Who is the best of the three judges ?

India
June 12, 2007 1:04am CST
I think Javed Akhtar is the best judge. Even the anchor considers his opinion the most important and takes his comments at the end to maintain the suspense!
4 responses
dbhattji
@dbhattji (2506)
• India
12 Jun 07
A judge should not put down the singers, all the judges do that to someone or the other, but Alisha is the least critical so I find her the best.
cool614
@cool614 (53)
• India
13 Jun 07
i think she is the worst of the three for her, everybody's performance is excellent. other judges do not put down the singers, but they just say what they think and point out contestant's mistakes.
soumidattaiitd
@soumidattaiitd (75)
• India
13 Jun 07
well... can ve vote for two..?? i think udit narayan n javed akhtar are the best judges...they are very judgemental...n at the same time...take a bit of care so as to not hurt the bad singers...i really respect him for that...
bhawnam
@bhawnam (1436)
• India
12 Jun 07
even i think javed akhtar is the best judge as his judgement is not influenced by any other person or any other consideration.. whereas at time the judgements of other judges seem to be so stupid when they call a fabulous performance not good.. then Javed saab takes his stand and says out loud what he felt without thinking what others are saying.
adijam265
@adijam265 (769)
• India
12 Jun 07
i think all the judges except anu malik are reasonable, i also think that alisha chinai is the best judge, she has it in her to judge well,