is smoking a sin or is it not just good?

@ilunice (946)
Netherlands
December 25, 2006 7:55am CST
Yesterday, I was in the company of my friends. we were four in number. One of us smokes a lot. He is a muslim. I don't smoke and so also the other two guys. the other two guys are christian and so also myself. While we were together and discussing on general topics, the friends that smoke brought out his cigarette and his lighter just have a shot. Then one of the other two friends retorted sharply and said "smoking is sinful". Then I asked if he means whether smoking is bad or is it against the law of God in either Islam or Christianity? He answered me that smoking is not only bad but sinful. Then i asked him why? he only told me it is sinful because it imoral. I seem not to agree with him. pls give example and references where applicable.
1 person likes this
4 responses
• Malaysia
14 Feb 07
i don't think that smoking would be a sin..
@Aussies2007 (5336)
• Australia
14 Feb 07
If I were you... I would get myself some new friends. Because one day... they will tell you that breathing their air is sinful.
@perugu (5279)
• India
25 Dec 06
hi,smoking is not at all a sin..its just a habit like anyother..nut this habit is doing harm to us people are restricting..tharts all.....
• Singapore
31 Dec 06
i've asked the priest about this....and he said that smoking is not a sin..but it could harm the body. it will, of course be better if we could quit. i'm a devoted catholic yet i smoke too..but i have to admit that i'm trying to quit now..not because it's sinful, but because of $$ and health purposes :D