Art imitating life or life imitating Art.......

@vega83 (6340)
Bahrain
April 17, 2007 1:57pm CST
You know, I am so sick of hearing every now and then that movies are such a bad influence, that rap songs make us violent and that GTA or any other violent video games, turns us into criminals. Well, to those people who say such things, I would like to point out, that these movies, these songs and these games, are actually not influential but inspired, they are inspired by real life. Let me be more specific, you know, I was watching this show of O'Reilly on Oprah, now I don't care about all of the political issues that they talked about, I prefer not to get into that stuff, because I don't know much about it, but he did say something, that I think I have good authority to speak about, and that's this. He mentioned that his generation were the ones who listened to motown and watched real nice non-violent shows, and now horror and slasher movies, and rap songs are the problems of this whole generation. When in fact, the main problems are created by, oh, what a surprise, guys from his generation. It's so easy to blame the media for everything. Yet, these movies, these songs and even yes, these video games, all tell the true stories of human life. I mean Jack the ripper was pretty much around before all those serial killer movies were made. The Texas chainsaw massacre might be a really gory movie, but it's only after the real life event happened that the movie was made, I mean it didn't seem like he watched a lot of TV, so what would make him do something like that? Rap songs only describe in words the truth of what goes on and around in the lives of these rappers. People in real life have done so much worse, and hurt other people in so many ways that are too horrifying and yet we still think that it's movies that influence that. People think criminals are born because of playing video games, well, I play the most violent video games and I've never killed anyone, or stolen a car or anything like that. I think that people are more comfortable in doing atrocious acts, yet they are uncomfortable when someone talks about these atrocious acts in movies or in rap songs. Why be such a hypocrite? I personally believe that movies are derived from life, and not an influence to any immoral or horrifying act, and people just need to understand that. What do you think about this, do you think that movies or songs or games influence people into being bad, or are these movies, songs and games are just a depiction of what is actually happening around us already, and are just becoming more truthful in showing us the reality of some of our world?
2 people like this
2 responses
• United States
18 Apr 07
I have to agree with you because I truly believe that art imitates life. In terms of bad influence, I think it should be the discretion of the viewer and how he/she views the elements in the movie that he/she would apply to his/her daily life. The essence of what's right or wrong is already embedded in us since we turned 18 (well, supposedly). If a viewer deems a movie to be "not viewable" in terms of, let's say, immoral elements according to the discretion of that said viewer, then by all means don't watch the movie. That simple. You see, there would be no movies if there won't be viewers. The moviemakers would not be earning anything if there would be no takers or viable audience to start with.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6340)
• Bahrain
18 Apr 07
yup, that's right, plus it's all about individual behavior, two individuals can grow up in exactly the same environment and turn out to be completely different people. The exposure is out there, but it's up to us, and in kid's case up to the parents on what we are exposed to, and after that, it's all up to us individuals in what spirit we take, what we see. Movies don't kill people, people kill people.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Apr 07
Thanks for choosing mine as the "best response"! Truly appreciate it.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6340)
• Bahrain
23 Apr 07
You're welcome!!
@nowment (1756)
• United States
24 Apr 07
I think it is a case of people looking to point fingers and place blame because they are refusing to accept responsiblity for their own actions or inactions. If parents took the time with their kids then maybe their kids wouldn't grow up to needing to lash out. hmm well lets see, What about Bugs Bunny, that rabbit was violent, pulled what could be viewed by some as mean spiritied practical jokes etc. Does this mean that our grandparents are people who go out and pull mean spirited practical jokes? What about roadrunner cartoons, did they inspire that the violence in them be emulated? come on when was the last time you saw someone purchase an acme anvil to drop on someone's head? People go to far, prior to the "movies" and music that we have today they had things like Detective Stories, sold in serial magazines, they even had a series of collector cards of criminals. kind of like baseball cards but for criminals. Did the generation that grew up in the 40's and and 30's grow up to be a bunch of violent malcontents bent on serial murders? My mom grew up in that era, as did most of her siblings. None of them have murdered anyone, but they do remember the movies about gansters and mobsters the shooting, killing, etc, yet none of them went out and joined gangs or the mob. On the other hand a boy who grew up in the 50's was spoild rotten, given what ever he wanted, he got away with most of his bad behavior. the boy's father said to his own father "I'm going to give my son everything you never game me" the Grandfather replied, "give him a stick of dynamite you never had one" When his son turned to walk away the grandfather sadly stated, "that boy is going to end up in prison" He did, why because he was never taught consequences, never taught that he had to be responsible for his actions, never taught to respect others, he was ignored half the time by his father and his mother spent to much time drunk. He was taught that if he did something wrong his parents would bail him out, until it got to the point that he couldn't be bailed out. Was it tv? he grew up on bugs bunny maybe it was Wyle E. Coyote's fault for dropping the anvil, or maybe it was Edward G. Robinson's fault for making ganster movies. Or maybe it was the fault of the boy and his parents for never taking responsibility for his actions.
1 person likes this
@vega83 (6340)
• Bahrain
24 Apr 07
Absolutely, parents and kids could take more responsibility for their actions instead of looking for someone to blame. TV is about entertainment, and not meant to educate the child, that's what parents are for, that's what ratings and parental control are all about. Yet still, whenever things go wrong it's always entertainment that is blamed for it, when in fact entertainment is born FROM it.