Would you rescue a dog from a home or go to a breeder?

May 8, 2007 10:37am CST
Hi all, we have just been to our local dog rehoming center and have seen some of the most sorry looking animals imaginable. We are now in the process of rehoming a 5 year old crossbreed called Max, adorable but has had a very hard life. We were wondering about other peoples experiences with rescued/rehoming dogs and how you have coped bring them into your home environment. Would also like to know if you think going to a breeder and being able to choose a puppy, seeing its parents and knowing its history is a better thing to do.
3 people like this
10 responses
8 May 07
I would like to adop from a home aslong as they are not too needy, im all for giving alot of love an attention but if they have to have alot of vet visits and alot of medicines then i will not adopt from a home because i do not have the money to pay for regular vets, i mean a lizard is expensive enough with lizards
2 people like this
8 May 07
I feel we are taking a risk with Max as he is a very skinny and poorly looking dog, but I feel that if we don't take the plunge he will just pine away in the kennels. I know we will have to take out insurance in case of vets bills but we already do that for the one dog we have at the moment and it wont be too much more for Max. As for lizards...wow...I can imagine they need a lot of upkeep and looking after, think I will stick to dogs, much easier:-)
8 May 07
Actuarly the lizard i have doesnt require alot of upkeep, all he needs is to be fed some crickets and veg 2 times a day, washed once a week and misted daily and obviously lots of love and talking to daily!
1 person likes this
8 May 07
Seems like I was showing my ignorance there, sorry about that, I've never actually met anyone who owned a lizard. I just thought they were quite high maintenance, guess I should have done some research instead of jumping in.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 May 07
Every pet my family has had has come from a shelter. I have always found them to be very loving animals. Sometimes they take work at first to learn trust but it has been worth it.
• United States
9 May 07
It took work. We just made sure that we showed no preference for the new one. If someone was petting the new one, someone else was petting the old one. When giving treats, we always gave it to the old one first. For some reason that made a difference. Good luck I am sure it will work out.
2 people like this
9 May 07
Do you find it hard to integrate them into a household that already has a dog. we are trying very hard to keep our GSD as "spoilt" as he was before Max turned up b ut it is a very turbulent time for them both.
1 person likes this
9 May 07
Thanks for the advice, we are trying to keep that up at the moment, but we both still feel like we are betraying our GSD when one of us pets or treats Max. How does a dog make the saddest eyes!
1 person likes this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
9 May 07
Hello Jakester519, All of our dogs are rescue's. Granted, training can often be easier and more complete if the dog is a puppy when it's introduced to your home environment, but shelters and pounds have puppies too. There are so many dogs euthenized everyday, all over the world. For me, finding them homes takes greater priority than breeding more dogs. Now, I understand if people have a personal affinity for certain breeds, or pedigree. But, unless you're looking to breed or show your dog, it's alot more humane to rescue a dog from euthenasia. If you are looking for a specific breed, or a specific temperament, you can usually let the pound workers know what you're looking for, and they're generally very helpful in trying to match you with the perfect new canine buddy. One last thing, often those scraggly, sorry looking animals perk right up with healthy food, exercise, and a large dose of love. Good luck with your decision.
1 person likes this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
9 May 07
How long do you have Max with you until you have to make a final decision? I hope it works out with Max and your family. Wishing you many happy, healthy years together.
1 person likes this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
10 May 07
Hello Jakester519, It's my experience that rescue dogs go above and beyond to be great additions to the family -- they're just so happy to have a good home. I'll be on the lookout for Max's blog. That ought to be fun! Please do let us know how it all goes. Oh, and thanks for the best answer! -Ladyluna
1 person likes this
10 May 07
Hi ladyluna, sorry for the late reply. We have now been told we can keep Max for good but we will have suprise inspections form the centre to make sure we are still looking after him properly. I like the idea of this, it shows they care about their animals even after they have moved on. He is settling in very well and Jake (our GSD) is making sure that he gets the full tour of the house and has even given up his bed (he didn't use it anyway, he prefers a blanket). I was a little worried there would be problems at mealtimes but they don't even bother with each others bowls/food which makes me think that Max has been raised around other dogs in a family environment, especially the way he puts his head in your lap before trying to get on the sofa! Our only regret is that we do not have the room to be able to rehome more dogs, it is so sad to see them in the pens, all I can hope is that more people will take the time out to visit these places and do the right thing. Will keep you updated on Max, he may even be starting his own blog in the future. Thanks for the posts.
1 person likes this
@rosie_123 (6113)
9 May 07
I would always go to a Rescue Home. All 5 of my cats were strays that I adopted, and when I was growing up, my parents kept dogs who were always from Animal Rescue Centres. In my view,those poor aniamls have already had a bad start in life, and deserve as much love, care, and attention as they can get. Also many breeders are unscrupulous, just coining in money with no real care for the health or condition of the breeding mother. To my it is silly to pour huge amounts of money away to a breeder, when you can pay much less and give some poor unwanted animal a good rest of their life.
@rosie_123 (6113)
10 May 07
Actually, running a Rescue Centre has always been my ambition, if I ever won the Lottery and had the money to do it properly. Knowing me - I would never want to part with any of the animals though!!!
10 May 07
Sounds just like my wife! Given the chance and the money she would be opening up the biggest sanctuary she could and never turning any animals away. She has already been expressing an interest in a donkey which I have to keep quashing every now and then. We had a stray dog in our house for a night because after being told by the RSPCA and the police there was nothing they could do, she couldnt bear to tell the dog warden about it. Luckily we managed to trace the owner ourselves through the local vet or we would have had three dogs now, which brings me to another topic, why dont all dog owners ensure their dog has a tag with a means of contacting them on it?
10 May 07
Wholeheartedly agree, as for the money aspect I would gladly pay more to help sponsor the kennels great work in providing the dogs a home until a more permanent solution can be found. With breeders they don't seem to have the same love for the animals, maybe because they are seen as commodoties to be traded. Just wish we had more space for more of the poor dogs that we saw, but then I suppose we would end up running a rescue center.
1 person likes this
@cipher2004 (1183)
• United States
8 May 07
I would have to rescue a dog.I have done it over and over again and would do nothing else to get a pet.I have not had any problems with the 3 I have recued in the past.I think they were grateful to me for taking them home.I now have a dog that my son rescued on the street corner.He was about 3 months old.He is pitbull/dalmation mix.Some adults(not children)were taking turns kicking him on the ground.Then they lifted him up by the scruff of his neck and were taking turns punching him.My son and his friends took the dog from them.If anything you would think this dog would have bad behavior.He is the best dog and does not have a mean bone in his body.My chow/golden retriever was 3 yrs.old when I got her from the pound.She was very shy and scared she lived for 11 more years with me.She was a great dog and had no problems whatsoever.I sure do miss her.You do know that it is a proven fact that mix breeds carry less defects.Therefore a mix can be better in health.I hope I have made up your mind.I think you should give poor Max a try.Just be sure to take him out to relieve his business often.If he messes up kennel train him.He is new to your home and doesn't know the rules yet.
2 people like this
8 May 07
I think if I saw someone treating a dog like that I would feel obliged to treat them (the humans) in exactly the same way. We have Max here with us at the moment whilst the kennels do the home check and vetting procedure on us. He is really such a lovely dog and Jake (our German Shepherd) and him are getting on like a house on fire. Trying to be firm, fair and kind with him, and the initial understandable nervousness is slowly being replaced with some trust as we come to terms with each other. He has definately been someones pet in the past as he does know basic commands and loves a soft bed to lie on! It will be a long journey, but as long as we can keep moving forward together I am sure we will all get there in the end.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 May 07
We adopted our dog from a shelter and she's the best thing ever. She was owner surrendered. When we adopted her, she was around 1.5 years old. She was already potty-trained, knows commands and is a very well-behaved and gentle dog. The only "problem" we had was a little separation anxiety (chewing on stuff)...especially when we leave her for more than a couple of hours by herself. We solved it by giving her a nice crate to stay in when we leave the house. She's happy and we've not had any incident since then. She's adjusted really well to her new life with us and she's such a joy to have. We have a 2 year old son who absolutely adores her and follows her everywhere and vice versa. It's so cute to see them together!
10 May 07
It sounds like you have given your dog the loving home it needed. I just hope we can do the same for Max and he does seem to be settling down nicely even though it has only been a few days. Thanks for the response, it is always nice to hear the good stories.
• United States
8 May 07
What a good question! After years of pet adoption I must say that the crossbreed is your best bet! For some reason mixed mutts are much happier and gentler in general. We have had several pure bred dogs and all have had major problems with their health. If you want to look into a pure breed of a dog, please check out dog sites and look at each breed to see what is the most common problem associated with them. Some are good with children, others are not. Some are prone to hip problems, while others are prone to ear infections. Some are prone to gastric problems, while while others have difficulty breathing. There are plenty of sites that you can find all of this information on. If you are going to get a puppy from a breeder, I would most certainly go and visit them. My chihuahua came from a home where the mother and father lived inside. They had their own room in an upstairs bedroom (kind of cute I thought). The owners were very kind, caring, and compassionate. We went to visit when the puppies were only 3 weeks old and brought a toy with us and left it there. When we brought the puppy home with us we also brought the toy so she would have the familiar scent of her previous home with her to help with the transition. Good luck and please remember, it makes no difference if it is a pure breed or a scraggly mutt, it is your responsibility to treat it well and care for it with gentle love.
1 person likes this
9 May 07
We had Jake (the GSD) from a puppy, not from a breeder I must add, and have had no problems with him. I just worry a little bit with not knowing past history on an adult dog, although I must admit that Max seems to be a very well adjusted fellow at the moment. He even lets us take toys away from him, my wife says I am cruel for doing this but I feel it earns trust between us and he does get them back almost immediately. I think that as long as a dog knows you can be trusted then half the battle is won when it comes to developing the relationship between you.
1 person likes this
@nicolec (2671)
• United States
8 May 07
There are so many unwanted dogs out there, that going to a shelter is the best way to give them the love they need. I don't like breeders. I just find it awefully materialistic and capitilistic to make money off two animals, well, you know what they do. It's not right. I'm sure I would get berated by any breeders. And I'm sure those dogs get lots of love to. But aren't there already enough dogs out there that need homes?
1 person likes this
• Canada
8 May 07
Well personally right now I would take anything! I am currently renting a house and I am not allowed any pets at all not even so much as a goldfish and before I have always had some kind of pet! My son all the time asks me for a puppy, but really though I would definately rescue a dog or any other animal before going to a breeder, thats how I got most of my previous pets. I had a puppy the owner was going to shoot simply becuase a mut got a hold of its pure bred and got her pregnant. I had a ferret that had been malnourished and exteremly neglected, I had baby squirrels it's mother had gotten into my parents ceiling and chewed big holes through the ceiling on the new addition causing lots of damage my stepfather being an animal lover live trapped the squirrel and removed it quite literally about 2 hrs away. Then baby squirrels started falling out the holes, he didn't know she had babies, I took 2 and had to feed them formula with a dropper then relocate them back to the woods it was so much fun but sad at the same time. There's been a lot of recued animals actually but I'm starting to ramble good luck with your new doggy.
9 May 07
Wow, it sounds like that if you went to a rescue home you would end up with ALL the dogs. My wife is the same, she was almost in tears when we left because we could only take one dog away and there were so many that deserve a loving home and it so difficult to turn your back on a needy animal. I do believe that having a dog in the house as a child teaches you responsibility for others and I hope that you and your son mangage to find a suitable pet soon as it sounds it will be in a very loving and caring environment.
@chrisken (85)
8 May 07
Good for you. There are so many dogs and cats that need homes. People should not be allowed to breed animals, there are far too many that end up in the streets through no fault of their own. I know when you get one from a breeder as a puppy you can train it better and know it's history but I have had dogs in the past and they both came from a rescue centre and made wonderful pets.
10 May 07
I can see that not many people are sticking up for the breeders and I have to agree that most of them do seem to be in it purely for the money. It does seem that Max has been trained and lived in a home before we rescued him by the way he has settled in so easily. I guess we have been very lucky with him, have heard horror stories from others about rescue dogs but I just feel that given time and love even the most nervous/aggresive/protective dog can become a great family pet.