for him.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

Ok OK forget blowing his brains out, bad idea. How about instead give him an anal insertion with a high pressure fire hose and maybe after you have opened up his sinisus you can possibly work things out. Having a clear head will always help.


myLot reputation of 42/100. redyellowblackdog (4040)  6 years ago

Computer cat likes most roztredtoes' posts and comments. Some are better than others. Which this is he ain't saying.



myLot reputation of 90/100. justiman (231)  6 years ago

okay now the second respose from red is more like it. So don't worry, if he was being held captive, they definetly released him.

Psychic Reviews Top psychic networks reviewed and rated. Find the best psychics.  TheConsumerAdvisor.org
 
5. myLot reputation of 26/100. Benito (162)   6 years ago

Its very very use for our daily life

Wheatgrass Juice People All natural wheatgrass juice and detailed wheatgrass juice info.  DynamicGreens.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 83/100. jota176 (269)   6 years ago

I have seen it work on people before. At one of the Churches I go I have seen people who have been able to walk again because of healing. I have seen people who have been diagnosed with cancer get better and they are still healthy today. One time, one of my friends went blind after getting into a car accidnet and the whole church prayed for him. He was in the hospital for 2 weeks and then we went to the church and the elders put their hands on him and he was able to see again as soon as he walked out of the chuch.


myLot reputation of 74/100. roztredtoes (1912)  6 years ago

One way to look at it, was either the power of prayer or an incompetent medical system the only thing that really matters is the out come.

Life Frequencies Pro A Complete Alternative Health System for your Computer. Download...  bztronics.com
 
7. myLot reputation of 90/100. justiman (231)   6 years ago

First of all, you said science and prayer in the same sentence and that is an impossible question to answer seeing as they are two totally opposite things. Then you ask this place to keep it out of the emotional arena, good one Red!!

Your Zodiac Horoscope Insert Your Birthdate & Get aswers about Past-Present & Future. Free  AboutAstro.com/horoscope
 
8. myLot reputation of 90/100. justiman (231)   6 years ago

I just read the whole thing Red and it looks like you kept the emotional people out of here by using those really really big words. Maybe next time if you want more responses, you should use words that these people understand like "sex" and "money" and "am I pretty??". You did, however, get some pretty intelligent answers, but I think one of them was your nieghbor and he seems to know you well.

Prayer Looking For Prayer? Find It Nearby With Local.com!  Local.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 99/100. GardenGerty (35316)   6 years ago

I believe . . . that there was an article within the last two years in Reader's Digest on this topic. I also believe that it was Duke University that did the study. When my first hubby was diagnosed with ALS, people told me "he can be healed if you just believe" problem is, he did not want a physical healing, he had been depressed all of his life. The way he was healed, and he was, was spiritually and emotionally. At that same time, because of the physical difficulty of caring for him, I had some severe problems walking, climbing stairs, etc. I never shared these as a prayer concern, but at about the time he became fully wheel chair bound, my back became fully functional, and I no longer had to physically lift my leg with my hands to move up the stairs. I know people were praying for me, and I know that I was healed. I still say that in that time the most significant healing was of my spirit, my mind and my emotions. I have not looked up the Reader's Digest article for you, but I bet it is available.

Find Alternative Medicine Find Local Alternative Medicine and  yellowpages.com
 
sponsors
Psychic Reviews
Top psychic networks reviewed and rated. Find the best psychics.
TheConsumerAdvisor.org

Wheatgrass Juice People
All natural wheatgrass juice and detailed wheatgrass juice info.
DynamicGreens.com

Life Frequencies Pro
A Complete Alternative Health System for your Computer. Download...
bztronics.com

similar discussions
do u pray bfore and after bedtime?
as a roman catholic, we are obliged to do praying bfore and after bedtime..follow what god wants us...
Does Your Prayers Are Answered?
I know that not all of us here do the pray before we start our day every morning and before we end...
I'M IN...Thanks for praying for me beautiful mylotters namely....
holla mylotters..i had my training for 45 days started last september 5,2011(without salary) and i...
why we need to pray if God already know what every thing?
we know that God knows every thing and my question is why we need to pray if god already knows what...
Send your good wishes to our fellow Sister Cynthainn on mylot
DON'T KNOW IF MYLOT WILL ALLOW THIS BUT HERE GOES ANYWAY...... PLUS HOPE CYNTHAINN IS'NT TOO CROSS...
Just because you pray, does God have to answer your prayer?
Some people pray and their prayers are answered. Other people pray and get no answer. They then...
I Am Worried About Him...
My husband is having such a hard time with this whole comp stuff. He is stressing more than I am...
Do You Pray For People You Work With?
and let them know you are praying for them, or do you Pray for them in Secret? Where I work there...
Which comes first, the national anthem or invocation?
I am making this program for our Seminar Workshop in my subject Personality Development. I am...
Staying focused on God?
Sometimes its hard to stay focused on what God wants for us, and living in his word each and every...
sponsors
Psychic Reviews
Top psychic networks reviewed and rated. Find the best psychics.
TheConsumerAdvisor.org
Wheatgrass Juice People
All natural wheatgrass juice and detailed wheatgrass juice info.
DynamicGreens.com
Life Frequencies Pro
A Complete Alternative Health System for your Computer. Download...
bztronics.com
Your Zodiac Horoscope
Insert Your Birthdate & Get aswers about Past-Present & Future. Free
AboutAstro.com/horoscope
Prayer
Looking For Prayer? Find It Nearby With Local.com!
Local.com
Find Alternative Medicine
Find Local Alternative Medicine and
yellowpages.com
Ask a Psychiatrist Online
17 Psychiatrists Are Online Now. Ask a Question, Get an Answer ASAP.
JustAnswer.com/Psychiatry
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.