Peyton, good or bad friend?

I think that I would have kept my mouth shut although I have seen the next eposodes so her telling might have been good - atleast for her.
I think that love is important, but we have a rule among me and my friends, Once a guy is with someone in the "gang" he is off limits forever, and this has worked fine for us over the years=)

I think she was a good friend. Sure she probably shouldn't have told her best friend that she was in love with her boyfriend, but she tried to get Lucas and Brooke back together after they broke up. She didn't make a move on him before making sure that they were not getting back together. I know that if I was in love with someone I wouldn't be able to stand aside and encourage the person to get back with their ex.

I think she did the right thing by telling her. I'd imagine it would have caused way more problems for her NOT to say anything, and then Brooke finding out. I don't think there's any way she could have forgiven her for not telling her that time since it did happen before.

And I think Peyton and Lucas should be together, they've always loved each other.

I think that Peyton has quiet a bit of personal issues and that she misreads her feeling for Lucus because he is such a great friend to her, she has lost everyone that she has ever cared for and I think that she reaches out to Lucus because of that. I also think that Brooke is taking it to far. If Lucus loves her than what is the deal? Yes I know that Peyton being her "bestfriend" and telling her that she has a thing for Lucus would be tough but at the same time Brooke knows Peyton better than anyone, and she should understand how screwed up Peyton's emotions can be. I think that in the long run everything will be fine.

I think Peyton is a bad friend. People think love is uncontrollable or out of your grasp-- "you can't help who you fall in love with" as they say. This isn't true though. You do have a choice who you're going to love. In Peyton's case, it's just a matter of choice if she respects her friend Brooke. It all boils down to loyalty and friendship. And she already has Jake; what does she need Lucas for?

I don't think Peyton was a bad friend for telling Brooke what she really felt about Lucas. Because I agree with you, you can't really choose the one you love and there's no point in denying it if you know what you really feel anyway. Although I'm not entirely sure why Peyton DID tell Brook now that I think about it. She probably should've just kept it to herself to avoid all the drama that happened between them.

But then she did anyway, and I actually think Brooke was more of a bad friend with regards to the way she reacted to what Peyton said. I don't think she really had to push Peyton the way she did. Like I said, it wasn't really Peyton's fault for feeling the way she did. Besides, boys shouldln't go between your friendship with your girls! Haha, but seriously.