sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

what's wrong with "scotum"?  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 93/100. funny52f (5126) 5 years ago

Scrotum is actually just a male body part used in a children's book that had raised the eyebrows of parents and educators. In the book "The HIgher Power of Lucky", the major character Lucky Trimble hears the word "through a crack on the wall". A friend of hers told her that "a rattlesnake bit his dog on the scrotum." The mention of this word in the book authored by Susan Patron led to the banning of the said book. Copies of it had been removed from the shelves of libraries in the US. What do you think of this now that stakeholders are still debating about the appropriatenes of the word's inclusion in a children's book.

 

sponsors
Publishing a Kid's Book?
Free PDF Upload Option or Let Us Custom-Create Your Book. Learn More
www.CreateSpace.com

Censorship Research
Online books, journals for academic research, plus bibliography tools.
www.Questia.com/Censorship

The Red Cat Book
Buy The Red Cat by Nancy Fabian. Children's book with Morals.
www.TheRedCatBook.com

charlene2350 (4850) response was accepted on 4/2/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  mature content, censorship, childlrens book, childrens book, scrotum
 
1. myLot reputation of 93/100. zenmachado (1109)   5 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.


myLot reputation of 93/100. funny52f (5126)  5 years ago

Ok. So you think its inclusion is not suitable to the readers.


myLot reputation of 87/100. TeresaK (8081)  5 years ago

This post contains content of a mature nature. You must be Signed in or Registered to have the option to view this content.

Publishing a Kid's Book? Free PDF Upload Option or Let Us Custom-Create Your Book. Learn More  www.CreateSpace.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 93/100. charlene2350 (4850)   5 years ago

i think that is absolutely stupid! It teaches kids that the body parts are somehow unmentionable. Like the word "p**is" people get all torn out of the frame, either giggling or covering their mouths in shock. What do thay want it called, "winkey" "Piggy", and I think scrotum is a lot better word than "b*lls".


myLot reputation of 93/100. funny52f (5126)  5 years ago

Oh. Do you think the author should change the bitten part, instead of being bitten on the scrotum, maybe change it to leg?

Censorship Research Online books, journals for academic research, plus bibliography tools.  www.Questia.com/Censorship
 
3. myLot reputation of 95/100. CinderInMySoul (4337)   5 years ago

i think it depends on the age of children the book was written for.

if its for kids under..say the age of 10 then the bite should take place on the leg etc. if its for kids over the age of 10 then scrotum is fine. they should learn the real names of their body parts as it is.

of course it could be a matter of just plain storyline too.

was being bitten in the scrotum somehow an important part of the plot? or just a gratuitous use of a usually "unmentionable" body part?


myLot reputation of 93/100. funny52f (5126)  5 years ago

It was mentioned I think on the first page of the book. I think the author here wanted to probably sound funny but was misinterpreted.

The Red Cat Book Buy The Red Cat by Nancy Fabian. Children's book with Morals.  www.TheRedCatBook.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 87/100. TeresaK (8081)   5 years ago

I don't see why a debate is necessary. It's the proper term for a body part, it's not used in any sexual sort of context, and it's in a book for children ages 9 and over. For me, there's no reason NOT to have it in the school library, particularly since it was a winner of the Newberry Medal. Then again, I am not a fan of censorship in any way, shape or form.

Embarrasing Sex Problems? Free Advices on Various Sex Problems  www.herballove.com
 
sponsors
Embarrasing Sex Problems?
Free Advices on Various Sex Problems
www.herballove.com

Kids Books
Find DVDs, books, toys,& more. Search listings at Local.com.
Shopping.Local.com

Ask a Doctor: Scrotum
18 Doctors Online Now Answer Your Scrotum Questions In Minutes.
Health.eAnswer.com/Scrotum

similar discussions
parenting
hello friends...i cant tell you how much i adore little children but the saddest part is that i and...
Do you smoke this..
I would not want to smoke for some good reasons. The main one being it is a habit I can't afford. I...
What do you feel okay with certain technologies for your children?
When it comes to technology do you think at a certain age for different types of technology is okay...
Time to wash my bras
I used to wash my bras everytime I wore them but really they didnt get smelly or sweaty most of the...
Forgive and Forget... Is it really possible?
It is always hard to forgive but in the act of forgiveness, forgetting is usually the hardest part....
Religion : the true intent..
Hi lotters.. Its just a theory of mine.. so if you disagree, feel free to share your...
Is my friend a lesbian? (confused)
I have this close friend of mine who is acting a bit weird these days. I don't know but my family...
"when you are married, love's in the past?" say what?
I was looking for a topic and found one in a response to discussion on valentine's day. this person...
sponsors
Embarrasing Sex Problems?
Free Advices on Various Sex Problems
www.herballove.com
Kids Books
Find DVDs, books, toys, & more. Search listings at Local.com.
Shopping.Local.com
Ask a Doctor: Scrotum
18 Doctors Online Now Answer Your Scrotum Questions In Minutes.
Health.eAnswer.com/Scrotum
Juvenile Book Publisher
60 Years of Satisfied Authors & Quality Books. Reviewed in 3 Weeks.
www.VantagePress.com
The Kingdoms & the Elves
Discover Robert Stanek's popular books! Mystery and adventure await.
www.amazon.com
US State Sponsored Terror
U.S. Police State Terror and uncontitutional oppression & corruption
www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXbojImKNlI
Food. Next Bull Cycle?
Global Food Shortage? Invest in BION for a green future and planet now.
www.BioNitrogen.com/Invest_Today
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.