sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionsblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLot

Should we have a ban on size zero in the modelling world? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4890)   ranked 108 out of 26,857 in people2 years ago

LAst night we were watching 'the truth about size zero 'which was all about fashion houses only wanting near anorexic girls to model for them.In the documentary a very slim young lady who is size 8 (4 for US) decided to lose weight to become size zero and see how she was effected. She took 4 weeks and managed it but was emaciated and miserable.
How can fashion houses dictate the size a model must be before they will allow her to model their clothes? Surely it should be the other way around. The girls who are most attractive being who the fashion houses make the clothes for so that there is maximum interest in their fashions!
What do you think?
Should models refuse to waste away for the industry?
Would it work if all models were not size zero?
Should there be a ban on size zero enforced by the government?

 
 
people
sponsors
Aspx Errors
Free Download: Aspx Errors Repair Tool. 100% Safe& Guaranteed.
AspxErrors.FreshPCFix.com

RV Lots For Rent and Sale Florida
Family RV Resort - Clermont (Disney)/Crystal River/Salt Springs.
www.eliteresorts.com

Anorexia Treatment for Adults/Teens
Low fee, effective, outpatient treatment. Los Angeles, 310-277-2796.
www.drkrevoy.com

krayzee (826) response was accepted on 3/27/2007.
denotes best response.
tags:  anorexic, model, anorexia, emaciated a, atrophied
 
1. myLot reputation of 93/100. krayzee (826)   ranked 5,439 out of 26,857 in people   2 years ago

Yes. I think models should refuse to waste away for the industry. But maybe a ban from the government should also help.

I think anorexia is a very serious illness. Not to mention that quite a few models died in the recent months because their agents told them to lose some more weight. This should be unacceptable. Asking a young healthy-looking girl to lose weight else she wouldn't get modeling contracts should somehow be forbidden. Don't get me wrong, is not that I want the models to be fat, of course I don't but nowadays some of them are downright emaciated. It really shouldn't go on like this.


myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4890)   ranked 108 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

The young girl (I think she was about 25)who was the presenter in last nights program only weighed 7 stones to begin with which is 98 pounds. She lost 14 pounds to become size zero and when she put on the size zero dress she had bought as a target, she looked lost in it.She had no shape of her own anymore .
Then she and her friends threw the dress in the dustbin and they went for a meal.:)


myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4890)   ranked 108 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

The young girl (I think she was about 25)who was the presenter in last nights program only weighed 7 stones to begin with which is 98 pounds. She lost 14 pounds to become size zero and when she put on the size zero dress she had bought as a target, she looked lost in it.She had no shape of her own anymore .
Then she and her friends threw the dress in the dustbin and they went for a meal.:)


myLot reputation of 93/100. krayzee (826)   ranked 5,439 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

Wow. She must have been a very ambitious girl to lose that much weight that fast. But I doubt it was very good for her health:(


myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4890)   ranked 108 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

I think you are right. Her doctor did not approve but said he would support her with it to expose the truth about how unhealthy it was.
She completely changed her diet and was subsisting on mostly fruit and vegetables and excercising like mad with the help of an american fitness trainer. She said all she could think of all day was how hungry she was feeling.
It was a brave thing to do for a documentary .
She regained her original weight in 2 months.

Aspx Errors Free Download: Aspx Errors Repair Tool. 100% Safe & Guaranteed. AspxErrors.FreshPCFix.com
 
2. myLot reputation of 94/100. AmbiePam (10688)   ranked 338 out of 26,857 in people   2 years ago

I saw a thing on the TV the other night about how designers keep making their clothes sizes they really aren't. They 'mis size' things to make them appeal to women. I don't know when our whole mindset changed on the way a woman should look. Should we blame Twiggy? I think if there were a ban on size zero models, there would be a positive response. Women on the catwalk and on the sidewalk would relax and feel freer to be themselves with less restrictions. I would love to think models would take the first step and refuse to model clothes with zero as the size. However, I think it is going to have to happen elsewhere. There is always some model, somewhere, desperate to be in the limelight, no matter what it takes to get there.

RV Lots For Rent and Sale Florida Family RV Resort - Clermont (Disney)/Crystal River/Salt Springs. www.eliteresorts.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 82/100. coolseeds (2368)   ranked 1,032 out of 26,857 in people   2 years ago

I don't think it should be banned but I must say that I do not find it attractive. Personally I wouldn't lose weight for a job. Not that I can. LOL. Maybe 5lbs which will be gone in 2 weeks now that I am busy.

I think someone who would want to do that to their body has serious issues. Mental or drug.

Anorexia Treatment for Adults/Teens Low fee, effective, outpatient treatment. Los Angeles, 310-277-2796. www.drkrevoy.com
 
4. myLot reputation of 96/100. polachicago (6168)   ranked 984 out of 26,857 in people   2 years ago

Our body structures are not the same. I am size 0 USA, so I am probably size 4 UK, or 34. I look and feel very healthy. I wouldn't ban size, but modeling agency. Some people are ok with any size as long as they don't look anorectic. I like healthy and not too skinny look.


myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4890)   ranked 108 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

I think the average here must be a size 12 which is about a 30" waist as aopposed to size 4 which is about a 23" waist.
People who are size 10 to 12 look perfectly slim and healthy to me.Its true though,your skeleton governs your shape.
I remember reading about mens body building and there were 3 types of physique governed by skeleton. All the top body builders fell within one type,the others while still muscular and lean really didnt have a hope of ever winning a major competition.


myLot reputation of 96/100. polachicago (6168)   ranked 984 out of 26,857 in people  2 years ago

Correct, I have the same weight as when I was 16 years old ....nothing change...but I am not toll and my bones are small...

 
5. myLot reputation of 71/100. DelicateFlower (247)   ranked 4,960 out of 26,857 in people   9 months ago

I do not think banning any particular size is the answer. I have personally known two girls who had the body of a model naturally. Both these girls had very fast metabolisms and were constantly snacking because they got hungry in a couple of hours. I would rather that the industry have a policy that every prospective model must pass a physical examination before the contract is signed. If a young woman is starving herself to an unhealthy weight for her body, a doctor should be able to find some signs of that in an examination. The scale isn't the only thing you look at, blood pressure, pulse, urin analysis. If everything checks out in the normal and this girl has a history of good health then she should be allowed to take the contract. That way healthy young women of many shapes could participate, since we all know that healthy and beautiful come in many forms.

 
similar discussions
Is hollywood to blame?
I wanted some different opinions on this topic...Do you think Hollywood is to blame for anorexia,...
anorexic at 4 yrs old?is this possible?
aside from being a picky eater, my niece who's only 4 yrs. old is very concious with her body.she...
Did Hilary Duff Look best in Lizzie Mcguire?
Lizzie McGuire was definitely a great television show to watch at.After,the show Hilary Duff has...
How can you help an anorexic person?
How do you help a person who is continuing to lose weight?
Fat or Thin
What if there are only two types of people and you ... yes you ... still don't have a pair. Would...
Do you think Nicole Richie really has an eating disorder...
Or do you think it's because of stress like she says it is?
Educate yourself
Too many people believe that eating disorders are only about food and weight tissues, when in...
Do you prefer Fat,Med or Skinny...In a Mate?
I prefer Med build, but has to be Tall.
Do you think models are too skinny at times for their own good
I feel they are too thin at times. which actually makes you see their body to their beauty