What Is a Dog?

Cookie the Chihuahua in Bed; photo taken by my daughter.
@Vivenda (583)
Portsmouth, England
November 20, 2015 11:08am CST
I love dogs. My favourite job was working as a desk editor for a firm that described itself, rather endearingly, as a “pet publishing company” and I have edited books about a wide variety of dog breeds. I do not own a dog myself. I am ever hopeful but, so far, Hubby won’t buy me a bow-wow. As I was walking across the park behind our house today, I saw a guy with three dogs. One was a pointer, one a small terrier of some type, and the other a complete mix-up. (I think the guy is a professional dog walker, as I have seen him with other dogs.) He had let them all off the lead, and was trying to get them back again but, as soon as one came back, the other one ran off! It was really funny to see them playing together and, to all appearances, a leggy pointer being pursued by a tiny terrier! It made me wonder, though, how dogs recognise each other as dogs. As part of my above-mentioned job I had to go to Crufts (the UK version of Westminster) each year in support of any of my authors who had book signings. When I’d finished my duties, I’d go to the Discover Dogs section and make friends with the giant breeds: mastiffs, bullmastiffs, great Danes, Irish wolfhounds and so on. Although I knew I could never manage one of my own, these were the dogs that attracted me. In the last couple of years, however, I’ve fallen completely under the spell of Cookie, a minute “teacup” chihuahua belonging to my daughter’s ex. She measures about 14in from her black, retroussé nose to the tip of her inkbrush tail. I certainly couldn’t say that she’s every inch a lady, but she’s every inch a dog! Unfortunately, she’s not very good at measuring dog sizes and has nearly become a snack more than once by swearing at a German shepherd. So, Cookie’s undeniably a dog – as is the magnificent Newfoundland I met on the park one evening. How can two creatures so disparate in size belong to the same species? And how much should we meddle with the natural breeding process of a species? Although my work over several years involved pedigree dogs, I have to admit a predilection for mongrels (mutts), mainly because of health concerns. What are your views?
8 people like this
10 responses
@Rollo1 (16676)
• Boston, Massachusetts
20 Nov 15
I think we have already meddled too much. I would love to know where one could find a mongrel these days. There don't seem to be any accidental pregnancies anymore. Either dogs are bred or they are sterilized.
5 people like this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
20 Nov 15
Certainly some breeds have been messed about with too much. Cookie, for instance, is much smaller than any dog should be. There was talk of breeding from her, but I'm sure that would be too much for her. Also, she snorts and shakes all the time. Both are usual for chihuahuas - but not for dogs in general. She's gorgeous, though - in her own way!
1 person likes this
@sallypup (69160)
• Centralia, Washington
30 Nov 15
@rollo1: come to my house. Our Leah was one of eleven mistakes. She's a good dog though quite frightened of other dogs. 84 pounds of long and lean maybe black Lab and whats it.
1 person likes this
@jaboUK (64346)
• United Kingdom
20 Nov 15
I prefer mongrels myself - I've only had two dogs and they were both of them mixtures. Do you still get to see Cookie?
3 people like this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
20 Nov 15
Certainly mongrels tend to avoid some of the faults that are exacerbated by inbreeding. Trouble is, there's a faint danger that they'll pick up the faults from more than one breed. Yes, I still see Cookie occasionally, and my daughter's often round there. It's the strangest split I've ever come across, for a variety of reasons!
2 people like this
@suzzy3 (8341)
20 Nov 15
I think all dogs are cute as long as they don't bite me. Cute little face arg
2 people like this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
1 Dec 15
Cookie likes to bite, but her jaw is so tiny that bites don't really register.
@allknowing (153544)
• India
21 Nov 15
We had this fad for the pedigree until I saw some strays on the street. I now have a stray who just walked into our life literally. She is priceless.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (153544)
• India
30 Nov 15
@sallypup She just walked into our life. we have many stray dogs around here.
2 people like this
@sallypup (69160)
• Centralia, Washington
30 Nov 15
@allknowing Your photo looks like the dog in it could be an Australian Cattle Dog.
1 person likes this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
1 Dec 15
@allknowing and @sallypup - lovely dogs! If I ever manage to get my husband to agree to a dog, we'll probably go to a Rescue Centre to give a home to an unwanted one. The trouble will be coming away with just one!
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
20 Nov 15
even wild canines like wolves, foxes and dingoes count as dogs. How they sense each other as such is outside my knowledge - they obviously can though - similar with different breeds of cat, etc.
1 person likes this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
20 Nov 15
Apparently, although wolves can breed with domestic dogs, foxes cannot. Dog foxes have been known to react to female dogs on heat, though.
1 person likes this
• Preston, England
20 Nov 15
@Vivenda didn't know that, wow. Thanks
@boiboing (13147)
• Northampton, England
20 Nov 15
What a sweet little face.
1 person likes this
@boiboing (13147)
• Northampton, England
20 Nov 15
@Vivenda Bless!
1 person likes this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
20 Nov 15
Looks can be deceptive. La Cookie is a first class beach, in more ways than one!
@Hatley (163772)
• Garden Grove, California
30 Nov 15
someof the purebred breeds se em to have a lot of health problems while my hienz forty dog a mutt was healthy as could b e .
1 person likes this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
1 Dec 15
Problem is, Patsie, they can sometimes pick up a variety of problems from the breeds that are in them! However, this is probably more true of first-crosses or so-called "designer breeds".
@troyburns (1405)
• New Zealand
20 Nov 15
I love that dogs seem so much less concerned about difference than we are.
1 person likes this
@Vivenda (583)
• Portsmouth, England
1 Dec 15
One problem for Cookie is that she can't interact adequately with other dogs. Most canine bums are quite out of her reach for sniffing!
1 person likes this
@Rohvannyn (3098)
• United States
30 Nov 15
Part of it is scent, I think, and part behavior. It's a bit like humans being able to tell that baby humans are still humans. Dogs react a lot to behavior and body posture, and no matter what the size most dogs are shaped generally right. So I think that's how they know. The difference between a chihuahua, for example, and a bull mastiff or great dane has always delighted me. As for my preferred furry friend, I like cats - they haven't been tinkered with quite as much in general.
1 person likes this
@Hannihar (130150)
• Israel
29 Nov 17
I love both dogs and cats. I had a lab-husky and she was the sweetest and kindest dog. I loved her so much. I loved to be with her.