sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

saltwater  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586) 5 years ago

i live in Australia and have tried many differant types of freshwater fish but have largely been dissapointed with them, I live near the oceon and have been brought up on saltwater fish.Have i just been unlucky in the fish that i have tried or are there good freshwater fish.Even trout that many people comment on how great it is seems bland to me. May it be that i have been spoilt living by the sea?


saltwater fish
 

fishing
sponsors
Kashi®: Get Protein
Add Protein& Fiber to Your Diet. Get Nutrition Info on Kashi® Foods!
www.kashi.com

Local Seafood Restaurants
Looking For Seafood Restaurants?
yellowpages.com

Your Favorite Restaurant
Could be featured for 50-90% off today. Find old favorites& new gems!
www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up

biwasaki (1044) response was accepted on 3/3/2007.
denotes best response, click it to go to the best response.
tags:  fish, cooking fish, differ in taste and smell, fishing, food
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. biwasaki (1044)   5 years ago

I live in Hawaii and have dealt with the same situation. Freshwater fish just doesn't taste as good as saltwater fish to me. A lot of the freshwater fish here are living in water that is muddy or in man made reservoirs, and they either have no taste or taste like mud. I would much rather have something that was caught in the ocean.


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

I agree totally with what you have said mud is the taste i get from them. I have friends here that come from in land and they tell me i am not cooking them right.I must add this and that and cook it like this and that, Well i am sure i could use an old pair of socks and follow their sacred recipes and still come up with the same flavour. Fish that can be cooked just on their own and retain the great flavour are the ones i prize.Sorry inland people i promise not to deplete your stocks , you may have them all to yourself.
Having said that one must not tarnish the reputation of the humble yabby!

Kashi®: Get Protein Add Protein & Fiber to Your Diet. Get Nutrition Info on Kashi® Foods!  www.kashi.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 90/100. lloydanthony111 (1180)   ranked 128 out of 193 in fishing   5 years ago

I feel the same the same way. Saltwater fish are much better. As a matter of fact, it's the only fish I eat.

Lloyd

Local Seafood Restaurants Looking For Seafood Restaurants?  yellowpages.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 93/100. raijin (6691)   5 years ago

I feel the same way too, am not used of eating freshwater fishes. The smell and the taste are not that good as what saltwater fishes do, and I've also noticed that freshwater fishes are a bit slimy thatn those from saltwater.
Freshwater fishes gives a an after taste that I think because I was never used of, so I don't really eat freshwater fishes..

Your Favorite Restaurant Could be featured for 50-90% off today. Find old favorites & new gems!  www.Groupon.com/Sign-Up
 
4. myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing   5 years ago

yes, there is really a big difference in the tastes of freshwater and marine fishes. maybe because marine fishes live in a much cleaner environment as compared to freshwater fish wherein they live in a confined area. but have you tried eating a milkfish (CHanos chanos)? i dont know if you have it there in your country but it tastes good.


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

I have never heard of milk fish in Australia although it may come under a differant name here, is it saltwater? i might google and see,I have come across stingrays like the one on your avatar as i stepped on one 18 months ago and it stuck its barb in my foot, very painfull lol


nid2210 (1)   ranked 165 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

Hi I have fished both coastal and regional being from the Riverina (Inland New South Wales) and I can tell you that the quality of the water has a much higher effect on fresh water fish. As far as trout is concerned If it isn't cooked as soon as it leaves the water it isn't much good. Hence why they smoke it...
The best fresh water fish I have ever had was silver perch (or black bream) my mother deep fried in crumbs whole and was absolutely beautiful.
I would just like to say is that saltwater fish and this is effected by two factors. The high quality of the water and the food that they eat.
What you mainly taste is the salt..
I know you aren't really interested in the add this add that strategy. But don't give up on trout untill you have tried it stuffed with mash banana.
Sorry this was so long winded but it is a combination of two of my passions: Cooking and Fishing
Peter Alkemade


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

I must admit i did like Redfin i used to catch in a dam/small lake in a vineyard i used to look after, I got me mate to skin them and them deep fry it. Beuatifull white flesh, and the Redfin were like mini snapper, From elbow to finger tip in size. The Murray Bridge fish are foul as by the time the water gets to there it's well polluted and grayish/olivey in colour, hence the flavour.We have a trout farm in the south east and i do not like them but are told fresh trout from up top like NSW are totaly differant
Thank you for your responce.


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

it's a freshwater fish. i dont know if you have it there ins AU. it's usually culturedd here in our country and it does tastes really good.

by the way, have you eaten a stingray? it's also delicious. we have a delicacy here in the Philippines called "kinunot" that uses stingray or sometimes shark. it's yummy and i like it when it's cooked that way.


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

hi there nid2210! yep, what we are actually tasting is the salt. yeah, the diet of fish also adds to it's taste. most of the omnivorous fish doesn't taste good if it's not cleaned very well.


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

i got a mixed up of information here.. the milkfish is a saltwater fish. sorry.


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

i got a mixed up of information here.. the milkfish is a saltwater fish. sorry. thanks raijin for the correction.


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

Yes i did a search to see this fish ans sounds nice.I have eaten stingray before and also had it smoked, is beuatifull like chicken, In AU we prize the Gummy Shark and also the school shark and the bronze whaler,carpet shark is aso eaten but is of a lower grade. he stingray is nice on a plate and not with its barb in your foot as i have experianced before lol


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

Makaira ,you just got two + with the one response, lucky boy today lol


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

thanks for "+"... yep, stingrays are really nice on plate but not when you stepped on it... this discussion is making me hungry... hehehe


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

I am getting hungry too, al this talk about fish. I have Tuna for tea tonight, only problem is that it come out of a can!!


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

too bad! fresh tuna are more appetizing than those found in can... hehehe.


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

Tell me about it, I was lucky to try some freshly caught Blue fin Tuna last year and it was perfect, texture almost like shark.The people who caught it were eating it raw whilst was just dead.I liked it very much but could not see $200 AU plus a kilo in it.We have a big migrating population just out from port macdonell, we also spend summer catching southern rock lobster, they are nice from down here in the cold water.


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

fresh tunas are very common in here our place though it' a little bit expensive for us (200 to 300PHP per kilo that is around 6AU$). what we usually have here are yellow fin tunas. actually, it's my favorite food. yummy!


myLot reputation of 93/100. raijin (6691)  5 years ago

As far as I know, Philippines is one of the top exporters of fresh tuna. Japan has the most number of demands in tuna here, as they use it most on sashimis. Gen San City is the best place here in the philippines to look for world class tunas!;)


myLot reputation of 98/100. makaira (636)   ranked 64 out of 193 in fishing  5 years ago

yep, your right there raijin. gen san is just a few hours away from our place.

3 Veggies to a Flat Belly Unusual article shows unique veggies that burn abdominal fat  TruthAboutAbs.com/fat-burning
 
5. vallly (72)   ranked 11 out of 193 in fishing   5 years ago

I like to fish in the ocean but I havent posibility for that. Maybe someday I can. My dream is to fishing in Pacific many great fish like swordfish, ton and other. What kind of fish u catch there in Australia?


myLot reputation of 90/100. spasticseagull (1586)  5 years ago

Australia is a big continent so it depends where you are as to what species of fish you catch. The species vary dramaticly as we have many extremes in climate depending whether you fish down south or up north.

Lake Erie Fishing Charter Chelsea Charters runs full time clean/comfortable boat, great rates  www.lakeeriecharterfishing.com
 
6. myLot reputation of 93/100. troopy (125)   ranked 84 out of 193 in fishing   5 years ago

Yep,
I have to agree, i live on the beach in nsw and have fished here , qld , s.a and tassie and the fish out of the ocean alway's taste better than those caught in inland rivers and estuaries. For me i like a fish just grilled in lemon with no batter or anything else really and most fish you catch inland just arent up to scratch cooked like that..
good luck with the fishing

VXB Fishing Reel Bearings Ball bearings at wholesale prices stainless and hybrid ceramics too!  www.vxb.com
 
sponsors
3 Veggies to a Flat Belly
Unusual article shows unique veggies that burn abdominal fat
TruthAboutAbs.com/fat-burning

Lake Erie Fishing Charter
Chelsea Charters runs full time clean/comfortable boat, great rates
www.lakeeriecharterfishing.com

VXB Fishing Reel Bearings
Ball bearings at wholesale prices stainless and hybrid ceramics too!
www.vxb.com

similar discussions
new pet
i'm planning to buy a new pet and its a fish. and i was thinking of what kind of fish am going to...
A long battle fight for fish
A two town fighting for the Best St. Peter fish a.k.a tilapia. This towns are Buhi (Buhi lake) and...
She ATE her OWN Babies,WHY?
I am really upset right now and I can not begin to explain my feelings. This may sound funny to...
Do u like seafood ..??????
i do :)
So I don't like "cold" fish..>_<
Over tens years ago, my sister in law who lives in Washington started sending her brothers and...
How to know what fish oil to take or not?
Fish oil and fish oil supplements are very good fatty acids that everyone needs to take. It helps...
Only confidence when was at home
I know a few people only can be confident when they are at home. When they go out, they seem to...
Interesting Fact: Eating just FISH could be Mortal
Fish has all essential amino acids that human needs to survive. However, we could die if we only...
fish in a bucket died
I was cleaning my tank, so I put the fish in a bucket of the old water. About 2-3 hours later, I...
How much Fish?
I am trying once again to bring my eating habits back into a healthy balance. I really need to lose...
sponsors
3 Veggies to a Flat Belly
Unusual article shows unique veggies that burn abdominal fat
TruthAboutAbs.com/fat-burning
Lake Erie Fishing Charter
Chelsea Charters runs full time clean/comfortable boat, great rates
www.lakeeriecharterfishing.com
VXB Fishing Reel Bearings
Ball bearings at wholesale prices stainless and hybrid ceramics too!
www.vxb.com
Now: Fishing Tackle -63%
Compare prices now and save up to 63% on great value Fishing Tackle!
www.Fishing-Tackle.best-deal.com
5 Foods you must not eat
Cut down a bit of stomach fat every day by never eating these 5 foods.
Thedietsolutionprogram.com
Blue Bank Resort
Stay where Bill Dance Kevin VanDam & the rest of the pros stay.
www.bluebankresort.com
Cloudveil Fishing Gear
Huge discounts on boots, waders, vests and more for your next trip.
www.LevelNineSports.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.