is audio book an effective learning tol?

Indonesia
May 19, 2007 4:13am CST
Hi.Do you think that we can learn from an audio book?would you buy an audio book to learn something?at what situation would you buy an audio book to learn instead of a traditional paper pack book? thanks a lot!
2 people like this
7 responses
• United States
19 May 07
There are a whole lot of books on my "to read" list right now, and I hoped at one point to get through some of them with audio books. Unfortunately, I tried listening to a book that I had already read, and discovered that I would tune it out very quickly, and not really hear what was being said. So I decided that audio books are not for me.
• Indonesia
19 May 07
i borrowed my cousin's ipod to hear his audio book but it bored me..i thought because the book,but when i read the hard cover book,it wasn't as bore as the audio book..thanks for your response!
• Philippines
19 May 07
Hi, I play audio books when I'm driving my car to work. It's another way for me to learn correct grammar, usage, and pronunciation. Besides, you can also pick salient points from these audio books, and you are making good use of your time especially when you are caught in a traffic congestion.
1 person likes this
• Indonesia
19 May 07
oh,u can focus to the audio book and driving in the same time?i don't know if i can do that..but it's a good idea if you stuck in the middle of the traffic jam.thanks for your response!
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
2 Jul 07
I think they definitely work if you can learn that way. I buy study guides on audio when I can. I wish I could buy all my books on audio. The only thing that really wouldn't work on audio, is math. So that takes off some science things too, like physics. Learning about Einstein's Theory of Relativity on audio is kind of hard because of the equations. So even though I could have my physics book put into audio since I'm disabled, I didn't have it done. Instead, I have a friend who will read it and then show me when it gets to the equations.
• Indonesia
2 Jul 07
learning about Einstein's theory from audio book??just read the tittle already make me dizzy,lol.i really2 not into science in any forms.it's good to hear that the audio book is working for you.i prefer the old fashioned way to read :) thanks pigglies for your comment!
@Darkwing (21583)
19 May 07
I prefer not to buy an audio book. I love reading. I think you take it in more if you actually read. Audio books would naturally come in useful for people who can't read, or blind people, but I think they take away from the pleasure of reading if you are able to do so. No, I would stick at my normal paperback or hard back.
• Indonesia
19 May 07
i think i have to agree with you.i bought an audio book to listen in my ipod but it was very boring..different with the normal book.but it will be useful for blind people for sure.thanks for your response!
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
2 Jul 07
I can't grasp what "pleasure of reading" means at all. For me, I always hated books. And then, I discovered audio and suddenly, I could "read". Reading on paper was slow and painful (literally, it gave me horrible headaches). But on audio, I finish books so fast it's unbelievable.
@Darkwing (21583)
19 May 07
Yes, you can't get into it as well because your eyes are doing nothing and you tend to get sleepy and lose your concentration. I'd much rather read. You're welcome and thank you too.
• United States
20 May 07
The only audio book I would buy for learning would for a foreign language. Listening to someone read drives me crazy because it's so slow. I also learn better by reading than listening. But for people who can learn by listening, audio books can be very useful.
• Indonesia
20 May 07
i listened too before and it was a man voice (is it always a man?)and the way he read it was so flat and it made me feel sleepy.thanks for your response
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
20 May 07
James Burke - host of Connections
I have hundreds of audio books, because before I retired I listened to books on tape or cd while I did my data entry job. Now I listen to cds in the car, I have no trouble listening to a book while driving, but then again, I'm not trying to get an education from these, they are novels. I have listened to some light non-fiction - Chicken Soup & stuff. I prefer fiction unless I can find a good history book. I think I could handle a "Connections" type audio book too, but I'm not sure about some deep subject. Now, my roomie got a lot of her education on audio because she's visually impaired.
• Indonesia
20 May 07
i think my problem is lack of focus when listening audio book.when i read normal book i have no problem because my eyes and my brain both are focus to the book.
@zamm13 (363)
• Philippines
19 May 07
IF you has a car and you drive most of the time and your job's nature is travelling then audiobook is good. But i still prefer visual books. You need a good pair of ears to clearly hear what the audiobook is saying.
• Indonesia
19 May 07
you are right.i have a car and it's very difficult for me if i drive and listen to audio book in the same time.i need to focus while i'm driving.thanks for your response!