choose jo hart or shay given / myLot

Indonesia

September 14, 2010 3:49am CST

city is lucyk. they have 2 national goalkeepers, shaygiven is ireland goalkeeper and joe hart is england national goal keeper. whats the best? young and talented goalkeeper joe hart or experienced shay given?

2 people like this

3 responses

sjlskl

@sjlskl (3382)

• Singapore

18 Sep 10

This is definitely a good position to be in. 2 top internationals vying for the same spot. Thou I would like to see both goalkeeper taking turns between the goalpost, this arrangement is not ideal as it will disrupt the continunity of the team. If I am to pick, I will pick Hart. While I will not be willing, I will sell Given off. He had been a good servant to the team and it is only fair to allow him to continue his career and enjoy his game.

1 person likes this

adhyz82

@adhyz82 (36248)

• Indonesia

26 Sep 10

but make dillema for mancini..he got always complain from shay given which protest mancini decision and make situation is not good among a player of city

ram_cv

@ram_cv (16513)

• India

14 Sep 10

Yes, City is lucky with two world class goalkeepers. How I would love to see at least one of them in Arsenal :). Having said that between the two, I still prefer Shay Given over Joe Hart. Last week Hart showed that he can still have that occasional rush of the blood and that cost them 2 points in the final analysis. Of course in the first two matches he kept them in the match!! Cheers! Ram

goalkeepers