Why do Americans have such hang-ups about religion?

@indexer (4852)
Leicester, England
September 21, 2015 10:29am CST
As far as I am aware, the Constitution of the United States makes it absolutely clear that the government of the country shall be completely divorced from considerations of religion. It forbids the establishment of a national religion and this has been interpreted as meaning that religion may not be taught or practiced in state schools. By contrast, the United Kingdom recognises the Church of England as the established church, of which the Queen is the Head. It is the law that a daily act of worship be performed in every state school (although this is not always enforced). When it comes to politics, the religious beliefs of MPs, party leaders and members of the Government have absolutely no bearing on who gets into office. It is known that Tony Blair was a Catholic and David Cameron is an Anglican, but Nick Clegg - who led the Liberal Democrats during the Coalition Government of 2010-15 - is an avowed Atheist. However, in the US it would seem that anyone who does not make it crystal clear that they are a devout Christian does not stand an earthly of becoming President! Is this situation not more than a little weird?
2 people like this
9 responses
@Jadedjinn (118)
• Pea Ridge, Arkansas
21 Sep 15
I am an American. I have no religion. All world leaders are filled with corruption seeking only to feed their own greed. When people preach to me i just smile and point out points they have made that contradict what they have just said :-) I just can't help myself. It don't bother me to hear them. Heck i might even learn something. To me politics and religion are alike in the sense that they both tell you what you want to hear in order to keep you under control but that's just my opinion.
2 people like this
• Pea Ridge, Arkansas
21 Sep 15
Yes I believe that to be very true. Makes you wonder what the world would be like if people had been left to decide instead of being told. Imagine what could be had people been allowed to think.
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
21 Sep 15
I think you might have something with that last point! I have long thought that organised religion had as much to do with keeping the "common people" in subjection as anything else.
@topffer (42155)
• France
21 Sep 15
Although the Constitution of the US is clear, there are still 7 states where atheists cannot hold a public office in the USA according to these states constitutions. These articles are never applied today, but it is weird to see that they are still there...
Advocating progressive values and equality for humanists, atheists, and freethinkers   By Matthew Bulger With election season upon us, and a near constant stream of public jabs and rebuttals between incumbents and their challengers, we should focus on som
1 person likes this
@xfahctor (14113)
• Lancaster, New Hampshire
21 Sep 15
lol. There are all sorts of laws on the books that make you scratch your head. Anyway, most of these state's laws are unenforceable and none would survive a court challenge. They can still be a nuisance though.
2 people like this
@xfahctor (14113)
• Lancaster, New Hampshire
21 Sep 15
We got a LOT of hang ups, lol. Seriously though, the idea was to prevent oppression from any angle, including religion. Nothing has been more oppressive to people in human history than religion. This was the reason for keeping it out of our government when we formed it. Our society is predominantly Christian, so I assume this would be the reason why. We've also just not had much of anyone of other faiths run for the job with a very few exceptions. You've got Sanders who is running now and Lieberman back in 2004 who are both Jews. If Sanders gets the Dems nomination he could probably win the general election. But it will have nothing to do with his faith.
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Sep 15
Interesting. I've yet to see a president that I would consider a "devout Christian," but you are of course, entitled to your opinion.
1 person likes this
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
21 Sep 15
OK - maybe I went a bit far with "devout", but an admitted Atheist would get nowhere!
1 person likes this
@Rosekitty (19368)
• San Marcos, Texas
21 Sep 15
Not all Americans have a religion.. and i am one of them unless i call myself one. I do not agree with the government does but i am only one person and it takes knowing someone higher up plus money to change things..something i don't have.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
21 Sep 15
Though the constitution is secular, the American Right has a very strong fundamentalist Christian bias and few US candidates would get far without their votes. A non-religious candidate can run for presidency but the voters would not put him or her in. A candidate declaring themselves atheistic would face vilification from the rather biased religious Right.
1 person likes this
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
21 Sep 15
Absolutely - this is why I described the situation as weird. I have a hunch that it boils down to a basic sense of insecurity that all Americans feel. They see Christianity as a buffer against all ills - especially any that are foisted on them by Islam - and so being led by a Christian is essential.
1 person likes this
@waflay (2737)
• Nairobi, Kenya
21 Sep 15
I think you're right. In the US there are High chances for a Christian to be the president but as for atheists and Muslims, chances for them are so minimal
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Sep 15
I wonder though, had Henry VIII not broken away from the Catholic Church, would the UK have such freedom of religion as it does now? I am so tired of this whole "if you are not christian you are not crap" thing that is going on over here in the States. As far as I am concerned the Politicians and Government leaders over here are no more Christian than they are intelligent.
@FourWalls (86585)
• United States
22 Sep 15
Christianity as an organized entity (NOT individual Christians, mind you) has followed the paganism before it in using force to convert people. And it really hasn't mattered what particular denomination: when the persecuted minority Christians in the 3rd century became the majority the first thing they did was put their foot down (figuratively and literally) on other religions. In England Queen Elizabeth I ushered in the persecution of Catholics. When the "persecuted" religious left England for America and became the majority in the colonies they began to do exactly what had been done to them. There was talk during JFK's run for president that there was "no way" a Catholic would be elected president. Additionally, a lot of Christians believe they belong to the "one true church," and everyone else is going to hell unless they join that "one true church." (There are at least half a dozen denominations that have it in their catechism that they are the "one true church," and they can't all be right!) Personally, I like the Jewish approach. If you go to a rabbi and tell him you want to become a Jew, he'll send you away. If you come back, he'll send you away again. He wants to make sure you're sincere, not that you're doing it because Madonna read the Kabbala or whatever. Maybe Christians should take that approach: live their lives in a manner that makes people want to come to them and ask, instead of waking someone up out of their afternoon nap by banging on their door and hawking their religion.