If you were a writer, would you give up your beliefs if your publisher told you

@saralee1 (1982)
United States
May 23, 2007 12:51am CST
write more secular? Would you do it for the money? to keep the job? for instance, you don't believe in abortion, yet you have to write an article in support of it? is this morally degrading?
3 people like this
9 responses
@mskzalameda (4023)
• Philippines
23 May 07
then I won't do it. I am a writer and a writer is bound to express and not to impress. If the publisher wants me to do something I don't want to do, then I'll tell him that call some writer that will do that for you for a writer can't be credible if he will write articles against his own will. you should know that for you are a publisher. I will defend my side and will make him realize some things in life. whatever happens, I wouldn't do it. :)
1 person likes this
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
23 May 07
well, me either. some things that are written though, are so outrageously crazy, I wonder if the publisher truly believes what they are writing. My cousin is a senior editor for a newspaper in AZ and has old me she has to do it all the time or risk losing her position. I was just wondering if this was commonplace, or just amongst the "allstars".(she is a Berkley grad) thank you for the opinion!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
23 May 07
you are welcome! I think we all need to fight for the right but some things like you said, are hard to fight for. If he can loose his job, its a different thing. Maybe he can find another one but it is a hard thing to do. It is also a hard thing to accept that you are writing false facts, these facts are contradicting your own feelings. If you are writing like that, I think the readers won't like to read your writings then. God Bless and let's pray for the soul of that publisher. :)
1 person likes this
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
23 May 07
Hi again! actually, it is pretty rampant right now in the US, or at least it was!Something about how the congress and the people gave all their power to the prez at one time, and nobody dared to utter a word against him, even receiving threats from FBI agents. It was hard times, hopefully they are over, and I prayto GOD that the American people NEVER hand over their freedom of speech to a loser President again!
1 person likes this
• India
24 May 07
I don't mind 'Reporting' that is giving the facts on any issue, for example if some religious cult is doing doing good work in the field of education or health or something then I don't mind reporting that. But I will never endorse something that I don't believe in.
1 person likes this
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
25 May 07
good point.But, I am beginning to think there is a fine line sometimes with your job, and your moral beliefs. unfortunately, many companies stomp on employees moral code of ethics, for instance,making them work on Sundays, or telling them to lie about a product, or to a customer.And, unfortunately, I am afraid when you work for a newspaper or magazine, indeed the editor edits your content, and what they will "ok" to write as well.
• Philippines
23 May 07
i will never do it. i will uphold my beliefs and my faith. i'd rather lose my job rather than cross whatever is it that i believe in. i will be steadfast in my faith. there are many ways of earning money. after all, man does not live by bread alone.
• Philippines
23 May 07
yes that's true! a human without his own principles will be like useless.
1 person likes this
@liranlgo (5752)
• Israel
23 May 07
i would never do that. I was working in the theatre and writing business, and there were times that they requested that i would change my conception, and i never agreed on doing that. Those are things that i believe in, and i would never change them because of money. They are who i am.
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
24 May 07
And, of course, I whole heartedly agree! the manipulation of a writers work is a crime. and forcing a writer to write a false belief is despicable.
@beaniegdi (1963)
24 May 07
I think that it would depend on your main motivation for writing, is it just as self expression and the pleasure of writing or is it to make a living from writing. If you intend to write for a living then straight away you are at the mercy of others as he who pays the piper picks the tune. However your analogy of the article on abortion would not happen as surely most people who want you to write an article on any subject would want it to be balanced and show more than one side or point of view. You would only be asked to write something that is fully in support of something like this if you had been commissioned to write some sort of propaganda leaflet. Not many published writers are writing what they truly want to as they have to write to suit the buying public and not themselves.
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
24 May 07
Well, for instance, the Mormons went on a campaign where they woul reach potential followers through movie scripts. thing is, they employed hollywood actors to "act" as mormons, and had given writers the basic points of what they wanted to tell in their storyline. these are not necessarily writing from the heart, you know? just business as usual in the Mormon church. I am sure these actors didn't convert to mormonism, neither did the writer of the script. haha!they just wanted the paycheck.
@Manoj_s (939)
• India
23 May 07
In fact this is happening in not only in the field of religious righting it is happening in all areas also .one has to right things which is not at all true out of threatining of losing job or receiving some reward .i think we all stick to truth there are lot of people who read things and belive it and it is going to affect in their daily life .if we have to keep our human values we may need to sacrifice even our jobs.i know easier said that done.how can one sleep properly after going against one's consciousness.
1 person likes this
@saralee1 (1982)
• United States
24 May 07
I can't agree with you more, or even how many bosses I have told to goto h---, (ahem) they weren't worth spit anyways.
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
23 May 07
..nah, I wouldn't do it.. guess I'm a writer and I have lots to say, if that's not what someone wants to read, I'm not going to write something else.. it just doesn't connect/compute... :))
1 person likes this
@stacyv81 (5903)
• United States
23 May 07
no way. Writing is a personal reflection of the writer. I would never compromise my stance on something, especially abortion for some human. I dont think so. Think about the people reading it. I mean, I wouldn't do it for the money, no matter how much. I think writing is something that although could possibly be shared with the world, it is still a personal matter. If you feel there is something you need to share with the world dont compromise or settle. I mean the money will be spent, but your beliefs will be everlasting!
1 person likes this
@rabanesd (284)
• United States
23 May 07
I believe that you should hold on to what you believe in. Never ever give up your faith for money. Do you know the story of Meshach, Shadrach, and Abednego? They too faced a decision about worshipping an idol that King Nebuchadnezzar told his people to worship. The three friends did not do as the King had commanded and they were thrown into a furnace as their punishment, but God saved them from being burnt. See, they are an example for you. Again, don't give up your beliefs and you will be rewarded. Hope you do what you believe.
1 person likes this