Homework and children ...

Canada
April 29, 2007 12:13am CST
Should there be a limit to how much homework a teacher sends home with a student each night ? Does a teacher have the rigth to send home homework that requires your participation ? And does a teacher have a right to have your child assigned to a project that involves them being paired up with someone from the class that is to be done on their own time , meaning you having to drive your child somewhere or another child coming over so they can complete the assignment ? When does it become a parents right to disagree with what a teacher is requiring of our children , when is it our right to step in and say enough is enough ?
8 people like this
19 responses
• United States
30 Apr 07
Honestly, I think many of the teachers have taken "homework" and turned it into a break for them to teach. When children spend 8 hours at school and then come home with 3 more hours of homework something is wrong. I'm sorry, my children go to school to be taught not read to out of a teacher's manual then handed a load of printoffs or page numbers to complete and sent home to finish. I think it's gotten out of hand completely when even the kindgergarden kids are bringing home homework. If the teachers would truly teach perhaps school would be complete at the end of the 8 hour day.
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
29 Apr 07
In this area homework seems to be either a ton or nothing. They either give so much homework that the child is doing it from the moment they get home till when they go to bed or they give nothing at all and it's all done in class. There is no in-between with them. I don't think it's right to be sending home so much work that the child gets no free time, where they are working all day in school and then at home as well. They need a break from it just like we do from our work. I also don't think the work sent home should require the use of the parent. It is nice if the parent can help out but it should not require it. They should have taught a basic understanding of the lesson so that the student can do it on their own. Add to that I don't think they should require the student to have the internet at home. Yes some of the teachers expect that here. It's not always available at home for some kids and to try and get them to the library in time isn't always possible. When it comes to group projects I think they are great, for in school but not when they have to try and do them at home. Some of our districts are laid out very strange and the kids come from all over. It's not like they will live just down the street anymore. Some could be several miles a part or more and a child cannot bike over there to work together. We also have a bunch of teachers this year who are doing all in classroom work. Nothing is sent home. Well that sounds great, but you have no clue on what your child is doing. You never see any work. You don't know if the grades they are getting are fair or not. All you see are the report cards. How do you know if that's is or not without seeing the work involved? We've complained to the teachers and the school on it. We've let them know when they are crossing the line. We've complained about having too much or them doing everything in class. Sometimes it helps but not always.
• Canada
30 Apr 07
You have worded it exactly as I was trying too lol . This is exactly how I feel , thank you for your response .
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
1 May 07
Thank you for best response. I'm glad you liked what I said. The school system here in Florida really irritates me so I have a lot to vent on when it comes to schools and what they do to the kids. Over all I think the school system needs a big overhaul and everything redone.
@kgwat70 (13388)
• United States
29 Apr 07
I do feel that there should be a limit to the amount of homework children are given, especially at a very early age. I think it is good that homework is given where the parents and kids work together as it is good bonding plus the parents might learn something new as well. Teachers should not overload the homework on kids though as they need time for some fun and spend time with family. I do not think a young child would be able to focus too long on homework assignments so that is why I think they should not give too much to do, As they get older, they should be given a little bit more homework.
• Canada
30 Apr 07
I agree with you completely :) Thank you for your response .
@xelissa (776)
• New Zealand
29 Apr 07
No I don't think so unless you don't want your children to learn the lessons of life and learn in the best way possible = experience. Working with someone incorporates communication and personal skills which could later in life be very well useful for a job because usually you will have to be working with someone.
1 person likes this
• Canada
30 Apr 07
I agree with you to an extent but when a child is given so much homework that they are unable to complete it all in a night it gives them a sence of insecurtity of not being able to do what is expected of them as not all children are as smart as everyone else in the class and what is the classroom for if as parents we are expected to follow all the rules of the school even if it means having other children over when we don't have the time for this or getting our children some place else when we are unable to do as there are a lot of parents with only one vechile in the household which is used to get back and forth to work each day making it harder to be able to help our children . Also I don't agree with projects that have to be done on a computer at home as not all children have access to a computer but nowadays many schools require work done at home on computers . I believe this is what classtime should be all about . I don't disagree with homework , I just believe it should have limits on what is required . Thank you for your response :)
@cdparazo (5765)
• Philippines
29 Apr 07
I came from a school that is very demanding and whose teachers gives homeworks everyday. It was such a torture for me but it more than prepared me for the career that I have to undertake. I am used to difficult things that I found things when I started working easy. I think it is okey to have ones children paired with other kids because they not only learn to work with others but they also learn how to cope with different personalities of their partners. Bottomline is that they learn and I believe that as parents, we should always be there to help and support our kids. Educating our children is not only the job of the teachers but ours too and it may entail more time to be spent with them. I make it a point, no matter how busy I am to guide my daughter on her homeworks and assignments. Many times I have to take a leave of absence from work and re-schedule some commitments and even miss some deadlines because I have to help my daughter or have to attend to her school needs which may include bringing her somewhere. Teachers gives homeworks for some reasons and I can't really say when is enough is enough. I trust the teachers that they know what they are doing. If I have any concerns as to their teaching methods and as to the performance of my daughter in school, I could always schedule an appointment with the teacher to discuss my concerns. I suggest you do the same so that you will be enlightened as to the methods and reasons behind why the kids are being given such assignments.
• Canada
30 Apr 07
Thank you for your response . I speak with the school on a regualar basis as some of my children have a harder time then others but now I am having to deal with problems because the teachers were not willing to listen to my advice as the one who knew my children and now my children are suffering from this . I had informed my son's teacher when he was in grade 3-4 that he was unable to read and that I was worried about this yet they kept sending home work that was too hard for him so he steadily fell behind . They told me not to worry about this as they were more worried about his self esteem and even though they had a hard time understanding him when he spoke they didn't see any need for him to have extra help . Instead of taking the time then to help him out they just quit calling on him in class and expected him to do all the work at home . He is taught in french which I am not able to help with as I am english and when he would come home he would be unable to do the work because he was to shy to let them know in school . The school knew this but figured if they just let him be that he would overcome his shyness and then they would try to catch him up on what he lost . This was not the case and now my son is in grade 6 and is unable to read or write and now they are realizing that something should have been done years ago but now it is too late too catch him up on all that he lost so he has to be put on an adjusted program . He will never fully learn what was already taught and will always be slower because of this . In this case giving so much homework figuring he would figure it all our at home didn't help , this is what should have been done in the classroom . Also with projects what I don't agree with is you get one child that the teacher knows is not going to do any of the work and you get another child that wants a good mark . Once they get paired up the child who did nothing is going to make a good mark off of someone else . This does not teach the child who needs to be able to do the work but doesn't want to as the other student will always do it . I also don't agree with projects that require a computer as we have a computer but not a printer and yet it is required they print everything out they are not allowed to write it up themselves . This is ridiculous as in life we are still going to need to be able to write things and a computer is just an easier way to do it but if you don't have a printer and I don't believe that should be a requirement to have a child in school . I see a lot of problems in the schools these days as there are children graduating who don't know how to read and write and children who are falling behing but being passed because they don't want to affect their self esteem . In the long run , none of this will help our children when they are out on their own . When I went to school we were given homework but when we needed help the teachers were there to help you now teachers expect we as parents should be doing the help yet we as parents don't have a teaching degree .
1 person likes this
@cdparazo (5765)
• Philippines
30 Apr 07
I think it is wrong for teachers not to listen to you and to notice that your child cant read and write much later. Teacher and parent's support is a big factor in a child's intelligence. It doesn't matter that you don't have a teaching degree for you to help your child learn. Teachers and parents are both responsible for the child's learning. Here in my country, not noticing such learning discripancy may happen only if I send my child to public school. But I believe your country have a very good educational system. I sent my child to school that uses the Montessori system wherein the child's is being taught according to the pace that is comfortable with him/her. You could also explore other options for your child to learn. My younger brother who can't seem to catch up at school had a private tutor and it really helped him a lot learn more and pass. If you could have an expert opinion or recommendation on what to do about your child and help him catch up would be step in the right direction. I think employing the teaching methodology appropriate for your child would be key to your his learning.
• Canada
30 Apr 07
I dont think kids should be given home work, They are in school for about 6 hours a day and then they are sent home to do like another 2 hours of work thats like 8 hours of work a day and then they only have a little time to play or see there family and to be kids .. Which I think is wrong, I find school kinda robs a child from being a child because our school is one of the highest academic school around here, and I find they are demanding in what they teach..
1 person likes this
• Canada
30 Apr 07
Our school is also one of the highest academically and because of this they require each child to know things on a university level but not all children are up to being capable of doing this . I do agree with some homework just not the full day as a child needs to be a child and have some free time as even as adults we get free time . Thank you for your response :)
@nilzerous1 (2434)
• India
30 Apr 07
There exists a subtle difference in opinion regarding Children's homework. While there are people like me who believe that children, particularly in their primary standards, must not be loaded with homework, whereas there are parents who believe that homework is an essential part of the learning process. However, I really strongly against any sort of homework. If you really want to give homework, it must not be more than half an hour's task. The right time to step in and say "enough is enough" - is that time when you find children getting isolated, behaving abnormally, or getting depressed. Parents must keep a close vigil at the homeworks given by the teachers, in case, it crosses the limit, you must intervene into it.
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Apr 07
Homework is for the kids to learn something for the class. The whole point of class is to learn and keep learning. Not just getting GED, AA, BA, and GRAD degrees. You learn to learn as well. Plus if you didnt do homework nothing would stick. However I've heard before that teachers today give way too much. I dont have kids so I dont know how much is true. I think a few hours. But not loosing sleep or anything seeing it depends on the age but still.
1 person likes this
@Grandmaof2 (7579)
• Canada
29 Apr 07
I just think that if more time was spent in the class room and less fooling around there would be more time to get the work done. I don't have anything against homework but I don't believe in 3 hours of it and especially stuff the kids don't even understand. The whole school system has gone downhill as I see it. When I went to school we were taught and we learnt, now a days these kids are graduating and can hardly read and write in some cases.
• Canada
30 Apr 07
I agree with you completely as so many children are unable to spell or read anything and yet still graduating and having a harder time in life because of this . Thank you for your response :)
@jenlynw (41)
• United States
30 Apr 07
yes I think there should be a limit to the amount of homework kids are getting, my kids, grades 4 and 6 both have at least an hour and a half to two hours of homework every night of the week except weekends. I would feel better if they at least had ONE night of no homework, these kids these days are getting VERY little sleep and they are stressed out, which leads to behavior problems in my experience. My youngest child has ADHD and trying to get him to stay focused long enough to get all that homework finished is a nightmare!! Then we have baseball practice, baseball games, and then church on wednesday evenings, so yes, I am definately burned out on all this homework! Not to mention, it's stuff that I don't even understand, (no I'm not smarter than a 5th grader! lol) but like with the math, the way we were taught is no longer the method they use so I'm not much help with that, Maybe parents should unite and meet with the teachers and explain that while we understand the importance of homework, they need to undertand the pressure the workload is putting on these kids, and we parents are tired too, we finished school once already, and I for one do not want to revisit that! lol
• United States
30 Apr 07
I do believe there should be a limit on the homework, and when they send it home, the child should be able to do the work without parental assistance. When my daughter comes home and doesn't understand her homework at all, I have serious doubts about the teacher's ability to do her job at all. And it's not just the homework - this teacher has had to reteach several topics because all the kids failed the quiz the next day. She was an 8th grade teacher who got moved to 4th grade, so her methods of teaching really need adjusted. As for projects requiring my child to get together with another child outside of school? I'd object. I don't know her classmates' parents (and don't care to) and she's not going over there. And I'm not inviting some strange brat into my home, either. As parents, we are ultimately responsible for our children, and we have every right to step in and say enough is enough. I've gone so far as to pull my child out of school and homeschool her. This year she's back in as an experiment, but it appears the school is failing again and I'll be homeschooling her after this year. Some things are too important to trust to the government.
1 person likes this
@gasmas100 (585)
• India
30 Apr 07
todays kids spend alot of time playing games, watching television and other activities. It is necessary to give them Homework, so that they have some constrictive activity to complete or gt a revision of their study once they return home. The best aspect here is that they get to indulge more in their study and spend less time doing other things. I think it is a good idea..........however, it should not be in excess else it may result in fatigue and frustration fo the child.
1 person likes this
@hkdgkurt (146)
• China
30 Apr 07
Hi.samtaylorskykierajen..i do think so..teachers sent too much homework to student when i was in hight school.usually i feel so tired after completed my homework everynight.anyways.teacher has the right to sent homework or assignments how much they want,but how many homework are appropriate should be thinked about by teachers...
@san_here (207)
• India
30 Apr 07
yeah, it's a matter to discuss, it's high time that u think about child's work load, but we cannot ignore home work completely, it has advantages such as child gets a chance to review topics, and get a good continuation, but now things goes beyond this matter, it's changed, as some manager gives assignment to his guys, to complete in fixed time, this is very bad, and sometimes even parents, or in most cases a private teacher has to work hard to complete it, i don't think child gets any benefit from it, it only adds their mental strain since it steals their leasure time. so homeworks should be changed so as they could tend the child to have a practical approach to wat thay studied, and ofcourse they will enjoy it!
1 person likes this
• Canada
29 Apr 07
Yes there chould be a limitfor how mach home work the teacher there could be 2 subject's. Yes the teache can send home work that requires your participation. Yes the teache dose have the right to make parterner's for project's that they have to do.
1 person likes this
@easy888 (10405)
• Australia
29 Apr 07
Hello,samtaylorskykierajen ,honestly,i did not need to do alot of homework when i was studying high school.I think it is important for children to have well development in different things, study may not be the only thing in their studying life,therefore,I think teachers should not give too many homework to the students,they still need some time for their families. Of course teachers have right to give some projects or assignements that require co-operation with otehr students,they can learn how to work with other people through the assignmens and know the importance of teamwork. If the children are too busy in their school work which they need to complete them till midnight everyday,I think parents will have the right to step in and say that is too much.
• United States
29 Apr 07
I think homework has gotten out of control, in some schools. In our local districts the amount of homework varies so greatly, even within the same school district. As far as parent participation, I think that entirely depends upon the age of the child. Obviously some kindergartners/first graders may need help in reading the homework. I don't like partner projects outside of school. I love them in the context of the classroom, but not as homework. I think any parent always has the right to call and inquire about anything that involves their child, homework or not.
1 person likes this
@4cuteboys (4099)
• United States
29 Apr 07
I sort of think they should limit it based on the grade of the child. So far my kids haven't been paired up with anyone, but I am not looking forward to that as the other child might not keep up his/her end ect. Alot of my son's homework requires help or participation. I'm okay with it, but sometimes wish there was a little less. My son was in one school district that was very tough, he had about 2 hours of homework as a first grader. Like three-four subjects of homework a night. When we moved the school he is in now has about 30 mins of homework and usually just one subject for second grade. I think alot of it is the actual school/principal not the teachers choosing the homework, at least that's what my sons teacher told me. She mentioned she disagreed with alot of the homework sent home but that the principal was directing them as to what the kids needed to do and turn in.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
29 Apr 07
erm.. i think there should be a limit on how much homework should a teacher give to their students.. dont' you think so? haha.. i think that's some kind of group assignment.. i think that's okay.. but there should always be a limit to it.. a teacher cannot give a bunch of work that occupy all the students free time.. don't you think so? in my country.. many students are complaining about the homework that the teacher gave them.. they say it's too much.. they have no time to do as they have extra classes after school classes.. and that really occupy most of their time.. do you think it's appropriate to torture students like this? no..
1 person likes this