school uniforms are up for debate yet again

Canada
June 18, 2007 3:15pm CST
As yet another another school year comes to a close our three public high local high schools are once again dealing with the serious issue of proper attire. The problem is so out of hand in out local middle school a note has gone home to parents stating no belly revealing shirts can be worn, no mini skirts or micro shorts, and tank tops and just clothing that is just more appropriate for a nightclub which many are years away from entering should be wearing.On the evening news the quick quip to make you make watch was watch the news to see why the school was bombarded with hundreds of calls from parents..of course the calls we positive, most parents are at the wits ends dealing with a child going out in such little clothing or hiding skimpy outfits under baggy sweats. So now the big talk is uniforms for September?Of course its been a long time debate. In a world where casual has become the chosen attire in professional settings, it appears that Casual Fridays began on Mondays in our public schools. T-shirts, jeans, shorts, sneakers, and sandals have become acceptable attire in the teaching profession So lets chat it out here's some pros and con's of uniforms let me know what you think??The Pros ... Eliminates opportunities for the ridicule of less popular or less fortunate students based on attire. Decreases theft and violence - even life-threatening situations- among students over designer clothing or expensive sneakers. Helping prevent gang members from wearing gang colors and insignia at school. Instilling students with discipline. Helping parents and students resist peer pressure. Helping students concentrate on their school work. helping school officials recognize intruders who come to school Cons Self Expression Many educators and sociology experts believe that requiring children to wear standardized uniforms stifles their self-expression. Self-expression is an important part of child development and some experts believe that curbing it with uniforms can be detrimental to a child. Experts also believe that students who are forced to wear uniforms will only find other, less appropriate ways to express themselves, possibly through inappropriate use of makeup and jewelry. Individuality Some experts believe that public education attempts to strip children of their individuality. They believe that public education does not meet the needs of children who do not fall in the norm, and that uniforms attempt to force every student into one mold. They see standard dress as another way for public educators to remove student individuality where they should be embracing and celebrating diversity. Some experts believe it is not in the best interest of the child to try to control socialization which is a part of human nature. They believe that such use of school uniforms does not prepare children from the real world in which they will continue to be judged by appearances. Cost There are just as many experts who believe that the cost of school uniforms is a negative factor as those who see it as a positive factor. Some experts believe that it increases the amount of clothing parents will have to buy for their children because the children will still want and need clothing for the hours they are not in school. Uniforms can be more expensive for a family who buys from second-hand stores or who relies on hand-me-down clothing from friends and family. Some experts believe cost is a negative aspect of school uniforms because there is no use for them outside of school. Comfort Many experts argue that different types of clothing feel comfortable to different people. Some children are more comfortable in a specific material or style of clothing. Uniforms reduce one’s ability to choose clothing that fits individual comfort needs. Experts believe that children need to feel comfortable in order to maximize learning, and that uniforms can therefore deter academic success. Pros are not Pros Many educators and experts believe that, although in theory uniforms should improve academic, behavioral, and social outcomes, in reality they do not. These experts argue that the studies of schools who initiate uniforms do not report improvement in any of these areas; therefore, if the desired outcomes are not reached, there is no valid reason to standardize student dress. PS personally I think we have the right to choice what we wear within the rules of a dress code. I know that might be a confusing statement but i mean you can wear a tshirt not half of one lol. I like my own personal style a uniform seems to take something away from a person. just my opinion of course Cheryl
3 people like this
8 responses
@wolfie34 (26771)
• United Kingdom
18 Jun 07
Personally in this age where bullying is rife, school uniforms need to be KEPT! Otherwise kids will go in with the latest Nike or FCUK stuff and those that have parents who cannot afford to keep up with the ever changing fashion will be open to being bullied because they don't wear the right trainers or the right hoodie. Secondly when kids are misbehaving they are more easier identifiable with their uniforms on and it makes them less likely to cause trouble than if they are in unindentifiable clothing, not relating to any school. Well that's my two cents worse anyhow. Uniform has to stay!!
2 people like this
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
18 Jun 07
Now a days, people don't care who is wearing NIKE or GAP! I see nothing of the sort at my daughters school. And if that is the case, then maybe the school should step up and put a stop to bullying. And how is it more identifiable to wear a uniform? I'm lost on that one. Do uniforms have numbers on them? Like an immate? That's a little off the wall.
1 person likes this
@wolfie34 (26771)
• United Kingdom
18 Jun 07
Because uniforms in Britain have the name of the school imprinted on them, like a logo with the school name on them!
1 person likes this
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
18 Jun 07
That still doesn't help any.
2 people like this
@raychill (6525)
• United States
18 Jun 07
I think uniforms are ridiculous. It makes sense...but it's ridiculous. It takes away your right to be your own person and if you want to wear different clothes you should be allowed to. Of course in that same respect people can offend others in dress or dress inappropriately. The uniforms make everyone equal in clothes... but not equal anywhere else. I think a dress code is the best middle ground. Let kids have their own style and choice and not be forced to conform to one look, but make kids also dress within a line of rules. My high school was a magnet technology school. We had a dress code. No shorts was the biggest rule on the dress code. No spaghetti strap shirts. Skirts and dresses had to be so long. clothes could not be ripped and torn and ratty or filled with holes. T-shirts could not be offensive...etc. Dress Codes I think is the best middle ground.
1 person likes this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
I think your response is great and I agree 100% I think it is the only way everyone involved can be somewhat happy. I mean it is crazy what teachers face and parents are at the wits end. Kids want there right to choose and all we end up with is kaos. I agree the uniform is a little uptight but as i have read in the upcoming comments in many countries in as been the norm for years and works great. I think here in Canada and the US we are a little lax in dress codes for school. But you have to agree it does eliminate a lot of issues and levels the field . thanks so much for commenting Cheryl
@raychill (6525)
• United States
19 Jun 07
Thank you. I definitely think School Uniforms are also one of those subjects that will always be up for debate. There also is really no right or wrong and you've gotta live with whatever decision is eventually made I guess. I'm just glad I'm not in school and I don't yet have kids to deal with it.
@emisle (3822)
• Ireland
19 Jun 07
In Ireland every high school has a uniform as far as I know. Even though students may not have been too fond of this, at least you didn't have to decide what you were wearing everyday! And there wasn't any competition between students fashion wise. People say that it takes away from a person's individuality, but the person's personality will still come through, and in my year everyone would have seen each other out and about and so would know what everyone's style was...though in the US schools are much much bigger and I think the competition etc would be worse.
1 person likes this
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
18 Jun 07
I think it should be the kids choice. And I don't mean have the kid pick out something that isn't against school dress code, but something of their own that they can wear that is dress code. I was never really into the whole uniform thing. But if it was to happen with my kids. I would deal with it, I guess.
1 person likes this
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
18 Jun 07
I goofed... Here is what I meant to say: "And I don't mean have the kid pick out something that IS against school dress code, but something of their own that they can wear that is dress code acceptable.
• Canada
19 Jun 07
I think that is a good compromise . I went to an all girl catholic school so dressing sexy and even wearing makeup wasn't soemthing many of us girls did it was our chance to wear sweat and ponytails lol. thanks for responding Cheryl
@jennybianca (12912)
• Australia
19 Jun 07
We went through this debate on school uniforms many years ago. At the time I was a primary school teacher so was heavily involved with the issue. I favour school uniforms. It can less expensive; it is smart; it identifies the school to which individuals belong, it eliminates competition regarding clothes & it reduces exposure to revealing clothes. At my daughters primary schoool the uniform was basic & cheap. Second hand clothes for 50c were available. At her high school, the uniform is a lot more expensive. If you buy the right size, it it can last two years. Her uniform is very smart. They have variety with the uniform so the students still feel they have some choice. Shoes are strictly limited to plain black. Nothing else. I am going to look at your other responses to see what other people are saying.
• Canada
19 Jun 07
first of all so great to see you and I can't wait to go read your stuff lol. now thanks so much for your insight on uniforms. I do see the benefits of uniforms and i think the would solve the problem that is at hand right now. You have been through the issue at a much closer level and showed me how it can work which is much this forum is for thanks so much hon hugs Cheryl
@Nardz13 (5055)
• New Zealand
18 Jun 07
Hey. School uniforms, all I have to say on this one is; I wish they had school uniforms here in my childrens school. They use to when I went to school and this is the same school, but now for some silly reason they dont. And now Im a mother Im washing clothes more frequently, because my kids are changing everday...
1 person likes this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
that's a very good point to bring up too lol and I sympathize . I wore a uniform in middle school and my mom loved it she washed my blouse everyday but my jumper got hung up the minute i got home and got done once a week. We had 3 jumpers and 3 skirts and 3 blouses I think, it's a long time since middle school lol thanks for writing in Cheryl
• India
19 Jun 07
School uniforms are must. It is a symbol of decipline. This helps in building up unity among students. Thats what I think.
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Jun 07
As a teenager in high school, who has gone to both uniform and non uniform schools, I would definitely not mind having to wear a uniform again. Having a uniform saves you a lot of time not having to decide what to wear in the morning.
1 person likes this