Saying no!

Alphy and Bubba - Alphy the grey one is a brat!
@ctryhnny (3460)
United States
January 3, 2013 4:01pm CST
One of my cats is always jumping up on my counters in the kitchen and the stove. When I catch him I point my finger at him and say no your a bad cat. He looks at me and walks away like I didn't even say anything. He's also the one who jumps on the top of my refrigerator but I recently put some extra stuff on there so he doesn't do that one any more. I love him dearly but he's got the devil in him for sure! Do you think he understands when I point my finger at him and say no and just doesn't care? Do your cats listen to you when you catch them doing something wrong or are your cats perfect and never get into trouble?
2 people like this
7 responses
@ZoeJoy (1392)
• United States
7 Jan 13
Cats have a mind of their own. Yes, your cat does understand you but isn't going to pay attention to what you tell her. Perhaps you need to put lots of extra stuff on your counters, just to keep your cat off your counters. :) Is there anyway that you can block your cat out from getting into your kitchen? I put pans of water on the counter that my cat used to like to jump up onto. The pans of water worked for her. When she jumped into a pan of water, she did not like it and it really startled her. She stopped jumping up on the counter for several weeks after that. But then, when she tried again after several weeks when I took the pans of water away, all I did was put the pans of water back on the kitchen counter. I also put a towel on the floor to catch the water when it splashed. Now, all it takes is for me to put a towel on the floor and then, she remembers why she doesn't like to jump on the counter. :) There are different things that are harmless that are worth trying. Perhaps double-sticky tape on the counter might keep your cat off your counters. Perhaps feeding your cat in a different room might help so that she associates her food to somewhere other than your kitchen. Just keep trying different methods to see what works for your cat. There are many suggestions on the internet. All the best to you and your cat.
@rebelann (117199)
• El Paso, Texas
18 Sep 19
That's a really good idea. Lucky for me I don't have that problem.
@Arieles (2473)
• United States
3 Jan 13
I think cats are like kids. When they are little they learn they are not to do something because you have redirected them or distracted their attention. I think your cat cares, he just has a little bit of a mischievous streak. I think cats can be trained to behave just like a dog. When my Mom first got her chiwauwau, she had trained him to go to his little bed in the shed at night. All she would have to say is "go to bed Spike" and he would go into his little bed in the entrance. She also trained him to stay out of the kitchen. He was allowed to go in the living room and the dining room but was not allowed in the kitchen. I think the best thing you can do with training any pet, like any kid and any adult is to praise the behavior you see. Reward them with a treat when they do something you want them to do, and you must begin the training when they are kittens and puppies.
@ctryhnny (3460)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Since I got them when they were already adults I can't say how their previous owner trained them. Thinking about it and the little information I know about her she didn't try to train them at all and she had them since they were born.
@Arieles (2473)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Maybe you could try to redirect them. Put some of their favorite toys in a spot where you don't mind them playing and on the counter put something that will deter them from being there. I don't know what, but something that would make them uncomfortable being up there. I really don't have any other ideas, but trying to draw off from Pavlov's experiment with his salivating dogs. Let us know what you do to get them to stay off the counter because I am curious as to what will work and what won't. Ha! It sounds like they are kids instead of kittens Good luck.
• United States
4 Jan 13
This discussion sounds familiar. I remember you talking about him jumping up on the refrigerator and he talked back to you. Yeh, they are very aloof and they are the princesses and princes of the world. They just feel you owe them for everything and they decide when they want to be nice or not. And no, they don't care one way or the other. I just love cats.
@ctryhnny (3460)
• United States
4 Jan 13
Cats are funny...they will come to you when they want to and not until then! I love cats too that's why I have 2 of them. I do get the feeling that they think I owe them something when it's the other way around and they don't know it but I saved them from being euthanized.
• United States
3 Jan 13
My cats say that they are purrfect. We shall not discuss their attempts to sneak in where I've told them not to go, nor shall we mention the teeth marks in my boyfriend's computer cord that "mysteriously" match up to a certain middle cat's teeth. We also shall not talk about how middle cat made her way up onto the top of the cabinet, which happens to be *ahem* next to the stove. We also won't talk about the attempts on Mommy's food, nor shall we talk about tails almost smacking me in the face while I eat. I will talk, though, of how the "kids" will go trotting into the bedroom when I tell them to do so. I will also mention how my boy brings me gifts. I will even mention how the baby will trill a response when someone (even by phone) asks her a question such as what she is up to.
@ctryhnny (3460)
• United States
4 Jan 13
yeah, my boys think they are purrrfect too. You can tell by the way they walk around and look at me as if they were little angels...NOT!
@911Ricki (13588)
• Canada
3 Jan 13
Try getting a squirt bottle, and mist them, or add a little lemon juice. I did that, when my vet recommended it, and it worked like a charm, when they would jump at the table and steal out food off our plate. They do sell things to keep them off, so when you are not home. But they can be expensive, and I am not sure if they work personally. Mind know right away, they give this sad look, and ignore me for the rest of the night.
@ctryhnny (3460)
• United States
4 Jan 13
I do keep a squirt bottle of water nearby but sometimes I'm not fast enough and they won't know why I"m spraying them! I've tried the keep off stuff and although it smells horrible to me it doesn't seem to bother them.
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
3 Jan 13
My mom used to flash a fly swatter at her cat. never hit him, just a swipe he stoppped the same thing as yours after a few weeks. Try it..
@ctryhnny (3460)
• United States
4 Jan 13
I keep a spray bottle of water nearby but sometimes I can't get to it fast enough. The fly swatter sounds like a good idea.
@wolfie34 (26770)
• United Kingdom
9 Jan 13
Clearly he is a mischievous character and it's probably his nature to get up to no good, our cat is very vocal and she can be very noisy throughout the day, no matter how much my dad shouts at her to be quiet she ignores him, because she knows she will still get to sit on his lap, she will still get fed and will be kept warm! Whereas with one of my ex's cat he was always going into a neighbours house through the cat flap and stealing their cats food! So how do you stop him? They can't close the cat flap because the cats need to come and go, it's difficult to discipline a cat especially when they are so determined and independent creatures.