Opinionated kids! Do kids really know what they want?

United States
June 13, 2007 9:47pm CST
Most times I let my little kid decide which movies she wants to watch, or even which clothes she wants to wear. In fact, she makes most of her own decisions. The only rule is that Mommy gets to decide on bedtime and matters of safety. Other than that, she's usually free to choose what she wants to do, as long as it's safe. This method might not work for every family. But, it works for us. I'd like to think that it's good preparation for life. My view is that kids need plenty of practice at decision making and lots of room to mess up, if they ever hope to mature into an independent adult. Otherwise they'll grow up, waiting to be told what to do next, instead of deciding for themselves. However, I know some moms who are just the opposite and don't let their kids have any say in the day to day decisions of their own lives. Some moms insist on dictating to their kids how and when things will be done. So, I was wondering, how do you handle this situation. Do you take your child's opinions as mere suggestions or give into their wishes trusting that they actually know what they want? Within limits, of course! How much authority do you give your children?
2 responses
@trk918 (254)
• United States
22 Jun 07
I've let both my kids make decisions & have an opinion. If you listen to them sometime they know better than you. Kids are smart but do need guidance. If they follow my rules then they get to do about anything they want within reason of course.
@makingpots (11915)
• United States
15 Jun 07
I believe in giving choices begining at a very early age. But I think that parents need to set limits on those choices by saying you can choose between these 3 movies or these 3 outfits, etc. Of course as they grow older these limits get loosened but I feel it is important to give those guidelines in the beginning.