Should Intelligent Design be taught in our schools?

United States
April 10, 2008 9:53am CST
I'm working on a paper for an English class. Since I am going into the education field, I thought choosing this controversial topic would prove to be very interesting. I would like to include some quotes. Got anything you'd like to share????Good or bad, doesn't matter, I need them all.
3 responses
@whywiki (6066)
• Canada
10 Apr 08
No it definitely should not be taught in school. Why teach the kids a lie. Evolution is what is happening and their are a lot of facts behind the theory. Intelligent design is a load of crap that can't possibly be proven or even taken seriously. There was a case in the states where the religious people tried to sneak it in in the form of a text book and the courts looked into the case and threw the book out of the schools. If parents want to lie to their kids about it and the churches want to propegate that lie that is fine but leave it out of the schools where kids are their to learn. Not only Christians attend the schools and in fact are a minority in many places so leave the religion to the people out of school and leave the kids to decide for themselves on their own time. Leave religion out of the schools and the government.
• United States
10 Apr 08
Thank you for your input. How would you reply to someone that says basically the same statements about evolution. That is, it is a religious belief. There are many holes in the theory that scientists have a hard time trying to explain. They respond with "we haven't figured that out yet." But then dismiss intelligent design due to the holes that can't be explained and receive the reply,"We haven't found evidence yet." My thesis is that they both should be taught in religious theory classes, not science. Just my opinion, I'd like to hear what others think.
• United States
10 Apr 08
Well, whywiki, I am certainly glad you did not teach my kids in school. The evolution theory is a load of crap and if you have monkeies and apes in your ancestory, then we can blame your family for the AIDS outbreak, right? No primates in my lineage. Just humans, starting with Adam and Eve.
• Philippines
11 Apr 08
Intelligent design can be taught without being indoctrinated. I think what's wrong is forcing the students to believe that intelligent design is the truth. That is not the genuine way of teaching. Since you're going into the education field, I think I should share with you some of my ideas. 1) Education means learning. Learning means rational thinking. And rational thinking always involves arguments, debates, polar opposites, extremes, etc. If intelligent design is going to be taught in schools, the way to do it would be to encourage rational discussions that refer to facts. I believe it is all right to hear out people who are pro or against this theory. To establish the untruth of evolution and other scientific theories is plain close-mindedness. 2) I am a medical student so I have a lot of experiences regarding the so-called conflict of science and religion. But for me, there is no conflict at all. For people who deny that science is unimportant in faith, then I suggest you read up on the writings of Thomas Aquinas. 3) Intelligent design is not a fool-proof theory. In fact, it has many faults. So if it is going to be taught in schools, both faults and advantages should be pointed out. 4) Teach intelligent design to people who can understand and people who are rational. Many people irrationally reject or accept theories without any background on the subject. Do not forget information dissemination. 5) To reject intelligent design either because it is a) blasphemous or b) it is unscientific is a matter of opinion. Everyone is entitled to his or her own opinion, even in classrooms. Hope this helps. If you really are interested in this topic, try researching on "Philosophy of Religion". Thanks
• United States
11 Apr 08
I enjoyed reading your response. You didn't get all emotional like most people do about this topic. I completely agree with your points. #1 is my personal approach to education with my children(we "school" at home), #2 I believe God is the creator of everything, so to say science has no place in religion is saying God didn't create it???hmmm people should think about that. #3. Most scientific theories have their share of flaws, and I think all of them should be approached with this idea. That would helps students develop critical thinking skills, as well as prompt new discoveries, and more open mined future scientists. #4 goes to people from ever side of the fence. They hols true to what they believe or what they have been taught, and assume everything else is irrelevant or untrue. Theories should only be taught to people with open minds and at least a bit of rationality. #5 Right on, you said it perfectly. Thanks for your input! I am researching religious philosophy on my own, but it is also my next class in college, so I'm getting a head start in my textbooks.
• Philippines
11 Apr 08
thanks for your comment. I recommend Thomas Aquinas, Gabriel Marcel and C.s. Lewis. :D