Gender differences...is it how we're born or how we're taught?

United States
August 26, 2009 9:22pm CST
Hello all. The differences between men and women, well some are obvious...such as physical features, but others, like conversation styles, thought processes, preferences for certain things...well we're just different, and yet women have things in common with other women, and the same is true for men. Do you think we are born with these differences, that it is a genetic thing? Or do you think we learn these differences from parents, society, peers, etc? I hope I explained that clearly enough, lol, and thank you in advance for your responses! Karen
5 people like this
16 responses
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hello my friend How come I didn't get notification for this? lol I think this is something that we learn you have some girls that act like little boys because they had all brothers so they were tough with them so therefore the girl grows up tough like her brothers, men are rough and they have their male figures to instill whatever it is they instill in them. Take my grandson for instance he is around me and his mom all the time, he is really sweet he does the whole wrestling thing and all/jumping on the bed/climbing walls, but in general he is really nice and caring which is great don't get me wrong, I tell his dad/uncles they need to spend more time with him so they can teach him how to be a man, we can't you understand. yes we are born with a personality, but it has to be enhanced either for the good or bad, but we have to learn. just my opinion hope you understand what I mean.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
You didn't get notification?? Oh, no! LOL, good morning my friend. Now that I am hundreds of years old, lol, I have observed enough that I know for sure we are born with our own unique personalities, but like you, I believe things and people around us can enhance or detract from that. It is good for a child to have experiences with adults of both genders. Help them develop a more well-rounded idea of people and the world around them. Thank you for your insights. Karen
• United States
28 Aug 09
I could not agree more with you, KittyKat. Life, in spite of its hardships, is great, and so is God and all these wonderful human beings he created.
@kitty42 (3923)
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hello my wonderful friend After I finish responding I got the notification lol glad to share my thoughts with you, I liked the question makes you think and life is beautiful when you think of all the different people/things that can shape us into the wonderful people we are.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Aug 09
hmm..get your stones in hand! The heretic's entering the room.. Being rather simple minded I think of the individual as being an individual. Granted, that individual shares common ground with just about every one else in some way or another through all sorts of avenues (environmental, genetic and on and on..). But when all said and done those commonalities gather into a unique combination we call an individual. ..Let me paint a picture..We all know computers to some extent, so I'll begin there..I buy a computer and it has everything I need. The operating system I want. The gig space I want. Its perfect for my needs.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
LOL, no stones allowed for throwing here. As Christ said, let he who is without sin cast the first stone, and of course, no one could :D I agree that in spite of similarities, we each do have our own individual uniqueness. Thank you for expressing yourself and have a nice day. Karen
• United States
28 Aug 09
Green, what a marvelous comparison and brilliant observations. Personally, I need that tweaking DAILY!! I feel that each person plays their own very important part in God's great design of things, no one any more nor any less important in the eyes of the maker. Hence, that is how we should also see one another! Thank you! Karen
• United States
27 Aug 09
(sorry, wrong button..my humanity rears its ugly again..) After I use it awhile, after the thrill and novelty wear off, I find a couple files missing that should have been included in the original program. Perhaps there's some corrupted files and/or a sound card that's flawed, keeping my speakers muted. Now the question is..should I accept the computer as it is and go on my merry way because that's simply the way my computer is? That's the way I look at natural vs unnatural vs environment etc. We know God don't do garbage and when we were created we were everything He wanted us to be. When we were conceived we left the perfect environment of the Father and started our journey in a flawed environment and, like that computer, we were missing some things that should have been there, or corruptions in our basis, or things that didn't work at all. In the case of the computer you'd no doubt take it back where you got it to get it running right. In the case of the individual you likewise go back to the 'manufacturer' and once the Father has tweeked you, you have a better notion of who you need to be. In the notion of male vs female roles, my favorite observation is that it was a former whoore given the delight of announcing the risen Christ, while the men hid in the shadows and since the Christ did nothing that was not of the Father, I will guess that the Father approved. Sexist notions belong in the recycling bin...As well as many other environmental descriptives that are used to define why an individual is as they are..As I said, I'm rather simple minded. Either we accept as is or we get tweeked. It is that choice alone that defines the individual. ENJOY
• United States
27 Aug 09
I think it is a little bit of both. There are genetic differences between men and women, and denying them just stops men and women from reaching their full potential. However, environmental factors play a large role too. Men and women have overlapping strengths, and the way we are raised can selectively bring out certain gifts and talents. There is no doubt that social learning is extremely powerful.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
I think you are probably right, Singing. Scientific studies have shown, that even beyond the physical differences, there are other things naturally inherent and unique to each gender. As you said, though, social learning is indeed extremely powerful. It can impact one in a negative or positive way. Since the most formative years are when we are very young, parents can also do much to help or to thwart their children developing the desire to reach their own unique potential. Thank you for sharing your wise insights. Karen
@kunizzul (1066)
• Malaysia
27 Aug 09
That is easy. Men and women are different from their physical and personality because this are nature. What make their personality different or same is their environment. It can be from friend, place, family or some incidence that they might have. For example, a woman who doesn't like man. This not her true nature as a woman. Maybe she become like this because she have break with her partner and did not trust any men anymore. Hehe
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hello Kunizzul. Yes, men and women are born with differences, some obvious, some not. But along with that, many other things influence how we see ourselves and others as we grow and experience various things in life. Thank you for sharing your opinions here. Karen
• Philippines
27 Aug 09
God created man in His own image. He created them man and woman. From creation, we see that God designed men and women with distinct differences to be able to fulfill the differing roles that He intended for them. I believe included in His design are the physical, emotional, intellectual differences between men and women. Gender therefore, is something we are born with. However, the dictates of society, environment and sin itself have caused men to behave like women and women to behave like men. These behavioral changes have caused some people to alter God's original design for them thus leading to gender changes. My opinion is that gender is what we are designed by God to be, and not what we PREFER to be. This is just my opinion. Blessings, PeacefulWman9.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hello Blungel. I welcome your opinion here, and think you have expressed it very well. You are correct in stating what the Bible teaches...that we each have a different, but equally important, role in life. And yes, society does tend to hold sway over those who allow it, and some can become confused in that process! Again, I welcome and appreciate your input. Have a great day. Karen
@marctiu (829)
• Philippines
27 Aug 09
Well, for me, I guess we are what we are brought up to be.. It's part of the development of a child where there is a gender crisis where they have to decide at some point in their lives their preferences. Society plays an important role in the child's conduct.
2 people like this
• United States
28 Aug 09
Hello Marctiu. So many things do play a role in how and who we become: genetics, parents, society, and eventually, our own personal choices. I thank you for your opinions and insights here. Karen
@dpk262006 (58679)
• Delhi, India
27 Aug 09
Hi Karen! I believe that it is genetic. The gender difference is by nature. Women think on a different pattern than men and most of the women have some very common features, while communicating and behaving, like-wise men think in a different style than women, however, all men have some common features. You may be right some of habits and mannerism is adopted by women, as they observe others in society and as they are told about it by their family elders.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58679)
• Delhi, India
28 Aug 09
Hi Karen! Thanks for appreciating my response. I agree with you that both males and females come "wired" differently directly from the Creator. You are very right that men and women may have some common features as they all are human, however,each gender do have traits unique to it. Warm Hugs! Deepak
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Aug 09
Hello Deepak. I am happy that you have made the same observations about the difference between men and women that I have done. The creator designed us differently for good reason, and we each fill an important part. xoxo Karen
• United States
28 Aug 09
Hi Deepak. While "nurture" and society do play a role, many scientific studies have now been done that back up what you say. Males and females come "wired" differently directly from the womb, hence from the Creator. While men and women have things in common as human beings, each gender also appears to have traits unique to it. Thank you for your insights. Karen
1 person likes this
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
29 Aug 09
I think it's definately something that we learn growing up. After all a baby girl isn't born with a desire to bake and sew anymore than a baby boy is born with a desire to build and fix. They learn by watching grown-ups and ppl around them. [b]~~AT PEACE WITHIN~~ **STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS**[/b]
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Aug 09
Hi Twoey. I do think how we're raised plays a role. I cannot help but have noticed, too, that boys and girls have different personalities and such from birth. So part nature; part nuture! Have a lovely day. Karen
@yugasini (12892)
• Secunderabad, India
27 Aug 09
hi karen, this difference of women and men,by birth and by society and by parent we know the difference of women and men,have a nice day
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Aug 09
Hello Yugasini. Yes, these things must all be factored in. I think our differences, from whatever source, make men and women a nice team, or of them and their unique characteristics, come the special ways of parenting and working together to build a good life. Karen
@Zhizho (1350)
• Indonesia
27 Aug 09
Hi..I'm sorry that I have opinion that some people don't agree about it.I believe that God has created human in good looking.God has fated about gender that you born be man or woman.So,Parents have a duty to give gender education at early age because it important thing that make influences to their kids.Such as,give a right name that suit with their gender.Kind of clothes,games and put them to different bedroom.So,when there is problem with kid's in gender,parents must be reminded,how they educate their kids.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hello Zhizho. All opinions respectfully stated are more than welcome here, regardless of who does or does not agree with them. We, as parents, should indeed raise our children, boys or girls, so as to give them choices and help them discover their own talents and passions, but it would be wrong to do so in a way that causes them confusion as to what gender they are. I have heard of and seen such a thing, and it does the child an injustice. Again, I value your opinion and thank you for expressing it here. Karen
• Philippines
27 Aug 09
Hi karen, from what I have learned in my gender lit class, there are biological differences between men and women that are inherent and natural. this would point towards the physical differences between the two. but some of the gender differences are produced by social factors or the ideology that were taught to us. so, it can be changed or developed over time instead of being inborn in everyone of us.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hi Abby. Like you, I have read studies and seen television specials on this subject. Most of these studies do point to certain inborn leanings and behaviors for each gender. Like you, though, I think the "hot wiring" is very much effected by things other than how we are when born. Thank you for you valuable insights! Karen
• China
28 Aug 09
Hello,PeacefulWmn9.Personally,I think after we are born,our parents and people around us have influnced our congnition about what a boy should be like and what a girl shoulde be like.Even though we know nothing about the world when we are babies,our parents will start to nurture us referring to our gender,like different dresses or different toys.Then as we grow order,we learn these differences between male and female unconsciously,it is an effection of the whole outside world.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Aug 09
Hi Sunshiney. I have seen and read studies of the differences in our brains, etc., rather the brain differences between males and females, but yes, I definitely believe how we are raised and "conditioned" also plays a big role in how we define gender. Thank you for sharing your observations. Karen
• United States
27 Aug 09
i have always hated the nature vs. nurture debates.....LoL...they confuse my head. It is like asking the "which came first, the chicken or the egg" question. Are girls feminine simply because they are female? Or because their mothers taught them the appropriate ways a "girl" acts? Are boys generally more rough and tumble because they are male? or because SINCE they are little boys, their fathers were willing to play a little more rough with them? As i said...it hurts my head. I can sit here and vacsillate back and forth all not..and still never cometo a solid descision! Awesome question though, and i am interested to see what theories others come up with!
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hi Liz. They can be confusing, yes? But I do believe if we know one way or the other, we have better relationships and do not try so hard to "change" in other what just might be inherent to their gender. I made a concerted effort, since I had all girls, to show them many ways to be and things to do...presents often consisted of not only dollies, but Tonka trucks, for instance. Yet...they still are very much feminine! For me, whatever the true answer to my question, I think choices are valuable! Karen
@dorannmwin (36392)
• United States
27 Aug 09
What a great question. Before I had both a son and a daughter, I thought that the differences between gender was something that was taught, but now that I have both a son and a daughter, I think there are more inborn differences than I'd initally thought. From the time that my son was born he was very different from my daughter. My daughter was always very meek about her food, when my son was hungry, he would throw a fit until we would feed him. Now, my son is a preschooler, he is so much rougher than Kathryn ever was. He doesn't cry when he gets hurt, he'll just point out his boo-boos to us, where as Kathryn would cry about them for what seemed like hours. Now, on the actual gender roles, I honestly think that those are taught.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Aug 09
Hi Dorann. I tend to agree with you from what many mothers have said. I had all daughters, but now, with so many grandsons, I have observed them from birth and believe that some things are truly inherit to males, others to females, regardless of how we are raised or what we are taught! It was very noticeable. I appreciate you sharing your observations here. Have a lovely day! Karen
• United States
28 Aug 09
The only gender differences set in stone are those we are born with. (That includes homosexuals, as I believe they are born as they are, they do not 'choose' to be as they are.) Males are different hormonally than females. They are also built differently, and their brains don't look the same when looked at closely. * Social conditioning changes from culture to culture and varies wildly. Being a girl culturally is very different in Africa, the Middle East, in Mexico. then in the United States or in Britain.
@Archie0 (5654)
27 Aug 09
I think it has equal importance of both the qualities that the way we are born as well as we are taught according the way we are taught of how we are and how we should accordingly behave, otherwise if we say its totally the way we are born then why we see somewhere girls are tomboyish types and somewhere guys act like girls, its thats why half of how we are born and half how we are taught to behave.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Aug 09
Hi Archie. Like you, I feel many factors play a part in who we ultimately become, whether male or female. And one of those factors is simply genentic, or how we are put together as a man or as woman. That, and each of us has a unique set of personality traits, regardless of our gender. And then yes, those other things enter into it after we are born. Thank you for sharing your opinions and observations. Karen