Private or public?
By MsTickle
@MsTickle (25180)
Australia
May 24, 2010 4:39pm CST
Recently here in Aus. a politician came out of the closet. He also resigned as the head of the department he was in charge of. The government department he was in charge of is in a fair amount of turmoil at the moment.
In your opinion, should a politician's private life be open for public scrutiny? Why or why not?
6 people like this
16 responses
@Nickfyoung (323)
• Australia
24 May 10
The trend these days is for the media to go all out for a story and they will go to extraordinary means to get one, including following a public figure and try and catch him on camera in a compromising situation. They don't care how this will effect his family or wife which is the shame of it. However, that being said, people in the public eye must realize this trend in the media and be aware that they are going to get caught out eventually if they are into something in any way a bit secret.
@Nickfyoung (323)
• Australia
24 May 10
Not necessarily, but they still do. There was a level of public sympathy for the situation because of the stress on his wife and family. While media these days are ruthless and without excuse, the public person needs to be aware of this and be squeaky clean.
2 people like this
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
25 May 10
And since they are human and none of them are squeaky clean then I think we should pick and choose our battles. Lets demand honesty in the things that really matter to the job. In any job anywhere, you will not get fired for cheating on your wife but if you are a megastar or a politition then suddenly it is our business? Lets focus on their policies and how they are using our tax dollars. Let their wives worry about the marriage part of it all. I really don't care and why do we?
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
25 May 10
Hi MsTickle,
I think it depends on what it is and it's relevance to the person's ability to run the office they were voted into. I think that it gets taken too far. I don't think a person's sexuality really has a bearing on that ability. I also think that all the public involvement when a politician cheats not only makes it more difficult on the marriage but it also distracts the politician away from his job.
2 people like this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
25 May 10
Yes sid, I think a lot of the time people in office get caught up in the so called perks and privileges of the job and neglect their duty. In my opinion, I think we need to keep a much closer eye on our politicians. Too many of them get away too often with ripping off the system.
@sid556 (30953)
• United States
25 May 10
Hi msTickle,
That was kind of what I was getting at. Clinton is a perfect example. Look at all the time, tax dollars etc that were spent on proving that he cheated on his wife. All our attention was focused on that and really, seriously, Hillary handled it with more grace than our politicians and the country did. It was such a distraction and a set up I might add. And that is just an example. I think we ought to be focusing on the things that matter like what these people are doing with our money.
@ElicBxn (64169)
• United States
26 May 10
unfortunately, the moment you step onto the public stage (being a movie star or a politician) you really DON'T have a private life any more
Anything, and EVERYTHING, you do should be considered as public, so if you don't want to be found out doing something wrong - DON'T DO IT!!! 

1 person likes this
@zandi458 (28102)
• Malaysia
25 May 10
Once a politician acceded the throne in the Government office he automatically becomes a public property. Must remember he is there because of the trust he earned from the public by voting him to power. He should be transparent and ever willing to accept public scrutiny. That is the price every politicians are expected to pay for being a public figure and enjoying the perks accorded to every politicians that run the government of the day. His private life now becomes public and therefore should always maintain a 'Mr Good' image to avoid mud being thrown at his face should he be embroiled in controversies regardless of public or private life.
2 people like this
@bunnybon7 (50970)
• Holiday, Florida
24 May 10
I really think it has a lot to do with whether or not what they are doing. say if its something that effects the public or our money then they should have to answer. here we had a president that fooled around with an intern. I really dont think it should have effected us in any way. his wife was the one it had to be bothering. i really think it was none of our business. but he was nearly impeached because of it. i think it should have been private. as it didnt effect us except for being a big news issue. 

@bunnybon7 (50970)
• Holiday, Florida
25 May 10
same thing my son said. but i dont see the point of them asking him about his persoal life in the first place.
i mean what was the point of that? it wasnt like he was the first to do it. Our most revered (by most anyway, not me) president did a heck of a lot more.1 person likes this

@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
4 Jun 10
No I do not think that a Politician's private Life should be open for public Scrutiny ( as for that matter any Famous Person) as it is their Business what they do in their private time, just because they are famous does not give the public the right to judge them, to know about their faults in their private Life, that is their Life not the Publics,
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
24 May 10
So this guy is gay. If that's not illegal and if his behavior isn't hurting anybody and if he wasn't running on an anti-gay platform, why is it anybody's business? There was a case in the US where a politician was having an affair and he had run for office on a "family values" platform. In that situation, I don't have any problem with somebody exposing him for a hypocrite. But in general, I think private should be private.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
25 May 10
Yeah, he was court using a government vehicle as he left a gay club. He came out to his family and the world and resigned. This is a separate issue really to my query...it was found to be deplorable that the man felt he had to hide the truth all that time.
1 person likes this
@dawnald (85137)
• Shingle Springs, California
25 May 10
I'm going to bet that there have been a lot of straight politicians using government vehicles for unsavory pursuits. But as for him hiding the truth, I think that's kind of very personal.
@neildc (17238)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
25 May 10
the thing that i know here in the philippines is that government employees and officials are being watched by the public. they are usually in the papers and on tv, on radio. and being government officials mean they have to answer to the people, including their personal and private life.
1 person likes this
@6precious102 (4043)
• United States
26 May 10
I do think a person's private life can show a lot about that person's character. For instance, if a person is untrue to his/her marriage vows, that tells me that there's a possibility he/she won't be true to any vow, so how can I trust that person? However, there are other things in a person's private life that have no bearing on whether or not that person is right for a political job. For instance, though I'm opposed to homosexuality, I would still vote for that person if we agreed politically. It would not be his homosexuality but his position on the issues that would cause me to vote for or against that person.
1 person likes this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
26 May 10
I'm of the same opinion 6precious102. There was a poll done on this question where I live and what prompted me to ask the question here was the poll results when I did the poll were 43% - 57% for their private lives to be open and I thought that was a strange result. Most of the responders here feel the same as you. Thanks for your contribution.
@catdla1 (6005)
• United States
25 May 10
They set an example by the work they perform in whatever office they hold. What goes on in their bedroom, behind closed doors isn't anyone else's business. One's orientation for gender preference has no bearings whatsoever. If they are in a committed and responsible relationship, then they are setting a good example.
1 person likes this
@epicure35 (2814)
• United States
14 Jun 10
Anyone who holds himself up as a leader needs to also hold to a higher standard because of his position of influence as a role model. Our leaders should be of exemplary character, not the king of sleazy corruptocrats we have now. They should be able to stand up to public scrutiny if they expect to make laws and decisions which govern the lives of others. They should be of sound moral character and spiritual strength. Anyone who wants to be a leader should also know how to be a good follower so he can make compassionate choices and not just foist things on others that he would not want to be mandated for himself, as in "do what I say, not
as I do".
A leader must have the talent for leadership, not just the money to buy his way in. He should have great ability as a person of merit and heroism as well.
@epicure35 (2814)
• United States
14 Jun 10
mstickle, thanks for your kind confidence re my response. I must note, however, that I failed to proofread correctly and there is an error - it should read KIND of sleazy corruptocrats, not "king". Sorry so sloppy!
@evepin (721)
• Philippines
25 May 10
actually, politicians are public figures so they really are subject to public scrutiny. however, i believe that people should just be interested on info that directly affects the government or the community.sometimes the "bad aspects" gte exposed for the purpose of gaining audience and all.
@karen1969 (1779)
•
25 May 10
You mean he said he was gay? Then why would he be forced to resign? Surely it's not illegal to be gay in Australia? I really can't se a problem with anyone being gay, it is up to them and does not affect their work. I think politicians should resign if they do something seriously illegal, but otherwise their private lives should be private. It is the same with famous people. The UK press has been full of Ronan Keating from Boyzone cheating on his wife but that's their business, it doesn't bother me, I still like Boyzone!
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
25 May 10
Of course it's not illegal in Aus.
That's not the issue here although it does bring up the fact that this man felt he needed to keep his sexuality hidden from his family even, perhaps he would have kept his secret no matter what his position, who knows? The question was based on his circumstances but did not point to his situation specifically...although I guess I can see why anyone would think that. Maybe he felt ashamed and that was why he kept it hidden.
That's not the issue here although it does bring up the fact that this man felt he needed to keep his sexuality hidden from his family even, perhaps he would have kept his secret no matter what his position, who knows? The question was based on his circumstances but did not point to his situation specifically...although I guess I can see why anyone would think that. Maybe he felt ashamed and that was why he kept it hidden. @beaniefanatic13 (5068)
• Grand Junction, Colorado
24 May 10
I want to know about the character of a person, including their private life. I think that a politician should have good MORAL character. I don't want to know necessarily that a politician cheated on his or her spouse, but for character I do. I know doesn't really make sense, and I'm contradicting myself. What I'm trying to say is that I think that a politician or any person who is in the public eye, is a role model and as such should be above reproach. I feel that a politician that can cheat on his family could easily try and cheat the tax payer. I truly believe that all the role models of the world, show how easy it is to do wrong, apologize and that 's suppose to make everything all better, when they are still being asked the same questions months down the road they act like, well I said I was sorry what the heck. A spouse who forgives, never forgets and doesn't trust easily she will definitely question when he's late or why he didn't answer a call. So why does a politician that did wrong not think he has to earn back our trust. They should be held to a higher moral conduct, if they were then would we be where we are now. People don't trust their politicians, I think this is because they tell us what we want to hear then change their agenda, or are led astray or become corrupt. If we got them out of office sooner, I think or system would be somewhat better. WE THE PEOPLE need to hold those in office accountable for their actions!!! No if's, and's or but's if, you can't do the job then let the next person willing to do it, get it done.
So inclosing I believe that what a person does in their personal life is a reflection of their moral character. I want to be represented by honest, forthright and moral persons', and I don't think that is to much to ask for. I know everyone is saying the beanie lives in a fantasy world, their aren't any good politicians left, I think it's our fault fault for not standing up and shouting we aren't going to put up with it anymore.
Sorry for going a bit off topic. As always just my 2 cents worth!!! Happy Mylotting!!!
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
25 May 10
Hi ronz30 and welcome to myLot. That's ok...giving your opinion, saying what you think is what the site is all about...if you are saying you think a lot of politicians are motivated by greed then that's ok. We each see things and interpret them in our own way and so there is no right or wrong. You might find however that by reading someone else's observations that y
ou choose to change your mind. Being a member here is a great opportunity for learning.


















