sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

Who Will Live or Die in this Last Book? email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series3 years ago

Did JKR really say one of the deaths will be early in the book? If that's the case, let us be prepared.When she said two main characters would die, I immediately figured Voldemort and Harry. Honestly, I don't see any way Harry can survive this series of books. That would also explain why that guy (the editor/publisher guy) remarked that he just sobbed after he finished the book.
There seems to be so much conjecture about whether Harry will die or if Harry is a Horcrux etc, but let us not forget that these books are in essence written with children in mind. How sad it would be if JKR ended with Harry lost to the world that has shown him such promise.
JKR has been quoted as saying that two main characters will die, that there is a price to pay for battling evil. So it may come to pass that Harry neither battles alone nor perhaps dies alone (if that is what's install for him). I am becoming more optimistic about Harry.
I think Snape will feature heavily in the outcome of Book7. He has a redemptive pattern to his behaviour. Like us all, he is neither wholly good nor wholly evil. He has, I believe, no other loyalty than to himself. In HBP you get the inkling of his early wish to shine and be recognised for his talents. I think as he grew older and was passed over and forgotten by many he became bitter and that was his impetus to join LV. To be associated with power and notorious by association. Maybe Snape will battle with LV and weaken him for Harry to finish him off? I don't have much hope that Snape will remain intact though!

Maybe he will pay the ultimate price?




book
 
 
harry potter series
sponsors
Washington DC NYE Party
Buy Washington DC NYE Event Tickets Online Today! Safe, Secure,& Fast.
www.NewYearsPartyPicker.com/DC

Macy's ® Wedding Registry
Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%!
MacysWeddingChannel.com

2003 insight at Yahoo!
Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote.
www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  harry potter, harry, lexicon, jkr, horcrux
 
1. myLot reputation of 98/100. mihimolly (4889)   ranked 2 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

I wonder about the malfoys being finished off. Snape may have made an agreement with Narcissa to finish DD off if Draco didn't do it but I dont think Voldemort was there at the time was he? LOL
He wont take an agreement between his minions as making any difference to his promise to Draco of murdering his whole family. So anyway,I think either Mr,Mrs or both elder Malfoy's will die,probably MR because Bellatrix is sister to Mrs and he doesn't want to cause too much dissent in the ranks.
I think the other person to Die is most likely to be voldemort although he nearly died before and was only saved by Peter pettigrew who I think will not do that a second time.


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

Most probably the Malfoys will die and it might be Voldemort who is going to finish them off in the end, remember what Dumbledore told Harry that Voldemort doesn't forgive easily with all that had happened in the Hall of Prophecy.

Washington DC NYE Party Buy Washington DC NYE Event Tickets Online Today! Safe, Secure,& Fast. www.NewYearsPartyPicker.com/DC
 
2. myLot reputation of 86/100. racheldarcy (2399)   ranked 5 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

Interesting....I heard that JK Rowling said she didn't want anyone to carry on the characters once the series has finished. Now this seems an odd thing to say as unless every character died she will not be abl eto prevent this. I interpreted this to mean that she would kill off Harry but thinking about it perhaps she was just stating a desire that she doesn't want it to happen and not implying that she was actually going to write the story in a way that it could not happen.

As it is a children's book I think that the three main children will all survive. Perhaps I am just being a bit optimistic here! The guy sobbing may not have been due to a main chracter dying - I think the death of a Weasley or even another child coudl be quite upsetting. Or even if Harry is badly injured so cannot be an auror or something like that coudl be written in quite an emotional way. Of course we have ignored the fact that it could be a very happy emotional ending.

I think that Snape may be absent for a while and then turn up just in time to save Harry at a very crucial moment. i think he needs to prove to the readers that Dumbledore was right to trust him. I am not sure whether he will die. Perhaps that will be the upsetting ending - no one (not even the readers) has any trust in him, then he proves that he is good but it is too late for anyone to rescue him and he dies thinking that everyone hates him. What do you think?


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

That's a very positive impression about Snape but at this point in time i still hate him because he killed Dumbledore, see aside from Harry he's one of my favorites with all his wisdom and everything.About the other deaths as well JKR mentioned it in the harry potter lexicon that one of the Weasley twin is going to die in the last book, very sad indeed.

Macy's ® Wedding Registry Create or Find a Registry @ Macy's. Rewards Program Save 5-10%! MacysWeddingChannel.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 69/100. smellsyummy (405)   ranked 101 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

I am only on book one, but my cousin is a HUGE Harry Potter fan(she is 17) and she can not get enough of these books.
I don't remember her saying anything about Harry dying in the future though. Personally, I would be sad if that happened.


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

Do read all the books and its worth it:)

2003 insight at Yahoo! Find Washington, DC area used Honda car dealers and get a free quote. www.promotions.yahoo.com/honda
 
4. myLot reputation of 92/100. wickedstepma (730)   ranked 182 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

I like your idea of Snape weakening Voldemort for Harry. I agree that Snape has always been striving for recognition. I feel that it is very possible that he will be one of the ones to die.

I also feel strongly that Neville Longbottom will be one of the ones who dies. Possibly standing up for his friends.

I don't think (maybe wishful thinking) Harry will be one to die. Dumbledore was happy when Harry told him how Voldemort resurrected himself using Harry's blood. Now both won't have to die if one does, because in essence part of Harry (his blood) will die if Voldemort does...and I think he will, finally.

I really hope that none of the Weasleys or Hermione make that list.


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

I'm really dreading to find out who's going to die, i was devastated when Dumbledore was killed by Snape (or should i say murdered!) anyway let's hope for the best:)

Washington VIN History at Carfax Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports. www.Carfax.com
 
5. myLot reputation of 96/100. lvap0628 (582)   ranked 41 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

I think that Snape will figure heavily in this last book even if he's no longer at Hogwarts. He still has a debt to pay to Harry's father who saved his life when they were students and I think Snape will try to save HP's life when Harry faces Voldemort. And since the prophecy said that either HP or LV has to die in the end, I think its LV and Snape who will die in Book 7. Or am I just wishful thinking?
*LOL* I still believe in happy endings though and I don't want the three best friends nor Ginny to die in the end.


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

I really hope soo too, looks like it would be Ginny and Harry in the end, awww...

washington post employment Search Jobs & Post Your Resume on Washingtonpost.com - Try Now. www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
 
6. jv1979 (20)   ranked 764 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

It would be really really sad if Harry died in the end. JKR would probably introduce more characters in the book and kill them off. My guess is that Voldemort would be the other major character who will be killed. Or one of Harry's friends who would sacrifice their life for him. It would still be sad either way. Harry is becoming bitter and dark as the book is progressing. I do hope Rowling has good stuff in store for Harry and Hogwarts.


myLot reputation of 87/100. bubblesheun (690)   ranked 37 out of 1,377 in harry potter series  3 years ago

All our hopes and expectations rely in this last and final book:)

Self Moving Storage WA Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required. www.MiniuStorage.com
 
7. lindajia (61)   ranked 767 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

i think Harry is going to die, maybe killed my his friends or teachers...
i don't know, i think harry is no longer the centre of the story

Single Aspx Page Get Matched with Sexy Singles in Your Area for Free! Sign-up Now. www-Join.com/singleaspxpage
 
8. myLot reputation of 94/100. accioetoile (197)   ranked 10 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

See, the quote I remember about two characters dying, that everyone is using for their arguments about who will die and that just 2 characters will die, is actually not just "only 2 characters die". It was something along the lines of "I saved one character, but 2 characters I did not intend to die, did" So I believe that more than just two major characters will die.

British Passport Renewal Services Urgent Experts handling, on time solutions. Call us for Instructions. www.passportdocs.com
 
9. myLot reputation of 96/100. ram_cv (2271)   ranked 1 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

If you want to hear the two characters who are going to die here you go:

The one to die early would be one of the Weasleys most probably papa Weasley. And the one to die at the end would of course be Harry Potter.

BTW, the book has long tresspassed the realms of children. I don't think any child under the age of 15 is going to understand the complexities of the plot from the third book onwards. So I guess that is not with JK Rowling's consideration at all.

Cheers!
Ram

Travel to Washington DC Why Wait? Browse Travelzoo's Washington DC Travel Deals Now. www.Travelzoo.com
 
10. snigdha220491 (6)   ranked 652 out of 1,377 in harry potter series   3 years ago

yeah...even i think snape is playin a positive character.
dumbledore said a "please snape" in HP 6th...imagine dumbledore pleading...nt possible
i think DD has asked snape to help him finish off himself nd help harry aftrwards to kill voldy
harry has to die...that's for sure nd if harry dies voldy is also destined to die
atleast ron nd hermionie r alive

Casting - "Breaking Dawn" Casting ID# 52152, Grab a Twilight Role Before The Deadline Ends. ExploreTalent.com/TwilightCasting
 
sponsors
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com

washington post employment
Search Jobs& Post Your Resume on Washingtonpost.com - Try Now.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs

Self Moving Storage WA
Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required.
www.MiniuStorage.com

similar discussions
comparing harry Potter series and Twilight
Which one do you like better 1. Harry potter Books or Twilight Saga Books? 2. Harry Potter Movies...
The Best Of Haryy Potter
Out of all the Harry Potter books there are so many things that are unforgetable. What is your...
Did you like the 7th Harry Potter books' ending? (spoiler)
I'll try to blab to fill up this space so that no one who sees this discussion will witness a mega...
Which character you like the most in the Harry Potter Series?
I would fancy the Weasley twins. They are awesome and their pranks used to drive me crazy. Their...
Why does people compare Twilight Saga to Harry Potter?
HI to all. I'm just curious why does some people compare this two? Any opinions there? I like both-...
Harry Potter 7 and 8!
The DVD of Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince (6) came out recently, and it features the first...
Hermione
If you could say something to her, what would you say?
what sort of fanfiction do you read/write?
I love HP and Buffy. Spike is just too awesome to not write about. What do you write? What...
How many times have you read any or all the books of Harry Potter series??
I have re-read book6 before the release of book 7...and watched all the movies before watching...
Harry Potter being considered "childrens fiction"?
Ha. I'm not just starting this discussion in hopes of justifying me checking out the 7th book last...
sponsors
Washington VIN History at Carfax
Don't spend $1,000s on a lemon - Get CARFAX Vehicle History Reports.
www.Carfax.com
washington post employment
Search Jobs & Post Your Resume on Washingtonpost.com - Try Now.
www.washingtonpost.com/jobs
Self Moving Storage WA
Free Truck Rental with move in. Reserve now. No CC required.
www.MiniuStorage.com
Single Aspx Page
Get Matched with Sexy Singles in Your Area for Free! Sign-up Now.
www-Join.com/singleaspxpage
British Passport Renewal Services
Urgent Experts handling, on time solutions. Call us for Instructions.
www.passportdocs.com
Travel to Washington DC
Why Wait? Browse Travelzoo's Washington DC Travel Deals Now.
www.Travelzoo.com
Casting - "Breaking Dawn"
Casting ID# 52152, Grab a Twilight Role Before The Deadline Ends.
ExploreTalent.com/TwilightCasting
Washington DC Real Estate Appraiser
Flanagan Associates Residential Appraisers. Fast Quality Service you can count on.
www.flanaganappraisals.com
D.C. Chrysler Dealer
Learn About New Deals at Your Local Washington Chrysler Dealer
www.ChryslerDealer.com
WA Appraisal License
Start Your Appraiser Career Today. 110% Money Back. PDA Included.
www.RealEstateLicense.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.