Nikon... difference between 18-135, 70-200 and 18-200?
By ahgong
@ahgong (10064)
Singapore
March 27, 2008 3:56am CST
I am looking at the different lenses that are available for the D80 and am wondering, what is the difference between them?
The instructor at the workshop that I attended mentioned these three lenses in particular.
With the myriad of lenses available in the market, I am sure we would not be needing to buy all of them in order to fulfill our photography needs.
For those using the D80, which one lens did you buy that can cover all your general needs?
How bout those using other brands like Canon, Sony, Pentax... which range of lens did you buy that can cater to most of your needs?
1 person likes this
2 responses
@desertdarlene (8911)
• United States
27 Mar 08
I have a Canon camera and if I were just going by focal length, I think you can get the best bang for your buck by buying the 18-200. That way, you can get both wide angle and a zoom/macro shots.
But, I would also like to know what the maximum f-stop is on the lens. The wider you can set the aperture, the better. especially if you like to shoot at night or in low-light. I wouldn't go any smaller(higher number) than a maximum aperture of f2, if I could afford it. If the 18-200 lens had a maximum aperture of, say 1.4 or 1.6, that would be an outstanding lens, but those are usually extremely expensive.
I only have a fixed 50mm lens for my Canon, but with a wide-aperture and it's fantastic. I've had other lenses with my Pentax, but not with the higher apertures and they were hard to use in low-light.
@desertdarlene (8911)
• United States
27 Mar 08
In case anyone's confused and who don't know, apertures are numbered starting at 1 for the widest and can go up from there. So, when I say "high aperture" I mean in the f1 range and "lower aperture" I mean the higher numbers. I'm probably saying it wrong anyway. 





@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
6 Jun 08
Thanks for the valuable insight there desertdarlene.
I just managed to get some clarity on the aperture size and the aperture speed.
What I still cannot figure out is this... what is the difference between a 18-200mm lens vs a 70-200mm lens, apart from the zoom capabilities?
What can a 70mm lens do that a 18mm lens cannot? And the reverse, what can a 18 mm lens do that a 70mm lens cannot?
@desertdarlene (8911)
• United States
6 Jun 08
Generally, the lower the number, the wider the angle. An 18mm lens would be good for landscapes and wide vistas. The higher the number, the bigger the zoom. So, a 200mm lens would get you in a lot closer and is better for objects far away. The 18-200mm lens gives you the greatest focal range of the lenses that you've mentioned. I hope this answers your question.

@trickiwoo (2702)
• United States
29 Mar 08
You should have one main lens known as a walkaround lens. This is the lens that you will keep on your camera most of the time. It should have a pretty wide range so that it can be very versatile.
As for what other lenses you'll want to purchase, you should look at your photography needs. If you shoot a lot of landscapes, you'll want a very wide angle lens. If you shoot a lot of sports or wildlife, you'll want a telephoto lens.
I have a Nikon D70, and my walkaround lens is a 28-300. It's perfect! It's really all I need! The 28mm is wide enough for all of my wide angle needs, and the 300mm is long enough so that I can get really close whenever I need to! In my opinion, you're not going to find a more versatile lens!
As for my other lenses, I have a 1000mm that I mostly use for astrophotography (mostly taking pictures of the moon), I have a Lensbaby 3G which is a selective focus lens I use for real creative shots, and I have a fisheye lens that I also use for creative purposes. I do plan on getting a macro lens in the near future. But for sports, wildlife, landscapes, portraits, still life, nature, and most anything else I photograph my 28-300 works perfectly fine!
Nikon Nikkor lenses can be pretty pricey, so you may want to get some third party lenses with a Nikon mount. I would highly recommend Sigma lenses. I've also heard that Tamron makes excellent quality lenses as well. They are very good quality and much more affordable!
@ahgong (10064)
• Singapore
6 Jun 08
Hmm... 28-300mm lens eh? Does it come with VR?
I wonder how much that would cost.
28-300mm would give one a 10.7 time zoom.
I was recommended a 18-200mm VR lens for the walkaround lens.
It also boast of a 11.1 time zoom.
What is the difference between the 28-300 vs the 18-200?



