sign in • sign up
web | myLot | discussions | tasks | blogs | news | photos
homeinterestsdiscussionstasksblogsnewsmessages friendsphotosearningsmyLotquizzes

sponsors
Obama Urges Homeowners to Refinance
($90,000 Refinance under $489/mo) See Rates - No Credit Check Needed.
www.LowerMyBills.com

Obama Backs Auto Insurance Regulation
Drivers Pay $44/mo on Avg for Car Insurance. Are you paying too much?
Auto-Insurance-Experts.com

Online Degrees
Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now.
Education.Nextag.com/Online-Degrees

Judge orders 3 to trial in Anna Nicole drug case email this discussion to a friend?

By LINDA DEUTSCH
AP Special Correspondent
 
2 months ago

LOS ANGELES (AP) - Three key players in the troubled world of Playboy model Anna Nicole Smith have been ordered to stand trial after a hearing that plumbed the drug-fueled depths of her final years and the alleged roles of her boyfriend and two doctors in feeding her addiction to prescription drugs.


A judge who heard sometimes shocking testimony about the flood of drugs provided to Smith ruled Friday there was sufficient evidence to try the defendants on charges of conspiring to give Smith sedatives and opiates.


Defense lawyers had argued that lawyer Howard K. Stern, Dr. Sandeep Kapoor and psychiatrist Dr. Khristine Eroshevich tried desperately to save the doomed model in her waning years, including a period when she gave birth to a daughter and lost her grown son to a drug overdose.


One of the last pieces of prosecution evidence introduced was a transcript of an investigator's interview of a Smith friend who said she saw Stern placing pills in her mouth.


"He poured them in her mouth like you would a bird," Gina Shelley said in the interview.


Superior Court Judge Robert J. Perry stressed that his ruling required only minimal proof that would cause a reasonable person to suspect the defendants committed the crimes. He dropped one charge that Eroshevich gave Smith placebos, finding there was not sufficient evidence.


With attorneys battling over whether Smith was addicted, the judge proclaimed, "I think you've proven (Smith is) an addict."


All three defendants pleaded not guilty, If convicted they each could face more than five years in prison. A Dec. 11 arraignment was set.


Eroshevich was the only defendant to comment after the hearing.


"I understand that I have to go through this process," she said.


Smith died of an accidental overdose of at least nine medications in February 2007 at a Florida hotel. The defendants were not charged with causing her death but were accused of conspiring to illegally provide her with controlled substances and supplying drugs to an addict.


Defense attorneys contended their clients did not know Smith was an addict and were trying to help her.


"Criminalizing a doctor's efforts to help a difficult patient is problematic," Kapoor's attorney, Ellyn Garofalo, told the judge before his ruling. "A doctor's even poor judgment is not criminal. Good faith is involved."


The hearing delved deeply into Smith's troubled life and the role the defendants allegedly had in feeding her drug addiction as they were swept up in her celebrity world. Larry Birkhead, the father of Smith's young daughter, said he never saw anyone take as many medications as Smith.


Prosecutors tried to show the doctors blurred the line between being physicians and friends. Kapoor once rode with Smith in a gay pride parade and worried in a diary excerpt read in court that she might ruin him because he had kissed her.


Attorney Adam Braun, who represents Eroshevich, said his client was Smith's friend first and then her psychiatrist.


"The weight of testimony is that my client cared deeply for Anna Nicole Smith," Braun told the judge. "She was well intentioned."


Stern's attorney, Steve Sadow, said the drug charges should not apply to his client.


"Mr. Stern is just a layperson," Sadow said. "He is not a doctor, and he is being charged with doctor-related activities."


The judge said at one point in the hearing that he was convinced all three defendants cared deeply for Smith and tried to help her.


The defense lawyers also objected to charges involving the use of pseudonyms on Smith's prescriptions. They said the practice was common for celebrities and noted Smith had even been checked into a hospital under an assumed name.


Prosecutor Sean Carney argued there was no "celebrity exception" to the law.


Outside court, attorneys for Stern and Eroshevich said they were pleased to have had the chance to see so many of the prosecution's witnesses - 17 in all - because it gave them a preview of the prosecution at trial.


Kapoor's lawyer, Garafolo, said the case could have serious consequences for doctors and patients everywhere.


The hearing included testimony from a bodyguard who provided a searing description of Smith's final days and his futile effort to revive her when she stopped breathing.


There also was testimony about the effects of methadone and a heavy duty painkiller called Dilaudid also known as "hospital heroin." An expert witness said there was no legitimate medical reason for Kapoor and Eroshevich to provide Smith the amount of sedatives and painkillers they did.


A pharmacist said he refused to fill an order for drugs written by Eroshevich and submitted by Kapoor because taking them would be "pharmaceutical suicide."


Possibly the most powerful witness against Stern was never seen at the hearing. A nanny who worked for Smith in the Bahamas was interviewed by an investigator who read her comments from the witness stand.


The nanny claimed Stern kept Smith in his thrall by persuading her to take excessive amounts of drugs that sent her into a stupor where she would sleep for three days at a time.


Although the judge reminded lawyers repeatedly that this was just a preliminary hearing, it had the feel of a mini-trial.


Defense lawyers, who challenged testimony on cross-examination, presented no witnesses of their own, holding back their evidence for trial.


 

AP Entertainment Writer Anthony McCartney contributed to this report.

tags:  united states, anna nicole smith, drugs, alcohol, death
 
1. myLot reputation of 91/100. the_vicar (4853)   2 months ago

This case gets more bizarre each day. There is little doubt Anna Nichol Smith had a drug and alcohol problem but was it enough to kill her? And did her boyfriend Howard Stern have her sedated because she was grieving over the loss of her son? I think there needs to be answers to many of the questions surrounding her death and there are even more questions surrounding the death of her son. There needs to be deep investigations into those deaths IF it is shown Smith died from drugs being forced on her and the reason for it.

If she was sedated because she was so unhappy that's one thing, if she was sedated because there was hanky panky going on between the doctor and Stern or if Stern was wanting control of Smith's finances, then that's something else. All of these questions have to be answered before any kind of judgment can be made.

 
2. myLot reputation of 95/100. lelin1123 (4535)   2 months ago

I believe there is alot that we don't know about concerning the doctors and Stern and what they were doing to Anna Nicole. I seriously think Stern was over medicating her either to prevent her from doing something or to kill her so he could get her money. I know something was not right and I hope all that are involved will be taken care of. Doctors can't continue to give more medication then their patients need no matter if they ask for them or not. Its about time that doctors are accountable for their actions. Elvis, Anna and now Michael have died because doctors have over medicated them. This has to end and end now. Every doctor involved in giving more medication to anyone should be arrested and put into jail with their license to practice revolted.

 
3. myLot reputation of 96/100. snowy22315 (8130)   2 months ago

I dont know about this whole thing. The thing was really pretty sickening. I gues ther are some things that are really never going to make any sense. anyone who really cared about her would have insisted she went to rehab.

 
4. myLot reputation of 87/100. lampar (1880)   2 months ago

As a playboy model and inherited big sum of money from her dead billionaire husband seem very likely she can afford to continue paying for those medication and drugs necessary to fulfill her needs no matter how high the prescription and doctor fees going to cost, it is more likely they profited much from her inheritance if they can make her dependent on them in her life if she become an addict, this woman seem too novice to realize that she put her trust on the wrong people.

 
sponsors
Online Degrees
Get Your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now.
Education.Nextag.com/Online-Degrees

Online College Degrees
Get your AA, BA, Masters or PhD at a Top Online School. Start Now.
CollegeDegreeNetwork.com/Degrees

other entertainment news

Gehry to design arts center in NY theater district

A nonprofit theater selling tickets for just $20 is bringing one of the world's most renowned architects to New York's pricey theater district.

Started in other entertainment news • 3 hours ago • 0 responses
Tags: united states, gehry arts center
Megan Mullally returns to B'way in 'Lips Together'

Megan Mullally (muh-LAHL'-lee) will return to Broadway in the Roundabout Theatre Company revival of "Lips Together, Teeth Apart," Terrence McNally's comedy about two married couples sharing a Fourth...

Started in other entertainment news • 9 hours ago • 0 responses
Book: Prosecutors were prepared to indict Clintons

Prosecutors investigating Bill and Hillary Rodham Clinton were prepared to seek indictments of them for their roles in the Whitewater and Monica Lewinsky affairs, an explosive new book about the...

Started in other entertainment news • 5 days ago • 0 responses
Tags: united states, clinton book
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton waves as she arrives at the Bella Center for the plenary session of the UN Climate Summit in Copenhagen, Friday, Dec. 18, 2009. (AP Photo/Heribert Proepper)
Medieval `mourners' to leave France for US tour

The white alabaster figures draped in cloaks show their grief in different ways: from a bent head, the face shrouded by a hood, to a hand swathed in cloth reaching up to wipe a tear.

Started in other entertainment news • 1 response • Last response by echomonster (0) • 11 hours ago
Tags: united states, french mourners
Gehry-designed theater set for 2012 opening in NYC

An independent theater company that had once planned to move to ground zero will get a new home designed by famed architect Frank Gehry in New York City's theater district.

Started in other entertainment news • 10 hours ago • 0 responses
return to mylot
We are loading a word from our sponsors. No thanks, cancel loading.