I need some feedback.

United States
February 4, 2008 10:16am CST
I am trying to rewrite this article, and would like some feedback if anyone is willing to offer it. Specific things you like or don't like about it would be very helpful. http://www.helium.com/tm/308664/preschooler-answered-question-school Thanks
5 responses
@SViswan (12051)
• India
5 Feb 08
I enjoyed the article. Having been a pre-school teacher and a mother of 2, I found it relevant. Though I couldn't find fault with the article, as a suggestion, I would say that you could put the points to be a little more clear-cut. Maybe bullet it....or number it with a heading for each...the article would be a little more professional then. Another way of making it interesting would be to make short situations instead of telling 'when your child plays with towers'. For example 'Sarah was playing with her blocks. Suddenly, she pushed them.' and then you could continue a little about why she did it. People like to read incidents more and they remember the points better then. I'm not an expert in writing. These are just a few suggestions to make it more interesting. I liked your content:)
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
6 Feb 08
I've found that a general summary of points usually gets lost when people just read....but incidents related to the points tends to stay longer in their head because they can relate to it when it happens...and when they see it happening, they go 'Oh! I read about that the other day....that's what she is doing'..and then they get more involved in understanding the child.
• United States
5 Feb 08
I'm glad you liked it. I always like getting feedback from other preschool teachers. I am trying to decide whether I should use such specific examples or make it more general to appeal to a broad audience. Maybe I can do both. Thanks!
• United States
4 Feb 08
Well first off, I definitely agree with your content. In order to improve it in my eyes I would use different words to refer to the toddler(s) as opposed to perpetually using 'your child.' Using alternate words as you started to in the beginning when you made reference to 'your preschooler.' Since 'child' doesn't really have that many applicable, professional sounding alternatives you could perhaps instead not make a reference to -your- child and make the article more general. That opens up a broad range of words that could be used instead, and makes the whole thing sound less repetitive and therefore more appealing to the audience. When the words used are: 'When today's youth play with blocks this happens' rather than 'when your child plays with blocks, he learns' it makes things more generic, and therefore applicable to a broader range of people. Some people (such as myself) don't have children, but are aunts or uncles that still interact with children on a a frequent basis. These people could relate to the article on the 'children in general' level. It also does not limit you to 'When he/she does this, this happens', you can speak about children on a broader scale. This tends to give it a more everyday, commonplace feel, which is what I think you were trying to get at with the references to the children of the reader. I hope I helped.
1 person likes this
@LouRhi (1502)
• Australia
5 Feb 08
I would have to agree with you on this CK, it is a very valid point.
• United States
5 Feb 08
You make a good point, but I've never been comfortable with such a general point of view. I will try it though and see how it goes. Thanks
@dani27 (544)
• United States
4 Feb 08
I really enjoyed reading your article. One reason because I totally agree with it. Being a previous preschool teacher and a mother of a 2 year old I enjoyed reading it. I sit and play with my daughter and read to her and we do make believe and she is a smart cookie. One peice of advice the part that you said about knocking over the blocks. You said that at the beginning and than again, I wouldn't repeat it, I would use a different example. But that is all I would say. Great writing.
• United States
5 Feb 08
Thanks, I didn't realize I repeated myself. And thanks for the compliment. I have lots of articles on topics of parenting andearly childhood education if you would like to read them. The link is in my profile.
@LouRhi (1502)
• Australia
5 Feb 08
I don't like the introduction. Well that was my first impression anyway. I loved the next paragraph though. Remember to talk all I say with a grain of salt though, opening paragraphs are not my strong point either! I have been trying to think of an alternative for you. Maybe something like Play, play, play, that's all preschoolers seem to do. or If you thought your preschooler would be hitting the books, think again. Play is.... or not! As always SC you make some great points and examples and I particularly like the ending that is very strong. Maybe this could be introduced earlier. Good luck let me know when you have leapfrogged hope this helps
@LouRhi (1502)
• Australia
5 Feb 08
Just had one more thought, maybe something about how children have their whole life to be sitting behind a desk of some description being able to play early on is invaluable and builds the foundations for a healthy well adjusted life
• United States
5 Feb 08
Yeah, I don't like the introduction either. It's a little too long-winded. I'm going to change that. I like this idea a lot, because this is exactly how I feel about pushing children into academics too early. Not only is it not necessary or appropriate, they have the rest of their lives to work. Let them have fun for these few short years while they can. Thanks!
@LouRhi (1502)
• Australia
5 Feb 08
No worries, glad I could help. I see your star still shining brightly Congrats again!