If you know how to knit and crochet...

@bonbon50 (659)
United States
May 20, 2007 3:40pm CST
which do you find easiest to do? I've been crocheting for 30 years but every now and then I see a pattern I like that's knitted. I'm wondering if I should 'give it a go'. So for those of you who know how to do both, was one easier than the other for you to learn?
3 people like this
6 responses
@mamacathie (3928)
• United States
20 May 07
I hve been crocheting for 40 years and I am the same way. I see a pattern in knit that I think I'd like to do . I did knit a sweater for my daughter and she has never let me live it down. It had a few big holes in it. She wouldn't wear it. Since then I tell her I have found a pattern for her and it is knit. Immediately she said No thank you MOM! LOL I cannot get the hang of picking up a missed stitch. I am going to get the hang of it. It is good to get a discussion from you, bonbon.
2 people like this
• United States
24 May 07
I learned to crochet about 40 years ago, too, and have tried repeatedly in the last ten years or so to learn to knit. Without much success until recently. I find knitting to be a lot slower than crochet; the stitches just don't take up as much room per row. Knitting seems to be much more versatile, though. I can do plain knitting now but lace is beyond me. What helped me the most was learning how to knit in the continental style; the method of holding the yarn is more like crochet!
@bonbon50 (659)
• United States
24 May 07
That's one thing I wondered about; if I would get used to holding my thread one way and then have trouble switching between the two. I'll have to check into the continental style, thanks!
@RebeccaLynn (2256)
• United States
20 May 07
I do both but I prefer knitting. Crochet hurts my wrist after a while and you don't see results as quickly as you do with knit. Crochet has so many different stitches to remember and knit only has two. I still like crochet. There are patterns in crochet that you can not get with knit but I still prefer knit. Knit took me far less time to learn too. I bought a book called "10...20...30 minutes to knit" at Walmart for 7.00 and I was knitting a baby blanket before the weekend was over. I really enjoy knitting.
@bonbon50 (659)
• United States
20 May 07
Thanks, that's give me courage to forge ahead! I think I'll always like crocheting better for the reason you mentioned, more detail and variety. But knowing how to knit would be nice too. Maybe I'll try my hand at tatting if I master knitting-lol!
1 person likes this
• United States
20 May 07
Good luck with tatting! My hands just refuse to do it! It's probably the fibro but I have always thought tatting is beautiful! I have seen tatted tablecloths that had to have taken months and months to finish and I so admire people who have the patience to tatt! Knitting is easy to learn and easy on the hands so I know you'll be a success! Have fun with it!
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
6 Jun 07
I don't think one was easier than the other to learn. Picking up a dropped stitch in knitting is very similar to a single crochet stitch. The two are very similar, it just is a bit trciky to get used to different techniques.
@suscan (1955)
• United States
6 Jun 07
I have been crocheting for a long time, I never learned to knit. My Grandmother taught me to crochet but she did not like to knit. I learned to loom knit about a year a go and I love it. It is easy and fast.
@kamalila (193)
• United States
30 May 07
I suspect that you will do as I did. I learned crochet first, a long time ago. But, as you said, I kept finding patterns that I wanted to try, knitted. So, I bought a how-to book and taught myself to knit. I did eventually get the knack, but my stitches aren't quite as even (drives me nuts) as my crocheted stitches. Knitting IS better for creating images. I designed then knitted a blanket for my daughter. It had a pegasus in the middle. Some would say that switching the yarn to the other hand is more difficult. Perhaps. I'm somewhat ambidextrous, so that didn't bother me. What DID bother me was not having a hook. You use the tip of the needle instead. That's where stitches get dropped. From what I have seen, which you prefer often depends on which you started with. Knitters will swear by knitting. Same for crocheters. We can use both, but we are most comfortable with the one we learned first. Someday, maybe, I'll try tatting. My mother-in-law says you have to have a LOT of patience for that one.
1 person likes this