sign in • sign up
web   discussions   tasks   blogs   photos

More buff than brains in 300  email this discussion to a friend?

myLot reputation of 78/100. driedmango (198)   ranked 7,086 out of 10,799 in watching movies 5 years ago

I got this article from Inquirer website. Enjoy!
---
More buff than brains in 300
04/13/07
Posted under Republic of Comics, Cult of Genre

By Alex Villafania, hackenslash Reporter
INQUIRER.net

MOVIES with epic battles have become a staple in Hollywood. Most likely, this became a trend after the smashing success of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, which cast tens of thousands of virtual warriors battling it out in open fields. Most recent epic movies with casts of almost or a little over a thousand were “Troy,” “Alexander” and “The Last Samurai.”

But it doesn’t take a large group of soldiers to make an epic movie great. In fact, it would only take a few hundred and this holds true in the movie “300.”

Directed by Zack Snyder, “300? is the movie adaptation of the 1998 graphic novel of the same name by renowned comic book master Frank Miller. As such, Snyder stylized the movie according to Miller’s visual designs and comic strip shots. People familiar with Miller’s work would also remember a previous movie adaptation of another graphic novel, “Sin City,” which also used comic book-style cinematography.


“300? follows the story of King Leonidas and his army of 300 Spartan warriors who faced the million-strong army of the Persian God-King Xerxes. Leonidas and his men prevented Xerxes from pursuing his conquest of Greece by blocking his army in a place called Hot Gates. Despite days of relentless attacks from Xerxes, Leonidas stood his ground and even exacted so much damage against the Persian army. However, the Spartans were betrayed by Ephialtes, a son of a Spartan soldier who was rejected by Leonidas for his deformity.

Miller’s story itself is based on a real historical Battle of Thermopylae in Greece, which happened 2,500 years ago. Much of the context of Miller’s graphic novel stuck to the original story but there were inaccuracies, including the number of Xerxes’ army [it was said to be just about 250, 000 soldiers], Xerxes himself being an androgynous giant, Ephialtes ever meeting Leonidas, and even the type of armor worn by the Spartans [historical Spartans wore light armor plating covering much of their body while Miller’s buff Spartans looked like they were going to a Chippendale party].

Because Snyder wanted to adapt the same designs as Miller’s comics, he used computer-generated environments as backdrop in about 80 percent of the film instead of shooting in real-world locations. This did a fair job in replicating the hazy and gloomy graphic novel atmosphere, which also made the movie look like it was part of a video game’s 3D cut scene. The shots were done in blue or green screen stages wherein the background images are digitally placed as underlay to the characters in post-production. Many of the film sequences followed the same comic panels in the graphic novel so that those who have read Miller’s “300? could compare it with the movie. Sadly, the backdrop almost becomes increasingly bland over the course of the movie primarily because it looks so surreal and fake.

The movie’s fight choreography also follows some of the basic fighting style of real Spartans, who only carried with them a short sword, a circular shield and javelin. In particular is the phalanx technique wherein the first layer of Spartans will serve as shield barriers against an onrush of enemies while the second layer will strike with their long javelins. However, the sword fights are overly done, somewhat toned-down version of Chinese wushu. This was done probably to make the hand-to-hand combat more dramatic.

Of course, the most obvious aspect of the movie is the lack of any body armor for the Spartans, who showed more skin than clothing. Historically, Spartans would barely wear any clothing when exercising and joining sports but were known to wear light body armor to keep them mobile. In the movie, they only wore a helmet, leather briefs and flowing crimson cape. Their near-nakedness did manage to show off ripped, testosterone-laden physiques. Just goes to show that even men in their 40s can still get great-looking bodies.

However, despite a good storyline and a stylized cinematography, the movie’s acting is less than stellar. Stage actor Gerard Butler seemed to be unable to let go some of his stage acting style, which emphasized a lot on facial expression and loud, perceptible voice. His character as Leonidas often made loud, expressive calls to his soldiers and he often bared much of his teeth that made him look crazy than determined. Meanwhile, Brazilian actor Rodrigo Santoro was made to look effectively effeminate as Xerxes in the film. A scene where Leonidas and Xerxes meet spills some sexual overtures. Again, historically, Xerxes never met Leonidas face-to-face.

Of course, the movie has a parallel story about Leonidas’ wife, Gorgo, who has to convince a committee of old parliamentarians to send forth support for his husband. This part of the movie does not have any real connections to Leonidas’ own, only as an intermission from all the gory battle scenes.

Perhaps the most insignificant part of the movie is in the last part where the Spartan Dilios, played by “Lord of the Rings” actor David Wenham, narrates the story of Leonidas to thousands of Spartans. Wenham’s character goes for a minute in a monologue that sounded more like an inspirational speech than a battle cry. The monologue should have been cut in half to lessen the dramatic effect for a movie that depicts gore and violence.

That said, “300? is a popcorn film that should be watched if only for its epic battles and fancy depiction of Spartans. “300? is committed to giving Miller fans a visual treat of their favorite graphic novel but does not really give a lot of explanation for most viewers who might think that real Spartans are naked warriors. Hopefully, nobody would think that these add-ons are true.

 

watching movies
sponsors
2012 Chrysler® 300
Get Info, Photos& Find A Dealer At The Official Chrysler Site Today!
www.Chrysler.com/300

Security Guards 24/7
Complete Guard Services operated by Former Law Enforcement 24/7
www.MaxumSecurity.com

Security Management
Earn a Certificate in Security Mgmt Online. Accredited. Respected.
www.StudyatAPU.com/SecurityMgmt

User has not selected a best response.
tags:  300, body armor, buff, comic strip, movies
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. kathy77 (6833)   ranked 1,654 out of 10,799 in watching movies   5 years ago

Oh I did not think that Lord of the Rings was as good as it seemed like it was going to be but Hollywood sure made a go of it and made a lot of money from this movie. The movie 300 I have not seen yet but I do hope that it is a lot better than Lord of the Rings.

2012 Chrysler® 300 Get Info, Photos & Find A Dealer At The Official Chrysler Site Today!  www.Chrysler.com/300
 
2. myLot reputation of 96/100. ram_cv (7097)   ranked 42 out of 10,799 in watching movies   5 years ago

I absolutely agree that the movie is more buff than substance. For one, the actions sequences are brilliantly done, but where is the strategy where is the planning and why deviate from the reality. All in all the movie is quite watchable, but does not make much of sense. It just shows that there is blood flowing all around and 300 fought against 30000 soldiers, but how and why is not well documented.

If you want to check out my complete review on the movie, check out:
http://www.epinions.com/content_339490016900

Cheers!
Ram

Security Guards 24/7 Complete Guard Services operated by Former Law Enforcement 24/7  www.MaxumSecurity.com
 
3. myLot reputation of 90/100. 5000ml (1829)   ranked 1,678 out of 10,799 in watching movies   5 years ago

I've heard similar reviews and I can easily believe it's true. Some of my female friends are raving about how great the movie is, but it's mostly only because the actors are practically naked! A Greek friend did tell me the movie is quite historically correct, but I'm honestly surprised she even noticed that seeing how much she was drooling over the actors ;)

Security Management Earn a Certificate in Security Mgmt Online. Accredited. Respected.  www.StudyatAPU.com/SecurityMgmt
 
4. myLot reputation of 82/100. painkiller77 (1294)   ranked 818 out of 10,799 in watching movies   4 years ago

great idea and knowledge. but to me 300 is an absolutely terrific movie. the attitude, the valour the spartans display send a chill down my spine. so much to keep their honour. they challenged and even demured a person who projected himself as god. i think they were bogged down by the wrong priests who just had no respect for these warriors. my personal favorite line in the movie when the king says : SPARTANS NEVER RETREAT!!!!!!!!!!. the greatest sequence when the king as a young lad fights the beast and also , when he kicks the intruder into the well..

Super cheap Body Armor Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.  www.Body-Armor.best-price.com
 
sponsors
Super cheap Body Armor
Over 6.000 shops& 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.Body-Armor.best-price.com

Forensic Science Schools
Compare Top Forensic Science Colleges& Find the Best Match For You!
www.ForensicScience.ClassesUSA.com

Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com

similar discussions
The movie ''300''
Has anyone seen this movie? I freakin' love it. I thought that all the fight seen's were very much...
The epitome of computer graphics and a brilliant script.
When you see this movie you find it's a bit unconventional with all its weird graphics and...
is it really based on ture story ?
i love 300 i read somewhere that the story is the movie is based on true events. is it true?
anybody see 300?
Hello everybody this was truly a great movie only part i didt like was where the queen slept with...
sponsors
Super cheap Body Armor
Over 6.000 shops & 23 Mil products! Best-Price.com - the shop expert.
www.Body-Armor.best-price.com
Forensic Science Schools
Compare Top Forensic Science Colleges & Find the Best Match For You!
www.ForensicScience.ClassesUSA.com
Local Coupons
1 ridiculously huge coupon a day. Save 50-90% on your city's best!
www.Groupon.com
Man Cheats Credit Score
He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score Using This 1 Easy Tip.
www.SecretsOfYourCreditScore.com
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.