is scrapbooking environmentally unfriendly?

Singapore
December 14, 2007 3:13am CST
Do you think scrapbooking is environmentally unfriendly? For those who do not really know what scrapbooking involves, here are some samples: http://madewithlove.com.sg/gallery/ in years gone by, people used to scrapbook with literally scraps found all over the place in their homes. however, it has morphed into a huge industry these days. a 12x12 inch patterned paper can cost close to US$1 each. and albums cost around US$30-40. paper flowers, brads, eyelets, epoxy stickers and the like all cost $$$. the more branded they are, the more costly they get too. thing is, a large amount of paper goes into making a scrapbook layout. In this day and age when everyone is trying to save trees, reduce the use of plastic bags, do you think scrapbookers and the manufacturers in the industry should do some soul searching and look for ways to reduce the amount of paper used in this hobby?
2 people like this
8 responses
@whyaskq (7523)
• Singapore
16 Dec 07
It is rather costly to invest in scrapbooks, isn't it. Personally, I would use recycle paper should I find myself indulging in such a hobby one day. Literally scraps for scraps. LOL.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
yeah, some scrapbooks from Prints are expensive, and the acid free covers that come with them. but with shrewd buying it can be not so expensive. with the 40% discounts, sometimes it gets me thinking that there are 40% markups to the cost price! the problem with scraps for scraps is that if you want it to last, the scraps have to be acid free. otherwise if it comes into contact with your photos they will yellow with time.
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
18 Dec 07
But if you save every place else on your supplies and embelishments, add the 40% off coupon, the cost per album is acceptable. When all else fails, get a 3 ring binder, page protectors and you got it made cheap as humanly possible!
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
16 Dec 07
No it isn't costly to scrapbook. It used to be when it hit its hay-day, but now that it is more common adn known about - pretty reasonable. Yes the albums themselves can be a bit high, but there are other ways to get appropriate albumes, plus if you watch sales and the 40% off coupons at some craft stores, you can get them quite reasonable. Watch scrapbook related web sites and stores. I have a blog Scrapbook for Box Tops and I give away free scrapbooking embellishments in exchnage for Box Tops 4 Education labels that you send me. Link in my profile. So your trash (as you throw away the box with the label) can be turned into treasures! Watch other sites nad pick up their sale days. I use to watch several sites, and at the end of the month just shop their clearance section - great deals! Watch dollar racks at Target and Walmart and those stores. Dollar Stores have quite a bit now! And I also have an article about where to find embellishments and supplies that are literally free or so low cost, you just didn't know where to look - Scrapbook Layout Ideas - link in my profile. Ever checked your junk drawers for stuff? or the hardware store? or yard sales? Lot of stuff out there for cheap to nothing. YOu just have to want to find it.
1 person likes this
@lilaclady (28206)
• Australia
14 Dec 07
I guess nearly everything we do is environmentally unfriendly in some way, so we can't go through life thinking of that all the time or we will just all stop living, can I can assure you with all this talk about global warming and such it will be the little people doing all the giving up for the enviroment, I say it is ok for the Governments of the world to get on the high powered jets to go talk about saving the world while staying in theit top class hotels with spas and all the other perks when they could hold a conference type call on the net and save energy, money, and a lot more...they will not give up a thing but they will decide on what we have to give up.... Lilaclady steps off her soapbox. :)
• Singapore
14 Dec 07
I do agree. like the recent conference on climate change in bali. all that first class flights for world leaders to go there and talk, and they can't agree on the wording! anyway, i guess we should just do our part. if we use more paper in scrapbooking, maybe we can use a few lesser plastic bags. haha.
1 person likes this
@lilaclady (28206)
• Australia
14 Dec 07
Oh my goodness don't get me started on plastic bags...we have laws about plastic bags as they say they end up in the bay and end up in drains and so forth well that is well and good but these days nearly all celebrations done by Government departments and sporting events these days it is fashionable to let thousands of balloons fly into the blue horizone, where do these smart people think the balloons end up...in the very same place the plastic bags end up...oh they are smart...
1 person likes this
@buggles64 (2709)
• United States
14 Jan 11
Since we bought our own bags to use at the grocery store, we have really reduced the amount of bags that have stocked up in the broom closet.
@lexus54 (3572)
• Singapore
15 Dec 07
In a way, you can say that scrapbooking is environmentally unfriendly because of the materials used, but in my country, this hobby hasn't really taken off in a big way yet unlike in US or Australia. But if you think about the how people over time have preserved their memorable moments, certainly the advent of digital photography have cut down on the use of photo paper for printing of photographs, because many people now store and share photographs in digital format than in printed format, and given that very many people now have turned to using digital cameras, there would be environmental savings in not printing out photos. Also some people have gone on to do electronic scrapbooking, so that's another environmental saving there. I'm now seeing more and more electronic scrapbooking sites, and I just enjoy all the creations.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
you're right abt digi scrapping. but somehow I prefer the paper ones... the texture and the pop out effect of embellishments are just not recreated in a digi layout.
@lexus54 (3572)
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
You are right. Paper scrapbooking has its own followers and appeal. You can't feel the real 3-D effects in electronic scrapbooking, but in the electronic form, you can play around with many text fonts, shadow effects, etc. and the amount of textures at your disposal are plentiful, so I would say that the electronic form has its own appeal too.
1 person likes this
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
16 Dec 07
I'm a a scrapper and I give away/swap scrapbook embellishments for box tops for education labels to help my grand daughter's school fund raiser so nothing I have ever goes to waste. Box Tops 4 Education is a program Pillsbury and other big brands has to help schools. Scrapbook for Box Tops - link in my profile. So while I am not wasting scrapbook supplies and being frugal and non=wasteful, others are getting embellishments insteado f buying them and not throwing away so much paper from the products!
1 person likes this
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
that's a cool idea. I don't think they have that system going in my country. although recently i made some cards to sell for charity...
@coffeebreak (17797)
• United States
16 Dec 07
I am a 10 year vet scrapper. Things have gotten a lot less expensive these days. PEople are seeing you dont' have to pay those high prices. You can find supplies and embellishments all over hte house or other places. I have a blog about scrapbooking if you can to take a look - Scrapbook Layout Ideas. Link in my profile. But as for the paper - I think you are nit picking - yes it uses paper but so do coloring books - at least with the SB you have memories for generations to come. COloring books are just colored and tossed. Talk about wasteful. Or how about homework? Kids have ato write the assignment, turn it in, it is graded, given back and to the trash it goes. Or newspapers - you read them and they are tossed. Plus, if you are a true scrapper, you know that we don't waste an inch of paper. We use literally every inch of each sheet of paper. I'd say scrappers are the most frugal and waste consciouncious (sp?) people there are in the craft industry.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
you're right! we use every inch cos it costs money! :)
@tiffiny (872)
• United States
15 Dec 07
Wow I never thought about that before! I am going to actually change the way I do my scrap booking thank you for pointing that out to me! One question thoe, can you recycle the parts of photos that have been cropped?
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
i suppose you could shred it up, and stick it as decoration or use it in a shaker box?? ideas! :)
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
14 Dec 07
OMG another politically correct, ecofriendly attack on something that is simple, fun and crafty. Yep, I scrapbook, and actually I throw away very little, I use scrap pieces for other pages. Oh and I love the papers they have now, however, I didn't realize that eyelets, brads and such were made from trees, hmmm thought they were metal. Oh and yes, I am one of those 'horrible' people that actually have a non ecofriendly Christmas tree, aka real tree in my home. Oh and by the way, I work for the Forestry Service, so yeah I know about condervation, and woods, and wildland fires, but that's a whole other subject.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
17 Dec 07
don't get me wrong. I Luuurrrvvveeeee scrapbooking. a total addict myself. just having some pangs of conscience you know... staring at my growing stash... at least some of it is going into making christmas cards this season!
@SukiSmiles (1991)
• United States
7 Jan 08
I never really thought about scrapbooking as being envirnomentally unfriendly. I guess it could be like everything else in this world. But I use almost every last bit of everything. I cut apart the piece left from my pop dots and use them. I save all my scraps of paper. If the piece is so small that I don't feel like saving it, I recycle it along with areas I've cropped from any photos. I also give or trade my supplies with others. I even cut off old buttons from clothing that is no longer good.
• Singapore
8 Jan 08
yes! i use the 'remainder' of my foam dots too! they are great for little cutouts!