Peter Jackson or Andrew Adamson-Who is the better director?

Tweet

Here's room for a heated debate--LOL. I'm a great die hard fan of both the Lord Of The Rings movies directed by Peter Jackson and Chronicles of Narnia directed by Andrew Adamson--my question who is the better director? In your opinion who interpreted the original books better--or do you think it's a tie. A lot of fans of Tolkien bash Peter Jackson's movies...saying he really strayed from the books...the thing is in my opinion if Jackson had done the movies EXACTLY the way the books were, there would have been a lot of confusion, not to mention each movie would have probably been fifteen hours long!! In any event, while I'm a die-hard Tolkien fan, I think PJ did a great job of it. As for Adamson--I think like Peter Jackson, he's short of a genius in how he interpreted the C. S. Lewis books--His expansion of the battle scene was terrific, since in the book it's only a casual mentioning that's only a few paragraphs long--to stretch out such a small scene in the book and to come up with such a spectacular scene in the movie is incredible For me it's a tie then