Did the wrong two go home tonight?
By carolscash
@carolscash (9491)
United States
May 2, 2007 9:07pm CST
Well, after just finishing watching American Idol, I must say that I was shocked at the results. I expected Chris Richardson to be leaving,butnot Phil Stanley. I thought that last night was one of his best performances of the season and that he has done very well the past couple of weeks.
I truly thought that Lakisha would be the other one to go tonight.
What do you think? Did the right two go home or should Phil have stayed?
I am not sure that I will watch the remainder of this season as Phil was my vote for this season to win it. I believe that he will get a recording contract and I believe that Chris will be a big star too. I look for him and Blake to do something together.
1 person likes this
4 responses
@funnycole (392)
• United States
3 May 07
I think Jordin will win it all now. Lakisha should go next and then Melinda. If either Melinda or Lakisha make it to the final it will be a Booooooring final.
@carolscash (9491)
• United States
3 May 07
I hope it comes down to Jordin and Blake. I am not a Blake fan but he seems to be the most original on there and I don't want Lakisha in the final. I liked her to begin with but something has changed and I don't think that Melinda is diverse enough to win it. Jordin seems to be more like Kelly Clarkson was and I think that she has a chance.
@carolscash (9491)
• United States
3 May 07
I thought that Phil was good looking,but each to their own. I guess he will just have to come out with his own album.
@KrisNY (7590)
• United States
3 May 07
Chris has been my favorite since week 1- Blake right behind and then Phil. I don't agree what so ever with the decision- Guess I should have voted another 1000 times! I thought it would be Lakesha and Jordan going home- I'm cheering for Blake now to win this! If he gets sent home next week- Idol is finished in this household! Bad choice America!
@carolscash (9491)
• United States
3 May 07
I am not a big Blake fan,but I really thought that Chris was on his way out. However, I thought that Lakisha was worst than Chris the last couple of weeks. Phil rocked the house with Bon Jovi and yet he goes home. I should have voted more too!!!
@gingisnapz (738)
• United States
3 May 07
It was hard to tell tonight. Jordin had the worst performance last night, but she's had a good last several runs. I really enjoy Phil though and I hated seeing him go. Chris was a given because I've personally felt for a while that he has needed to go. I agreed with Simon when he said Chris is rather nasal when he sings. Nasal singing is something I have a hard time with, so I didn't so much enjoy listening to him as I did looking at him (just don't tell my husband. lol)
@carolscash (9491)
• United States
3 May 07
i figured that Chris was going but I just thought that some of the others would go before Pil. I really liked him. I guess I will wait until some one signs him and he has his own album.
