Do you think bakeware makes a difference?
@vera5d (4004)
United States
January 28, 2008 4:24pm CST
I cannot make nice cookies.
(I won't get into the "I shouldn't even be making cookies because I'm on a diet...lol)
But no matter what I do, my cookies come out looking weird. It does not matter if I use store bought slice & tray 'ems or if I make the dough from scratch. I do not have problems baking lasagna, chicken, or even cakes for that matter.
My husband says I should enter contests for "best tasting, worst looking"...
Today's cookies were almost burnt on the bottom but still somewhat raw in the middle/top. I had them on the highest shelf in the oven, so if anything they should have been burnt on top!!
I am wondering if I need a different pan. My mom has one of those fancy cookie sheets that's really thick with a lipped edge made by some major brand cookie sheet company...hers look wonderful, like she and martha stewart made them...
My pan is a beat-up pan that has raised edges, kinda like a cake pan, but the sides are really short...
What do you think? Does the pan make the difference?
1 person likes this
13 responses
@schilds (410)
• United States
28 Jan 08
Santa brought me new cookie sheets for christmas. Love them! Makes a huge difference. Also check your oven temperature - they make thermometers for it - they are only a couple dollars. If it is off your cookies can bake wierd. Lasagna and chicken and stuff isn't as affected since they are thicker.
1 person likes this

@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
Our oven is a little off but I have a system down for getting it right...maybe I do need a thermometer...that could be a good thing to get with the new cookie sheets!!
I have been making "healthy" cookies...but I can't just eat 1 cookie...:)

@k1tten (2315)
• United States
28 Jan 08
The pan makes all the difference! I know that I had several pans like that once and they just didn't work well after a while. Personally I'd invest in some new pans if I were you. And forget the diet! A well balanced diet includes a cookie in each hand! lol
And now I want some cookies.
1 person likes this
@Bev1986 (1425)
• United States
29 Jan 08
Yep, I agree with the others... the pan makes a big difference. In fact, I threw all my cookie sheets away and now only use baking stones for making cookies and everything else that goes into the oven.
I get my baking stones from Pampered Chef, but I know you can buy them other places as well. My cookies never burn and they always turn out very moist and tasty.

@vera5d (4004)
• United States
30 Jan 08
I like pampered chef but they can be a bit pricey...I have never used a baking stone, that would be neat to try!

@megumiart (3771)
• United States
28 Jan 08
Yes! I a few different types of baking pans, some are dark-coated metals, and whenever I use those, the bottom of the cookies get burned, and the middles aren't cooked through. When I do the exact same recipe on aluminum pans, they turn out perfect. ;0
1 person likes this
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
come to think of it my mom's cookie sheets are a light metal (i assume aluminum)...think i will put them on the list for christmas next year!!
@lilybug (21107)
• United States
28 Jan 08
I have always had the best results with aluminum cookie sheets when it comes to baking cookies. If I use a nonstick cookie sheet they always seem to start burning on the bottom. I would also get a thermometer for the inside of your oven. Ours heats 25 degrees hotter than the dial says.
1 person likes this
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
yes, I think that might be what I need...thx for the response!!
@Adoniah (7512)
• United States
28 Jan 08
The pan does make a difference. So does the size of the oven comepared to the pan. If you have a small oven use a small pan. If the pan is almost as big as the oven then all of the heat is being held down at the bottom of the oven and that is why the bottoms are burning befor the middle is getting done.
I have a tiny apt. so I have a tiny oven, so I use little baking pans. I even cook one cake pan at a time for a 2 layer cake so that they will get done right even though both would just fit in the oven!
Those air bake cookie sheets are very good! They are expensive but they do work. You might invest in one if you bake a lot of cookies. I just put another pan of the same size under the pan I am cooking the cookies on. It sort of does the same thing. I also use wax paper sometimes to bake them on too. That makes a difference in the burning too. You just have to keep the temp at about 350 and you still have to oil it if it says so.
Happy Baking!
Shalom~Adoniah
1 person likes this
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
i didn't consider pan/oven size relation...will have to taje that into account too! thx for the response!
@Polly1 (12644)
• United States
30 Jan 08
Here are some of my cookie baking tips. Chill the dough, thats important. I bake 2 trays at a time. I change the top and bottom cookie sheets after baking 5 minutes, that way they bake evenly. I also have my oven down 25degress from what the recipe says, my oven is hotter then what it says. I don't have the fancy pans and my cookies come out good. Good luck. If you still have troubles, get those good pans and only bake cookies with them.
@qouniq (1966)
• Malaysia
29 Jan 08
I never face a problem like you even no matter what type of baking pan I am using. I just put my pan in the middle/center of the oven and did not put 2 or 3 layer of them in one time. Or may be it is because of the temperature of your oven. Different oven have a different level of temperature. When first I bought my oven and started to use it, I can't properly use my mom oven after that. After get used with both of them then now I can differentiate the temperature level for baking or whatever thing I want to do with them.

@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
I think I am going to see about getting an oven thermometer...that might make all the differece!!

@Grandmaof2 (7578)
• Canada
29 Jan 08
Yes I do believe the pan makes a difference. The good insulated ones are the best for sure.
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
29 Jan 08
I have no idea what kind of oven we have. It is ancient...probably real popular in the 60's lol :)
@Uroborus (908)
• Canada
29 Jan 08
Yes, if you have an old, beat-up, pan then the surface can get sticky. It also doesn't transfer the heat evenly if the surface is bent or twisted. I would suggest just getting a new pan. Not necessarily a fancy, expensive, one. Just a new one of the type you are using now. I'm sure it will improve things.
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
30 Jan 08
Yeah, mine has seen better days, that's for sure!! I will hopefully be getting a new one soon...
@newfette (338)
• Canada
29 Jan 08
Yes, the pan makes all the difference.
You can use parchment paper on top of your pan to stop the cookies from burning on the bottom. But DO NOT USE WAX PAPER two completely different kinds of paper.
I know a few people who use aluminimum foil, but I have never used it myself so I don't know how well it would work.
Some cookies require the pan to be greased, check the recipe it should tell you. To do that you can use a papertowel or wax paper, get a bit of shortening NOT BUTTER and spread it evenly and thin layer on the pan.
Always prepare the pan before you start making cookies - you'll get better results.
Butter or magarine give the cookie it's crisp on the outside.
whipped butter or butter with low calories can ruin the recipe. If the recipe calls for butter, use butter. Only use margarine if recipe says it's okay to switch them.
Let butter(or margarine) stand at room temperature for 30-45 minutes before using it in recipe.
Preheat oven 10-15 minutes before putting cookies in
Place dough on COOL cookie sheet. Use shiny aluminum pans. Will help cookies brown evenly and lightly. Dark sheets will overheat and burn bottom of cookies.
Check minimum bake times on recipe, even one minute can make a difference.
Take note after your first batch of a particular cooking of cooking time and temp so you know what to do for next time.
Hope those tips help! Happy Baking! For a killer muffin recipe message me!
@vera5d (4004)
• United States
30 Jan 08
those are some fantastic tips!!! Killer muffins sound good...I have yet to screw those up!!













