sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

My mother-in-law thinks Barbie is a bad influence for my daughter... email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 100/100. ladymoonstone143 (1287)   ranked 9 out of 14,888 in parenting3 years ago

My 2 1/2 is starting to get fascinated with Barbie and is watching all these Barbie DVD's but my mother in law thinks Barbie is bad influence because she might make my daughter thinks that you have to grow up like Barbie thin and pretty. I don't see any harm on it because I think my daughter will outgrow this like she outgrows Wiggles, etc. I am also vigilant on what she is watching. What are your thoughts on this?

 
 
parenting
sponsors
Free Barbie 3-Story Dream Townhouse
Get The New Barbie Townhouse w/ Fab Amenities.See site details.
www.top-cat-savings.com

Little Girls Skirt
Find Your Soulmate& True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile.
Singles-Date.com/LittleGirlsSkirt

Recovering from Eating Disorders
Addiction Model Treatment for Eating Disorders.
www.milestonesprogram.org

misskatonic (2646) response was accepted on 3/13/2007.
denotes best response.
tags:  barbie, dolls, bratz, weight, little girls
 
1. myLot reputation of 78/100. misskatonic (2646)   ranked 2,136 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

As long as you explain to your daughter that real women don't look like Barbie, there shouldn't be any problem. Kids aren't as impressionable as a lot of people think. They do listen to what they're told and they do pay attention as long as those lessons are reinforced. Barbie is not to blame for women with body issues, it's the media and the models that are strutted about everywhere we go.

Free Barbie 3-Story Dream Townhouse Get The New Barbie Townhouse w/ Fab Amenities.See site details. www.top-cat-savings.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 98/100. emeraldisle (8978)   ranked 1,681 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

I don't think you have to worry. I think most girls now a days play with barbies. I know my neice did and trust me she doesn't look anything like barbie. At two and half all your daughter knows is she likes the stories and playing with the doll. When she's older you can explain if need be that people come in all sizes and types. let her enjoy her childhood while she can and don't worry about your mother-in-law.

Little Girls Skirt Find Your Soulmate & True Love. Get Matched on Compatibility Profile. Singles-Date.com/LittleGirlsSkirt
 
3. myLot reputation of 81/100. marief2rnurse (2514)   ranked 1,229 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

There's nothing wrong with Barbie. Your little girl is too young to think she needs to look like Barbie. I'm sure right now she's just fascinated to see a doll speak and move. My kids love Barbie, my 2 and 6 year olds and none of them are thinking they want to look like Barbie. We keep teasing my 6 year old that she needs to diet, she is even saying she's losing weight but she already looks pregnant LOL.

Recovering from Eating Disorders Addiction Model Treatment for Eating Disorders. www.milestonesprogram.org
 
4. myLot reputation of 86/100. michelledarcy (4382)   ranked 205 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

My daughters both play with barbies and they are 5 and 2. I think that as long as you give them a balanced outlook on life it won't affect them that badly.

Vintage Barbie Sale Compare Prices & Save up to 50% Order Yours Today! www.Price-Discounts.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. chertsy (2579)   ranked 1,614 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

If your mother in law thinks Barbie was bad. I hate to see what she thinks of the Bratz dolls, lol. I don't see the big deal with Barbie. My girls plays with barbies and bratz, and they could care less about there size. Makeup and clothes, that's a different story all together.

Mother's Day Jewelry Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in & near Washington DC. Jewelers.YellowPages.com/DC
 
6. myLot reputation of 98/100. poppoppop111 (3231)   ranked 11 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

i don't beleive that barbie will have a bad effect on a child. it's just a toy. there are so many worst things in this world to worry about than a toy.

Access Floor Furnish & Installation ATC is Washington's most experienced Access Floor Installer and Dealer. We stock multiple products and excel in providing original finishes and solutions. www.accessfloors.us
 
7. myLot reputation of 94/100. jhrcsr (297)   ranked 3,885 out of 14,888 in parenting   3 years ago

My girls always had Barbies, now my granddaughter comes along and it's nothing but those Bratz dolls UGH! They are sooooo ugly, to me, but she really loves them. Each generation has a doll that they favor. If the child is a girl, she is going to fall in love with this or that. Believe me, it will change several times in the next few years for you. I don't see any harm in it. Let her play and use her imagination, it helps grow their little minds and teaches them creativity.

Wizards Kids Gifts Buy Washington Wizards Boys & Girls Apparel at the Yahoo! Sports Shop. YahooSports.TeamFanShop.com
 
8. myLot reputation of 91/100. LisaHW (1510)   ranked 1,929 out of 14,888 in parenting   2 years ago

Little girls admire grown up girls who are pretty and nice. That's generally how little girls are.

I don't think the Barbie in a DVD that a two-and-a-half-year old watches is going to even be remembered in a few years.

Besides, in a world full of people who blame Barbie for little girls' having bad self-images, I don't happen to be one of those people.

Wanting to be thin and pretty is what most girls want, regardless of Barbie. Wanting to be thin and pretty isn't such a bad thing to want to be, and not all girls who want that develop eating disorders.

Besides, I believe that girls have self-image problems because heterosexual young girls are often going to find the narrow, straight, build of their male counterparts the most attractive thing. Teen girls who keep their stick-straight builds a little longer may be happier than girls who get curves, because the minute the curves show up it can take heterosexual girls away from what they find is attractive.

To further aggravate the problem, many males prefer the youthful build that slender girls have. (Its built into evolutionary hardwiring that small waists indicate youthfulness.)

I think the wish to be thin and pretty is just there in a lot of girls. In fact, as a girl raised on Barbie and the mother and aunt of another generation of girls raised on Barbie, I tend to think it is the natural appeal of thin and pretty that makes Barbie so appealing to little girls (rather than Barbie's making "converts" out of people who otherwise wouldn't be interested in thin and pretty).

I'm not in favor of raising little girls without emphasizing their inner qualities, and I'd certainly do whatever I could if I thought my daughter seemed to be developing an unhealthy obsession with being too thin. Still, being slim is a healthy thing to be, and being pretty is a nice thing to be.

Besides, my daughter has echoed my own words: "I played with Barbie, and I knew she was a doll. It never occurred to me to think I could be like the doll when I grew up."

I believe when little girls are raised with the right values and with the right kind of good sense they know the difference between a doll and themselves. I tend to think that eating disorders and similar unhealthy obsessions with appearance are rooted in something far more complex and deep-rooted than Barbie dolls. In fact, I don't think Barbie has the power to influence little girls that so many people seem to think she does. (If she didn't there would be a whole lot fewer overweight girls in this world.)

Maybe I'm wrong - but those are my thoughts.

Washington Nationals Baby Kid Clothing Shop online at babysport.com & FREE shipping on orders $99 or more. www.babysport.com
 
sponsors
Vintage Barbie Sale
Compare Prices& Save up to 50% Order Yours Today!
www.Price-Discounts.com

Mother's Day Jewelry
Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in& near Washington DC.
Jewelers.YellowPages.com/DC

Access Floor Furnish& Installation
ATC is Washington's most experienced Access Floor Installer and Dealer. We stock multiple products and excel in providing original finishes and solutions.
www.accessfloors.us

similar discussions
Does your daughter like dolls?
My daughter has quite a few dolls, but I never see her playing with them. For birthdays and other...
Is Disney Princess just as bad as Barbie dolls?
I love Disney, don't get me wrong. But recently I was watching Aladdin with my kids, and it...
do you own a barbie doll?
or did you have one when you were a kid? my mom said my sisters and i have barbie dolls when we...
Who should play Barbie in Movie
Barbie was a great children doll. I have had a few dolls collection. Malabu. Beach barbie to name a...
Does anyone here buy items from Avon online? And is Avon available outside USA?
I was wondering if anyone here on myLot buys Avon products online? I have heard that they are...
What is Barbie trying to say!?!
OK I so wish I could have gotten a picture on here of this but I didn't so please bear with me on...
why does little girls loves barbie and hello kitty?
My 2 daughters always want barbie and hello kitty they love wearing dress who's picture was hello...
Girls did you play with Barbie dolls growing up? Boys, G.I. Joes?
Barbies were a huge part of my life growing up. I would play for hours and hours on end with my...
sponsors
Vintage Barbie Sale
Compare Prices & Save up to 50% Order Yours Today!
www.Price-Discounts.com
Mother's Day Jewelry
Find elegant, unique Mother's Day jewelry in & near Washington DC.
Jewelers.YellowPages.com/DC
Access Floor Furnish & Installation
ATC is Washington's most experienced Access Floor Installer and Dealer. We stock multiple products and excel in providing original finishes and solutions.
www.accessfloors.us
Wizards Kids Gifts
Buy Washington Wizards Boys & Girls Apparel at the Yahoo! Sports Shop.
YahooSports.TeamFanShop.com
Washington Nationals Baby Kid Clothing
Shop online at babysport.com & FREE shipping on orders $99 or more.
www.babysport.com
barbie play house
Find Barbie Play House Online. Search For Barbie Play House Today!
Tazinga.com
Collectible Barbie at Marlbe
Huge selection of new and vintage Barbie. Other fashion dolls, fashions, and accessories. Win Contests.
www.marlbe.com
Customized Barbie Doll
One of the kind Barbie type doll in your likeness just $350 apiece
www.customtoyfigures.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.